Last May, the new DSM-V, the standard for medical and psychological professions in classifying sexual disorders, admitted that there now exists "a subtle but crucial difference that makes it possible for an individual to engage in consensual atypical sexual behavior without making being labelled with a mental disorder". This shift away from deviance accompanied a rejection by the American Psychiatric Association of a new category of "hypersexual disorder"; but pressure groups, London-based historian Julie Peakman reports as she introduces her survey of what has often been called perversion, had managed previously to finally remove homosexuality from the list of diagnosed disorders. This struggle to define what is acceptable and what is deviant comprises this study, promoted as the first one-volume summary of "perverse sex".
Following Peakman's scholarship on eighteenth-century British prostitution and pornography, this European-centered presentation peers beyond English shores to look back to classical and biblical reactions to varieties of sex, and--given the limits of firsthand evidence for much of history, often relying upon court testimony and scientific or religious examination--personal accounts when a few dare or boast or are coerced into admitting their own indulgences. Peakman's argument remains clear throughout a dozen thematic chapters. "Normal" does not always equate with heterosexual, male-dominated activities. Standards keep changing. The abnormal alters over time and space.
Despite the unreliability of much of ancient literary or artistic evidence, and the scarcity of trustworthy medieval and early modern accounts for, understandably, a topic prone to secrecy more than display by many of its adherents, the sexual practices uncovered do reveal a similar pattern. For instance, as Peakman lists early on, "oral sex, masturbation, homosexuality, lesbianism, transvestism, flagellation, exhibitionism, voyeurism" all have been accepted by ancient peoples, then condemned by Christian societies, and denigrated by those who in recent centuries began to replace the labels attached to such behaviors. As Western culture secularized, these actions were not so much "sinful" as "irrational"; the medical profession rushed to prevent the acceptance of such activities as normal.
Changes in the past few centuries show this process unfolding. Around 1710, Onania was published. This purported to prove the harm of masturbation. A first, this pamphlet (which by its sixteenth edition tripled in length) warned women as well as men about the practice. Yet, two centuries later, the leading sexologist Richard von Kraft-Ebbing dismissed threats to females. "Woman, if physically and mentally normal, and properly educated, has but little sensual desire." At the same time, Sigmund Freud purported to diagnose women and their orgasm with his own pet theory. After observation and interpretation by Alfred Kinsey and Masters and Johnson by the middle of the last century, masturbation by either sex became classified as normal again. What Greek or Roman doctors recommended to patients, what Christians condemned, what Enlightenment-era or Victorian physicians diagnosed as a physical or mental disorder, and what modern counterparts judge as "a healthy and necessary alternative to procreative sex" typifies the "life cycle of a sexual perversion".
Peakman examines same-sex male and female sexuality, and she distinguishes differences in social or cultural reactions. Men tended to, in the ancient world, be accepted if they dominated the homosexual coupling, while the passive partner was seen as weak, often a slave or a boy trapped, perhaps in a power differential. Women were also regarded as passive, and therefore dismissed as subservient. For lesbians, the sanctioned intimacy many females of any sexual preference tended to demonstrate among themselves allowed women to pursue same-sex relationships with less scrutiny by authorities and less danger than homosexuals. In 1921, an act of Parliament banning lesbianism was never passed. It seemed better to overlook the practice rather than to draw attention by prosecuting it.
A provocative chapter on bestiality enlivens the range of invention. Peakman muses whether this practice was more a question of preference or of opportunity, for what until the last century was a European population with many people growing up much more closely in contact with animals next to them on farms or nearby in villages. Size mattered. Men worked in barns, dairies and fields. As meticulous court documents support, they tended to be caught with their breeches down among mares or sheep, which fit with the males more neatly. Women snuggled in their own rooms in town, cradling smaller cats or dogs. As with homosexuals and masturbators, those who clung to critters were often exposed by peeping Toms and Tammies, who spied through holes in the walls or windows upon their misbehaving neighbors. The crime was often punished by death, both to the creature and the human.
