Showing posts with label UCLA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label UCLA. Show all posts

Friday, September 6, 2019

Peeping above the trench


How I Won the War Movie Review (1968) | Roger Ebert

I figure a year on, I'll keep my blog card raised tentatively. I've chosen for reasons of reticence and privacy to retreat from publicly proclaiming my every thought and opinion. Risks of generating "outrage" now imply this caution from many of us in less than secure employment (all those jobs created--nobody ever asks how many are side gigs, hustles or part-time work cobbled together or to supplement a precarious full-time position). Even if I had tenure somewhere, that does not guarantee safe passage across troubled SJW waters.

One of my most thoughtful charges observed the other day how 'we'd never have gotten to talk like this in a CalState class. We get to hear each other out, and while I suspect the prof's leanings, he never tilted us one way or the other. He always came up with a countering idea.'

This was praise indeed. That may be a perk of my predicament. Still, I proceed with caution. What used to be between four walls now has a recording angel or printer's devil, invisibly tuning in. The marvels of efficiency and increased productivity accrue, as do the human efforts assigned. Sure, I can teach from anywhere and so my students log in too in pajamas. But we still have only so many hours, and the days never expand to accommodate this pace.

More than one drudge I know in the muddy mire of academia at its basic level of labor rather than leisure as the primary mover has chosen survival tactics. The costs of censorship of ourselves presage Orwellian immanence when our mind is our only safe space. Not sure how long that long-baffling mystery within our membrane will survive jamming, hacking, and 'targeted' advertisement. As I write, A.I. cameras meant for, natch, warning the rest of us against the bad guys packing are touted, for the same device, to recognize big spenders.

As the faithful devoted to CasaMurphy know, my removal from engagement with the constant TDS-emitting transmissions upstairs from my lair lead to their own tangle of remarks, so this entry will be a politically-neutral or neutered zone, to defuse explosions. I feel the need to retreat, like perhaps John the smart sarcastic Beatle above, from the fray. My psychic wellness needs self-care as I guess a new ager might phrase it. I have enough social contact on my long commutes (and I thought I'd never have to suffer the 5 freeway again or cross the Orange County line) and my necessary attention to hundreds of people.

If you are reading this, thanks. I will likely never return to the frenetic every (or later other) day pace I reached years ago when I had more leisure for reflection, rambling, ranting, and reviewing. Amazon cut back any benefit to appearing in the firmament unless one acquired tons of material from them to be a 'verified' purchaser. Else, one's reviews sink down into the depths of the reviews, never to be seen except to the scuba divers among the few curious.

However, I reckon looking out from my increasingly keyboard tethered perch may not be so bad. I teach incessantly online more than in person, or combinations thereof, so my own life has been overtaken due to necessity with course commitments which demand my prompt, and seven-day attention. If I beg off a day, I have managerial queries emitting virtual steam, student appeals and plangent cries filling my message slot and e-mail inbox from multiple modalities. Education-speak for cameras that enable us to reach more of you than ever before. 'Scaling' comes with a prof as a thumbnail talking head, so hoodie or scantily-clad undergrads for all I know populate my invisible or rarely seen cohorts out there in cyberia.

This access also lowers costs. Not for those enrolled but for those overseeing at the rarified levels of capital human or otherwise who dictate our fates, at least as living paycheck to paycheck. Courses may double or triple in size, without in certain cases any compensation added. The pace of eight-week terms, the rapid turnaround of grades and evaluations of written (not multiple-choice autograded) submissions by those coming to my curricula with little or no preparation for the humanities--understandably as I have no liberal arts majors--has challenged me for a long time, sure, but the former alternation I had between large online enrollments and intimate onsite courses has, thanks to the Webcam and PC recorder, vanished. Now, any class can be, well, as large as 'they' want it to be, and this shows no signs of reversal. Once the tech's in place, the hands assigned adapt to the Fordist assembly line.

I hear all around on the news the desperation of those hiring for hired hands. Not in my line of work. It's always been dismal, since I went 'on the market' but the STEM takeover of the undergraduate direction, the staggering loans, and the denigrated state of the pursuits befitting the 'free men of a privileged class' among the ancients attests to the fall from grace.

As to that elusive gift from above, I have been searching myself for meaning. I keep this to myself, additionally, on a need to know basis, as this inner and outer 'journey' (a word which has been appropriated for Life Itself) takes me in directions dark and unsettling as well as bright. The second half of our expected actuarially determined span turns many of us thus. It's an often caricatured and misunderstood quest. Yet some of you out there know it well. 

Therefore, I seek solace after dinner, when I switch off my connections to the work world, even if I confess my Kindle may turn on for bookish pursuits and my endless amassing of more books to read on my varied public library wishlists. I heard recently a younger professor whom I greatly admire is leaving a post that any humanist would do the proverbial die for. When younger, I'd regard this as nearly unfathomable, but even then I'd recall a fellow grad TA at UCLA recall his watching an older prof, one of those who sauntered postwar into a niche when even ABDs were snapped up by the desperate institutions flush with Cold War and Space Age funds, drink from a mug. My colleague thought it was coffee. Somehow he found out that the prof was sipping from a big lug of Maalox. Tenure track. 

Wednesday, May 13, 2015

What's a Professor to Do?


A former doctoral classmate, a few years ahead of me at our alma mater, now teaches at Emory. He was one of the stars of the English Ph.D. program then, and it's no wonder he has continued as a commentator as well as critic of the system that has shifted, as younger generations seek cash back rather than wisdom accrued. His essay in Sunday's New York Times ranks #1 for "most e-mailed." He looks back to when students emulated professors, and they held them in awe. He was one of them, as was I. He reflects: "I saw the same thing in my time at the University of California, Los Angeles, in the early 1980s, when you couldn’t walk down the row of faculty offices without stepping over the outstretched legs of English majors lining up for consultations. First-year classes could be as large as 400, but by junior year you settled into a field and got to know a few professors well enough to chat with them regularly, and at length. We knew, and they knew, that these moments were the heart of liberal education."

His op-ed piece asks: "What's the Point of Being a Professor?" As face-time shrinks, the utilitarian function of professors grows. That's all we're good for, and in an era where not 18% as in 1960 but 43% of students earn an "A," why complain? Only 8% of students frequently hear “negative feedback about their academic work;" 61% report in a national survey he cites that their profs treat them as colleagues or as peers. I think of my older son's new alma mater, where all are on first-name basis.

I find it odd that the writer does not mention the related shift away from the four courses, two in Shakespeare, one Milton, one Chaucer, that distinguished English majors there until recently. In the Wall Street Journal, Heather Mac Donald asked if UCLA's humanities had forgotten their humanity. My former classmate at my M.A. program in Claremont told me that only four out of 52 colleges surveyed now require Shakespeare, which at my undergrad program was required for all in English. What replaced them at UCLA are courses in gender, race, and theory. I have no objection to these. But they fail to ground undergrads in literary tradition, which they can then challenge all they like.

He continues: "I returned to U.C.L.A. on a mild afternoon in February and found the hallways quiet and dim. Dozens of 20-year-olds strolled and chattered on the quad outside, but in the English department, only one in eight doors was open, and barely a half dozen of the department’s 1,400 majors waited for a chance to speak." When I was in Rolfe Hall, I don't recall the hordes my colleague did, but I did wait slumped on the linoleum outside an office, waiting my turn, in a time when we all carried enormous backpacks full of texts and notebooks, and kept slumped, reading on. I never developed a close relationship with any of my professors, keeping them at a distance in college and since, but I did get to house-sit a week for one of my diss. advisers when he went on vacation. I never addressed him or others on my committee as other than "Professor"-X, out of respect and habit.

I assume at my both my sons' colleges, that has changed. Perhaps as when children call parents of their friends by their first names, a lurch into informality that missed me, as discipline gave way to permissiveness outside my own circle. Now, in a career-driven mindset, the liberal arts, for the few still taking it. UCLA continues to have a very large English department compared to many of its sister institutions, as a proud "public Ivy." My fellow graduate avers: "When college is more about career than ideas, when paycheck matters more than wisdom, the role of professors changes. We may be 50-year-olds at the front of the room with decades of reading, writing, travel, archives or labs under our belts, with 80 courses taught, but students don’t lie in bed mulling over what we said. They have no urge to become disciples." I assume he's closer to 60 than 50 by now, but the truth holds here.

With a bit of an emendation. I don't lord my august presence over my charges. Unlike those at elite institutions such as UCLA and Emory, my students are often vets, single moms, middle-aged folks downsized or out of a job, immigrants and first-generation strivers not attending college on the largess of well-off relatives or families abroad. I work with them, and I struggle--teaching a snippet of Greek culture or Impressionist art in one course, the Industrial Revolution and Neolithic progress in another. They sit, at night, tired out from days that may begin before dawn. I try my best, again. 