One legendary spin on this, when the fear of the hybrid half-animal/ half-human persisted over many centuries, was the case of Mary Toft. A serving girl of twenty-six, in 1726 she gained the notice of the king's surgeon, who came to investigate. "In search of fame and fortune, she had inserted various rabbit parts into her vagina with the intention of duping her doctor. She had called in her local physician, claiming to be in labour, and, to his astonishment, out popped the various bits of rabbit." Understandably, doctors were puzzled and amazed. She later confessed; she served four months.
Peakman returns at the conclusion of many chapters to the need for consent. This proves the crux of the matter. Partners may be assumed to agree, but in BDSM, can one legally go along with one's own assault? If an animal is a participant in sexual activity, can that creature be said to agree? If so, what does that mean, and how could such consent be determined? As for necrophilia, the dead partner certainly lost any say in the matter. Pedophilia has had its recent advocates who claim consent exists by those who perhaps may be at the legal age of consent (which varies), but as Peakman notes, attempts by that faction to come out and gain acceptance during the 1980s in the wake of gay rights movements only resulted in more persecution, as child-lovers were marched back to the closet.
The Marquis de Sade emerges as an inevitable spokesman in this debate. In his epigram to Juliette (1797-1801), "he defended its publication stating that he saw 'unnatural vices' as 'the strange vices inspired by Nature'. 'Natural' for Sade were all the perversions he described." Peakman sums up this twist: Sadeian philosophy asserts natural origins for all our actions, so they all logically are natural.
But, as the words sadist and masochist capture for two centuries since, those men who originated these terms celebrated a brutality and an exchange of power where consent may not always be arranged. Peakman reminds us of the Roman males who took sex rather than asked for it. She turns to the plight of the Victorian or Edwardian child unable to resist the predicament of his or her exploitation. "Men had no need to rape starving victims; they merely needed a few pence in their pockets and an eye for a starving child." As with the desperate or lonely, the inventive or deluded who sought release or comfort in grasping a horse or a cat, so Peakman draws the reader's attention to those who have been at the receiving end or found a blunt slap regarding bold sexual relationships.
With exhibitionism and voyeurism, the question of victimization now recedes; ironically, Peakman shows how until very recently with the advent of the Internet and mass-media, these two activities often depended on the lack of consent of those on display for the delight of Peeping Toms. Their female equivalents in public (and here we can include printed material--this book itself is illustrated with many period examples--and the media) may increasingly show off their vaginas and labias, Peakman finds, but the respective amount of depictions of the erect male phallus lags far behind. The gender imbalance, she mentions if only as an aside, as to who is looking at whom appears throughout much of the West; one limit of this book is that it does not examine global cultures to offer a broader perspective for comparison and contrast. This is admittedly a hefty volume as it is, yet her coverage for all its lively details rushes by, leaving the reader wanting much more than her many casual remarks when the need to interpret material and not only to collate and paraphrase it arises so often.
As these contents testify, millennia of visual arousal certainly continues to stimulate, even as market demands change and new interests bloom. Research opportunities beckon. "'Chubby-chasing' became a hobby for those obsessed with fat. Whether this has to do with the after-effects of post-Second World War rationing or with the current preoccupation with diet has yet to be ascertained." For all the inherent verve in this subject matter, Peakman keeps a firm control of its impacts, and its contexts.
Near the conclusion, this cultural historian of sexuality wonders if any taboos are left. I learned a new one. Forty or so people, it is claimed, have "loving relationships with objects" and call themselves "objectum sexuals". Two of these "OS" women fought over who deserved the Berlin Wall, and they, being polyamorous, agreed to share the wall "as a lover". Amy had fallen for both the Empire State Building and the World Trade Center, "and grieved the loss of the latter as one would a lover". Peakman records that these women had in common trauma, rejection, and types of dysfunction.