Often in this blog I remark if in somewhat occluded fashion about my own career. I've taught, thanks to adjunct and grad school work, far more than 80 courses. My full-time gig of nearly twenty years went from three 15-week terms of five courses each to eight-week terms averaging three courses, so I quail at doing the math. All I know is I've had some courses dozens and dozens of times by now. But I tinker with them, they get updated, and I update. One on technological culture from a humanities perspective has warped and woofed myriad ways since I started it in '97, while I teach Shakespeare somehow in less dramatic changes as I sneak a bit of the Bard into two weeks of an intro to lit class. 

My students are different from those my near-peer teaches. They can enter with a GED. They enroll for practical reasons rather than philosophical ones. A new marketing campaign addresses those who aren't trying to "find" themselves, but who already know what they want and how to get it is a degree. Still, last term, on a printout for submission online of a student's teaching evaluation, by whose scores we are rated in turn by deans, I did see "Best Proffesor Ever!" in ballpoint on a verification form.

Tuesday, June 26, 2012

On the Road with Ruin

While The Road to Ruin was the second LP from the Ramones, another punk band, in the next decade, provided music as punchy as the New York suburban kids but with a considerably heftier lyrical and spiritual impact. Philadelphia's quintet wove a Buddhist message within an artistic tapestry enmeshed into hardcore. My first post about Ruin juxtaposed their stance in the '80s with how guitarist-founder Glenn Wallis has moved along an increasingly unsparing interrogation of what we call the buddha-dharma, which recently he dubs Speculative Non-Buddhism. Today's entry looks not at (x-)Buddhism's "shell game," but the now-Dr. Wallis' band's sonic outreach. These paired posts reveal what I've been unable to find much of elsewhere online: how Buddhism and punk ignite.

We first hear Ruin's path to dharma in 1982's flexi-disc singles "Twilight" and "Phenomenal Expression" in Terminal! Magazine. These sound, as flexies did, as if their hometown Flyers used them for pucks. Still, you notice why Ruin stood out even them. This pair reminds me of Husker Du's early singles before they signed with SST. The latter song of Ruin is short even by punk standards: 45 seconds of atomic meltdown. As the titles hint, there's a gleam amid the gloom. The glimmers of melody and lyrical insight may elude casual listeners, but both bands hint at maturity within hardcore's slamming compression.

1983 found the band with two songs on Get off My Back: A Philly Hardcore Compilation. These cannot be found online, so I cannot comment on "Love Dog" or "Proof" in its first version. Still, from hearing it later on 1985's "White Rabbit" promo demo cassette, it's easy to understand why "Proof" was re-recorded twice more. It focuses their sound more intensely, and the hardcore expectations of barked vocals and hammered delivery are seasoned with mood shifts and starts and stops. It's a more physical song, and this helps. There's a splendid video of the band bobbing heads in unison around their drummer (not sure if it was Richard Hutchins, or Pete Della Pelle who replaced him), as they unite in generous obeisance to their common cause. The love they share for their music can be felt.

The previous year, their first LP, He Ho, appeared. I wish I could review this as it was meant to be received, but I can only reconstruct most of this from equivalent live tapes at XPN radio and a St. Mary's 1997 concert, both available via Freedom Has No Bounds. As a band interview at The Worst Horse Buddhist pop-culture site documents, this album was primitive compared to what they wanted to get down on tape. "Rule Worshiper" stands out most. As it's the only one I can access on both a Fiat Lux studio and remastered version, it appears that this song on its reissue on the long-deleted 1996 anthology Songs of Ruin and Reverie has been edited into a sudden fadeout, which hones the power of this sharply defined attack on the titular fealty.

For me, the songs (I'm handicapped by live versions and not studio ones) hold up by the standards of what must have been a no-budget, mid-80s tiny indie release. Taking up Leonard Cohen's "Master Song" and the Rolling Stones' "Play with Fire" demonstrates Ruin's proverbial range of influences beyond the MC5, Stooges, Clash, Ramones, and Motorhead nods their "Worst Horse" interview credits. Commendable as such touchstones remain, I'm enticed by a subtly artsier side that appears to bury the jackhammer patterns of the Buzzcocks within the staccato tempos of Wire--these may reflect what I want to hear; these two endure as my own exemplars of how punk could challenge its formula.

Unlike the musicians in the previous paragraph (even if some albums had to be burrowed out from imports six thousand miles away in very few stores), Ruin might never stay on a road, at least on a blacktop far enough west closer to me. Given the smoke signals and rattle patter of what passed for communicating the appeal of what could remain very regional music back then--as the pages of Touch& Go (anthology reviewed by me) display for '79-'83 (oddly overlapping my undergrad years)--the welcome a band received in its hometown might be utterly unknown a state away.

My hometown band X sung about this as the "unheard music." Bob Mould in his recent See A Little Light (memoir reviewed by me) movingly tells of how the Huskers moved from town to town, setting up a presence, sleeping on couches, talking to the local college radio station perhaps (I worked at mine, KXLU), and seeking out like-minded outliers, the kids who hung out in record stores, who read existentialism, who didn't fit in. I'd like to think Ruin attracted some of the same, across the continent from where SST came to dominate the local L.A./O.C. scene, as hereabouts hardcore became, well...

Nick Rombes wrote well a few years ago about punk's rapid implosion from 1974-'82. I note that T&G and Professor Rombes' own A Cultural Dictionary of Punk (reviewed by me) nearly coincide with their terminus. Ruin, however, crafted its blend starting when critics and listeners like me (and Rombes perhaps as a contemporary) had pushed away as sour whatever artistic integrity had curdled into punk conformity. The Minutemen and Huskers (for me the most visible, as they shifted to SST and could be found gigging around here and their records could be bought) expanded their horizon of what punk could mean less as the corrosion of conformity and more as personal liberation.

This draws me back to Ruin's coming-of-age. By the mid-'80s, Ruin had taken what few punks took seriously--a path to freedom along lines of transformation less by political or gender confrontation, more by a religiously faithful path. I'd heard vaguely a few punks had found Krishna, as Eleanor Henderson's recent novel Ten Thousand Saints (reviewed by me) dramatizes in the second term of Reagan. But nobody I listened to or talked to tried to align a spiritual search with a musical one. My encounters with the world of the intellect, like my musical forays, were largely solitary, autodidact. So, I used to wonder, as I took on the tensions and aspirations comprising my own Irish Catholic upbringing during this uneasy time, how the music I played could show me literary and personal role models, guides out of my own confusion. Music had started this for me, long before I found the Mekons annotated their vinyl and the Crass anthology I'd bravely sought out filled its paper sleeves.

It's difficult to know if listeners could make out paeans to dharma anymore than anarchists memorized what Brits shouted out in angry spatter, or Americans chanted in hoarse cries. On vinyl or in concert, without a lyric sheet committed to rote recall, I was often left clueless about the "message" as the "medium" blasted my admittedly fragile ears, so much I (carless anyway, riding my bike around, taking the bus, bumming rides, the thin kid on grants and fellowships, worried more about a GPA and passing scrutiny than scoring tickets) rarely went to shows, and ruined my hearing cranking up headphones in a grad school dorm or a rented apartment, dissertation looming, qualifying/ language/ oral exams over me, a personal life careening into an unwisely chosen relationship amidst a climate of economic straits, ideological rants, and the hothouse climate of doctoral programs in literature, obsessed with nouveaux French varietals. Meanwhile I tackled Old and Middle English, Shakespeare, Milton, Richardson, Eliots, Joyce, Beckett, and this year's model of impenetrable, translated, thick theorists vs. close readings of verse. Teaching remedial or frosh comp, grading blue books, dealing with pampered and/or poorly-prepped undergrads often left me nearly response-less as a weary reader, with always more to pick up by my desk, on the bus, in my apartment or co-op bed.

I include my own encounter, as (post-)punk played steadily during this decade. Grad school began with British Marxists and post-structuralist myth; Jacobeans and "ordinary language philosophy" in less than everyday prose. Ten years earlier, I had to leave the town where I'd been happiest, when my parents moved. As part of my childhood was spent happily wandering the blasted heaths and scrubby chaparral around what would be the final lemon groves in the county, I lamented what I'd come back to. First draft of this blog entry, I was reviewing Hari Kunzru's Gods Without Men. Early on, Nicky, as dissolute English rocker, flees the pressure to perform in the Westside manse-studio. He drives out past where I was raised, oddly at my cheeriest as a boy, if pale in smog and heat. I lived north of the last town in L.A. County on the border of the nation's largest county, arid east way past the Eastside.

"LA faded into a thankless dead landscape. You couldn't call it a desert, really. It was waste ground, the city's backyard, a dump for all the ugly things it didn't want to look at." (26) Yet amid the "valley of the dirt people," as the Inland Empire's denigrated, before millions filled tracts and big-box malls full of junk from the warehouses there that distribute junk from the ports which comes from China, I found it pleased me to explore once dusty spaces. We all love where we dreamed, the music we first heard--even if 93 KHJ Boss Radio and "White Rabbit" over and over, more than "Play with Fire." For me a jackrabbit was a glimpse, a coyote a fact, a smudgepot the winter night's heavy orchard scent.