Therefore, as definitions of (arguably) accepted practice expand to include buildings as objects of affection, the challenge for scholars to comprehend sexual behavior which is not nowadays accepted also grows. Peakman avers how it is "now reasonably common for people to incorporate fellating, fetishism, infibulating or fisting (or at least one of these activities) into their usual role play". When (nearly?) no part of the anatomy, the natural realm, or inanimate objects may appear beyond the embrace of somebody needing a catch and release, are any areas out of bounds?
In a too terse but necessary epilogue, Peakman considers harmful sex "to the degree of death or bodily harm between consenting adults (sexual cannibalism or sadomasochism); second, vulnerable adults [e.g., those with learning difficulties or Down's syndrome]; and, third, the age of consent." As I hinted above, the final category has always varied. While she does not delve into some of these areas with sufficient detail, Peakman advises more monitoring of institutions against abuse, and better support for those who may be at risk of coercion or manipulation.
Finally, as procreation at last appears to be "no longer a sexual necessity (or hazard)" for more men and women, sexual acts themselves gain parity. Peakman judges that any kind of sex becomes a matter of preference. We now enjoy freedom of choice, extended and abetted by a mediating Internet. We redraw intimate boundaries, beyond those of one's own body and a willing partner (or two?) close at hand. (PopMatters 12-9-13; 11-19-13 to Amazon US in shorter form)
Showing posts with label Sade. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Sade. Show all posts
Saturday, January 25, 2014
Friday, April 1, 2011
Sex & Stones
May break my bones? This blog's reviewed earnest accounts by Western Buddhists, Irish republicans and their discontents, scholarly punks, musical marginals, and/or overeducated malcontents moaning across six hundred pages of footnoted density. But I do harbor a broader (no pun intended?), if arcane and misfit, sensibility beyond pet preferences. Today, "foolishly," I'll skim some newly excavated shards about sexuality.
In the New York Times glossy Travel magazine, amid articles touting a Laguna Beach yoga-camp where you could eat 1200 calories a day while yanking your dog up scenic vistas, for a mere $3900 a week (a bargain next to a $5k ashram up/down this coddled, mansed, and condofied fiefdom of the once open access Pacific coast), Sean Penn glowering from noble Haitian relief work, and ways to spend money in London, I stumbled upon Joumana Haddad, by a journalist puffed (if more svelte from her elegantly swathed stance than her tagline's inspiration suggests) as "the Oprah of Lebanon."
Sex and the Souk doesn't delve very deep, but Haddad raises a cogent point among the posing and preening. She does strike me as a bit disingenuous, for as a Christian, why'd she make a big stand about never having worn an hijab, which is a Muslim practice? But given her affluence, her two kids by two different men, and her ambiguously affluent status now due to what seems hinted as a sugar daddy out of her current boudoir, a high life in Beirut's high rises appears to afford her a windowed vista above the city, a corner office, a laptop, and sniper's perch. A scenic vista along another urban coast, from where she can target the chauvinist hordes.
Nina Burleigh gives her subject more attention for her hand-rolled cigs, her "J" tattoo for her own "racy" magazine "Jasad" ("body" in Arabic), and her gushing over Steven Colbert. She'll land five minutes near his televised lap on the inevitable promo tour for her forthcoming tell-all book, I predict.
If Jasad's "articles by intellectuals and poets about masturbation, homosexuality, fetishism and polygamy alongside antique photos of nude Arab boys luxuriating in voluptuous Ottoman settings and close-ups of female genitalia" comprise "tame fare by Western standards," I guess I need to watch less TV, or change the channels more. She claims at twelve that finding de Sade's "Justine" proved her "baptism by subversion." (I'd recommend Joachim Neugroschel's witty Penguin translation of the Marquis' cheerier "Philosophy in the Bedroom," or even "Juliette," over the depressing, decidedly morbid "Justine," but as Haddad mastered it in French, I'll give her the benefit of my doubts, being one language distant from her magazine and another from the decidedly un-erotic, to my tastes, de Sade. His point's not to titillate, but to flagellate, the body politique.)