Now, I returned, staying but half-a-mile from where I'd grown up, to begin my program in English literature. A small fan blew. I studied Gawain as the local college station played the Dead Kennedys and the temperature hit 108 outside in Claremont and my rented room was where I paced and typed and translated, my fingers staining the pages with sweat. The English Civil War boomed again within the small print of one of many used Penguins, next to my Pearl. The clock radio transmitted whatever eclectic playlists the local d.j.'s played, often under an influence. A year later, M.A. in hand, I was off to UCLA. Living at the once-Paul Robeson socialist, now overtaken by Chinese grad students, ramshackle co-op, the weather eased, the climate changed. In Orwell's year come to pass, a Ph.D. hovered, a Grail for my medievalist-modernist self, seeking meaning between glosses and footnotes.

Meanwhile, what was Ruin up to? The Philly punk archive Freedom Has No Bounds takes its name from a Ruin lyric; find them all at the link via the band's website. In this already long article I will spare you the English major's exegesis of particular songs, but check at "Freedom" for how Ruin covers a song I long ago (the age of, what, six, seven?) tired of from endless AM let alone FM radio blare, "White Rabbit." Lysergic swirl fits Ruin's embrace of letting their songs lag and roam, away from hardcore's hurry into more guitar solos (brief, I assure you) by Glenn and his brother Damon. "Proof" from the promo cassette sounds as if the Flyers skated on it, and "Life After Life" suffers from a noise annoys production on an understandably lo-fi format, long before such became hip.

On the video stream embedded on the band's website, Vosco Thomas Adams' vocals resemble the DK's Jello Biafra; Ruin gravitates towards lurching and swaying on much of 1986's Fiat Lux. Small world: as I started UCLA, a guy I met the first night told me he'd dated Jello's sister. As with the Dead Kennedys, earnest bands wearied of packaging intelligent commentary within restrictive structures. If punk--political or spiritual--meant to encourage us towards freedom, how could it pressure us, as hearers, concertgoers, fans, to conform to a mohawked, leather-jacketed identikit?

To its credit, Ruin realized this impasse on its own road. Last Days of Man on Earth offers (links to other Ruin songs on this side are sadly as of this writing dead; everything's out-of-print in this impermanent realm) a portal to hear this band's best work. It's preceded at "Last Days" by what may be (given the limits of retrieval) my favorite song of theirs, the single "By the By." Catchier, as if Pere Ubu's electronic squeals warped into Vosco's muffled, stomped-on, muttered staccato as it alternates with more-Jelloish bellow. The postpunk, edgier, nagging riff merits applause, and the band charges forward in an unpredictable, call-and-response tune that I play over and over. Mission of Burma, as I noted in my previous review, comes to mind as a parallel for where Ruin roamed next.

As for this and the album that followed, their recordings, even altered into a digitally compromised state through files to laptop to headphones, open up far more the melodic vision the band found to expand their consciousness on their second full-length record. I detect hints of Misfits and Motorhead, maybe a bit of Minutemen. I'm biased towards bass, and I sense more seeps up from the mix of Cordy Swope's playing in the later work by his band, which seeks a hard rock, less punk orientation paralleling the move of many "college rock" ensembles during that pre-grunge decade.

While rapid in time, Fiat Lux slows in space. They push into wider terrain, eager to play off textures and voices that swoop in and draw back. The approach favors intensity, but akin sometimes to mainstream rock in its decision to ease up on hardcore habits and to embrace accessible if still rushed and loud sounds. "Hero" was covered a decade later by Superchunk and this up-tempo anthem's well matched to the latter group, who (two songs by the Verlaines!) know good music, along with equally attentive devotees Yo La Tengo. Here's hoping Hoboken's trio considers Ruin on their next album--for all I don't know, YLT may have played a song in one of their audience-request concerts.

I wonder if YLT during their annual Hanukkah charity concerts (see my bio review) has paid tribute to Cohen's "Famous Blue Raincoat"? Ruin delivers a solid version, and for me, being vaguely familiar with the surprising hit (at least in what used to pass as alternative radio) of Jennifer Warnes way back around the late '80s of this song, I liked hearing Ruin's assertive response to its sensitive but defiant declamations. "Proof" gets a third try, but the file on "Last" does not include this as far as I can tell; the numbered tracks appear one shy of the discography via the band's website. I would have liked to hear this in a better-than-hockey puck material manifestation of its metaphysical teaching.

Side two of Fiat Lux opens with the lighter (if barely) tone of "China," with a chorus of "dig a hole" and what may be a piano imitating a "Chopsticks"-type progression. It's refreshing to find the band allowing some humor coming into what can be a fierce, committed mode of delivering an uncompromising mission. The lyrics page shows their mindset, and it's maturing into doubt. Their eponymous song "Ruin" finds Vosco growling his band's name, and this harsher reproach balances nods, as with an inclusion of "White Rabbit," towards a broader appeal. "Great Divide" returns to a more hard rock place, and the Stooges' "Real Good Time" hastens the LP to its close in a more partying mood than the philosophical content of the bulk of this album hastening enlightenment.

A 1997 reunion after a decade's disbanding finds the band opening a live concert with a propulsive instrumental that's one of their best songs. Rings for weeks in my head. You can hear it via Ruin's Soundlift sampler page. It reminds me of a less histrionic Killing Joke riff entangled with the confident clanging exuberance of industrialized, gritty, barking Wire in their early '00s incarnation.

So, that's Ruin on records' road. I wonder what a producer like Steve Albini or Bob Weston could have done with their talent. Link to the Buddhist entry previously posted on my blog for more overlap and excursions into the band's ideological and phenomenological shakeups--especially from the band's founding member, Glenn Wallis.  Earlier this month, one year on at S N-B, he explained:

Really, this project is an extension of Ruin. I have dropped hints about it all over the site. I also have lots of veiled references to punk rock and rock n’roll in all four of my books. I always told my bandmates: “this has nothing to do with music!” The punKoan, then, is: with what does it have to do?

I invite you to find out more, as I do. I commend them for their ambition, and I await (perhaps without fulfillment in this incarnation) a pristine presentation of what they sounded like on records.

I suppose shortcomings contain their own moral. A lesson learned--we seek a sound and a pleasure that eludes our grasp. While I lament the absence of CDs and the demise of an anthology that from the few songs I can find appears to noticeably sweeten the sound and force open its dimensions, the links above enable you to brave the entrance and meet the band's invitation to reorient your life (as I mark another anniversary/ birthday-week among my family and dearest friends up north, who all love raucous music, if not the same bands!) around a band that could be your life--if a life lived depends on waking up to another outlook, stance, defiant possibility for "phenomenal expression."

[Photo c/o "Worst Horse" of Ruin "with sparklers": Damon left, stage diver center, Glenn right.]

Friday, May 13, 2011

Christopher Newfield's "The Unmaking of the Public University": Book Review

Has the American right-wing conspired to take down state universities? Does a “multiracial, worker-inclusive majority” benefiting from higher education that is funded by taxpayers threaten conservative politicians and corporate managers? The author of Unmaking the Public University: The Forty-Year Assault on the Middle Class, a University of California, Santa Barbara, professor of English, argues that the past 25 years of advances by a “college-educated economic majority” threaten the establishment. Christopher Newfield, who came up through California’s once-vibrant university system to achieve tenure at one of its respected campuses, reports from his own research with faculty committees on a “roundabout weapon” which the reactionary culture warriors bent on taking down the “mass middle class” have brandished to disenfranchise a restive, assertive, and diverse majority.

This lengthy study follows Newfield’s Ivy and Industry as a history of what happens when humanists meet industrial (and now post-industrial) knowledge managers and technocrats. As markets and profits demanded increasing attention in the ‘80s, the humanities faltered. Business schools, defense grants, marketing opportunities—spurred by shifts from factories to information—asserted their power over universities. These turned “privatized knowledge factories” as public funding dipped. For Newfield’s argument, this shift represents an oblique strategy by the Right to undermine a class-based, earnest, insurgent cadre determined to replace “traditional business values” with an alliance of students turned managers and leaders, schooled in the civil rights movement and anti-authoritarian attitudes.

Part One, “The Meaning of a Majoritarian Society”, analyzes this challenge. “Inventing PC: The War on Equality” presents the conflict of “political correctness” in the late 20th century “culture wars”. Those angered at diversity are determined to resegregate student bodies along class and racial lines—which recalls the stratifications of earlier decades. We now see “Market Substitutes for General Development” studies, industry-collegiate links, donor reliance, and the weakening of English departments. Funding favored technological fields as public money and political support declined for the radicalized liberal arts and social sciences. Finally, “The New War—and After” brings the transfer of power into the past decade, when what Newfield interprets as “poor data poorly interpreted” exaggerated the post-9/11 dangers of “subversive faculty” and assumed radical bias.

Allow my autobiographical digression. I’m also a Dodger fan from Newfield’s generation and hometown; I’m from a blue-collar family that our state’s postwar UC Master Plan was meant to assist as I pursued my own higher education at a “public Ivy” campus with a world-renowned reputation. I attended a sister campus to Newfield’s UCSB, down the coast at UCLA in the late ‘80s and early ‘90s. I taught six years (the limit) at UCLA as a teaching assistant, and then in Los Angeles public schools, as I finished my doctorate in English literature. I have taught since then at a non-public (but “minimally selective”) institution serving mainly immigrant and first-generation Southern Californian students from largely non-traditional backgrounds, albeit often older than a typical UC undergraduate. My students represent a pragmatic cohort often less academically prepared but arguably more career-focused than some UC liberal-arts majors.

Chapter 9 of Part III, “English’s Market Retreat”, scrutinizes the literary and cultural study (LCS) field. Newfield and I attended graduate school during the post-1970 collapse of lifelong job opportunities for English PhDs. As jobs increased for non-tenure track applicants like me, jobs decreased for tenure hires like him. English departments responded to this “contingent” or adjunct (and less often, full-time without tenure) trend in a hesitant manner. Humanists denounced the labor shift; then they adapted it.

The Modern Language Association (MLA) failed to offer practical reforms.  A 2001-2001 MLA analysis of the LCS job market defended “oversupply” as the norm. Fatalism, the public’s growing sense that the humanities lacked utility, and demands for required composition rather than LCS courses all weakened humanists, who tended to resist commercialism. They resented downsizing, while budgets shifted expenses through a reliance on teaching assistants and “visiting” rather than full-time (and tenured) faculty—who tended to resent teaching composition or language-learning classes to lower-level students or even undergraduates, as such tedium distracted them from rarified research, I may add.

Critics of austerity succumbed to market forces. Peter Drucker’s “knowledge management” innovations applied tough entrepreneurial theory to those bearing “intellectual capital”. This set of principles clashed with those employed increasingly by humanists to justify their reaction to such political blocs, erected to suppress dissent. However, Foucault and Lacan provide fewer principles to assist English professors charged with meeting expenses. Newfield examines this lack of a strong defense as weak offense, but his dry chapter, which might have benefited from campus accounts from those who were there to balance his reliance on “subtle and conflicted formulations”, fails to dramatize the transition over these 35 years, as enacted by thousands of my fellow students and professors.

Elsewhere, he provides a valuable resource in compiling data, inevitably dry but carefully collected, that document how the humanities and social sciences must beg for money that they generated, which is used by universities for engineers or medicine. Drama and music departments decay while MBA programs may enjoy gleaming facilities. While his account passes over the lot of those assigned or resigned to attend such venues, this book appears aimed at administrators of—rather than everyday users of—such spaces.

Newfield, as expected, questions the lack of what he regards as racial diversity in many departments, which he sees as skewed as those for “underrepresented” populations at many public universities. He shows, if too broadly and rapidly, how integration does not always follow demographic change. Economic restratification may solidify after social change. The frenzy for admissions, funds, and research grants increases. Newfield asserts this as a “professional-middle class self-defense”, but I would question his view that this “self-defense” while “apparently color-blind and supportive of diversity” is targeted intentionally against the “racialized masses”.

There may be think-tanks and corporate entities engaged in shadowy subversion; the Koch brothers come to mind (this study first appeared in hardcover in 2008 before they were exposed as funding Tea Party and climate-change denial “grassroots” movements).  Yet on an everyday level, labeling this as a “decentralized and complex campaign to discredit” those progressives challenging business and political elites appears more sensible than to label this a coordinated assault against “racialized masses”—those who aspire to UC admissions appear to me as diverse as Los Angeles itself.

The Price of Admission

Newfield subtitles his account as a “forty-year assault on the middle class”; this amorphous entity itself is more and more a “multiracial” one, comprising immigrants from hundreds of nations and their increasingly intermarried and blended families. The class stratification of this global, entrepreneurial elite, as it settles in the US and seeks inclusion within (or parallels to) admissions programs designed for historically disadvantaged American groups, complicates Newfield’s colleagues’ delineations. Also, the rapid increase in tutors, intensive and pricy SAT preparation, and counselors-for-hire gaming the entry process (as often as neo-con reactionaries) challenges Newfield’s model.


As an observer of the admissions frenzy (and a now a parent of two teens) I suggest that this escalating competition is driven by a corporate-funded tutorial industry—and a desire to attain an affordable, respected degree. In an increasingly multicultural state, most residents outside the affluent or those courted for rare talents face this “brute selectivity”.  Newfield relegates most of his few mentions of Asian American students, who far outnumber at UC their parity in the state population, to a couple of footnotes; he also does not include Indian or Middle Eastern American students in his study.  More consideration of how such “minority” but often markedly “overrepresented” populations effect his findings might have enriched their relevance, for many students seeking technical and business degrees come from these backgrounds, which throw off his assumptions based on a rear-guard action by managers from a conspiratorial “white” cabal. They certainly prove to be capitalists, but they draw from allies worldwide, often with degrees earned here.

Furthermore, the affirmative action programs in which I taught at UCLA in the late ‘80s often enrolled those from upper-middle class suburbs, rather than those from inner-city or rural high schools from where few students entered the UC system, and from which far fewer graduated. A few Asians qualified based on the national origin of their families; most were denied this “bridge program” as based on university-mandated categories relating to “race” more than class. Today, perhaps more than a quarter-century ago, the majority of those applying to UC, I’m guessing, come from weaker-income families. These parents suffer job instability, often regardless of what “ethnicity” or combinations thereof they checked off on an application.

Newfield criticizes the lack of parity as to faculty and diversity. Meritocracy and equality contend. He admits that integration succeeds better at more selective schools. He notes how less elite workplaces integrated as whites “retreat upmarket”, yet he overlooks how those ambitious or motivated students from among non-white populations also follow this migration to more lucrative careers.  At my less prestigious institution, I observe how far more students from “non-traditional” backgrounds seek careers in business, high-tech, management, or in the professions. They rarely enter an unstable, underpaid, overworked occupation reliant on adjunct classes and multiple campuses, amidst “the declining status and working conditions of large sections of college teaching”. 

Regardless of the complexion or gender of those behind the lectern or in the seats, the public university system relies upon quality. Newfield warns of Michigan’s “privatization” and reliance on philanthropy as a harbinger of what happens (as the UC system now proposes) when out-of-state (or international) students paying higher tuition gain a greater share of admissions. When global markets and not state access determine who enters a flagship institution, its reputation as a state-wide system established for local advancement may concomitantly decline.

This message reminds us, as taxpayers, parents, neighbors, colleagues, and coworkers of those enrolled and graduated from the land-grant and state-funded universities, of their importance. If professors questioned the complicity of the US corporate system in angering those who attacked on 9/11, then, after all, these professors were doing their job: to encourage criticism, and to foment debate. Newfield applauds the professoriate for its resistance to revenge, flag-waving, and jingoism. “They refused right judgment and clear action. Or to put another way, they taught.”  Unpopular opinions wilt when unprotected at work, at home, off campus; this makes their shelter on campus all the more urgent.

All the same (here Newfield argues against a former UCLA classmate of mine), I think that he downplays the liberal tendency in the humanities and social sciences to dominate a department by hiring and promotion and course content. What Stanley Fish calls “impaired liberalism” emerges as a challenge to the academic freedom afforded students as well as professors. That is, pressure persists within classrooms for those with less power to accept the positions advocated by those with tenure, who enjoy a protection denied, suppressed, or less likely to be appealed to by the term-paper or dissertation writer, the T.A., the adjunct.

Taxpayers must fund the universities which may and which should question our own ways of making a living, of conducting wars, of denying climate change. Yet I see no contradiction in demanding accountability from institutions founded to serve those from my state, paid for by those of us from our state. Those of us outside the public universities must assure their perpetuation—-for all who seek to learn and to assert facts as distinguished from opinions and cant. This may be a more nuanced position than Newfield and his colleagues may understand. I sympathize as do many humanists with liberal concepts, yet my own eclectic thinking compels me to question arguments arrayed by my peers, students, colleagues, and mentors. That too is part of the higher education I earned in part at UCLA.

Certainly Newfield’s call for remedies restoring the liberal arts and social sciences to their once-respected ranks should be heard. It may be idealistic by definition, but as an interested bystander in the professoriate’s less exalted echelon, I concur that this makes it no less necessary. The problem embeds itself in the institution, funded by a government with whom it often argues.

Universities can’t be capitalist. They need to balance their books, but they need to teach from books, and produce more books, that challenge profit as the price of everything and the value of nothing. Teaching, Newfield concludes, remains “labor-intensive, craft-based creation” which is noncapitalist. “Since capitalism will continue to insist on bottom-line measures of their output, universities will at those times need to be frankly noncapitalist”.  We should be able to afford this ideal of a lively campus, not so much as an ivory tower, but as an open arena for battles even against us, who pay for admission. (PopMatters featured at RePrint: 5-6-11.)