But at least her comment reminds us of the current, and perpetual, if often undercover, subversion that powers impose to suppress. I've just reviewed Islamic scholar Olivier Roy's "Holy Ignorance: When Religion and Culture Part Ways" featured at PopMatters. This French professor might agree with Haddad: the globalization of religious identities as they drift from their cultural moorings may lead to the Net, books, and magazines as media by which change will occur, which no imam, prelate, or eruv can shut out. If people want to believe and behave a certain way, they may find that they can do this from anywhere in the world, with a freedom never afforded their ancestors. The struggle to freely wield the lash, in de Sade vs. Saudi Arabia, certainly invites its own clash of provocations and imprecations.
Any whip my Connacht progenitors raised must have been against only a cow or horse. So I reckon, even though my maternal line appears to have been feisty enough to provoke paternal lack of paternalistic pacifism. My ancestors never likely met up with Jewish traders let alone Buddhist adherents. Although I possess a great-great grandmother with a bonafide Traveller (don't call them Tinkers or "Irish Gypsies") surname and provenance.
With the exception of a few Scouts in one place I partly (!) grew up, where college town sophisticates mingled with us barely non-gypsy rubes (my best friend had a pet goat, my family couldn't stop breeding pups, and two neighbors smelled up the still then semi-rural acreage with two horses), I'd remained ignorant long, never seeing a bagel until college. I met non-Catholic friends only in grad school. As Diarmaid Ferriter documents in Occasion of Sin: Sex and society in modern Ireland, reviewed by me at The New York Journal of Books, within my diasporic "living memory," the impositions of the Church weighed upon many of us who were raised in supposedly post-Vatican II guitar-Mass disco-ball Sodom.
I wonder what my pre-Christian forebears from the isle might have venerated. Even as a kid, I rooted for Druids over Patrick, and felt bad about the copses felled where crosses rose. Evidence for sexual mores, naturally, remains notoriously difficult to interpret, given the lack of testimonies, the clerical censors, the surviving palimpsests of even medieval depositions and ancient lyrics confounding scholars. Compare with primordial scraps we rummage among, wondering what troglodytes did when they did what they did.
One archeologist compares what we know about pre-literate sexual activity to a few thousand bits of a billion-piece jigsaw puzzle. Timothy Taylor has mused, as I've addressed less imaginatively and more stolidly in my research (link may be down to pdf) on "the invention of 'Celtic Buddhism' as a concept," that the enigmatic find in Jutland of the Transylvanian-made Gundestrup Cauldron displays in its androgynous and shamanic figures an ambiguous glimpse at "tantric sex in Iron Age Denmark." (215) While as I have argued Taylor overstates his case, this giant decorated silver bowl represents for him a possibility that might have been. (Qualifications weigh down any sentence I can compose about this topic.) If Tantric yogic traditions could have spread from India to the West, by way of intersexed, torqued figures as the wisdom carriers of knowledge and dream, what a world might have evolved.
Taylor briefly entertains an alternative history: "the courts of medieval Europe might have thrilled to the erotic dances of Indian-style courtesans, surrounded by voluptuous sexual imagery, as on the Hindu temples of the Deccan." (218) This passage appears in his "The Prehistory of Sex" (1996). It attempts to make sense out of such fragmented evidence from "four million years of human sexual culture." I found it (inevitably?) patchy and erratic, as the curious glimpses into shadowed contexts shifted so often and the focus, given the scattered fragments of evidence, endures as it always will, mysteriously suggestive, but his section on Neolithic megaliths captured my attention.
I once glimpsed Marija Gimbutas, the late Lithuanian-born archeologist, as I passed her open office door, deep in a green-painted, subterranean passage in a UCLA science building. This setting, cold and austere, may have suited her, for her studies during the decade I walked by her lab, praised by feminists, inspired notions of a goddess culture, a matriarchical hegemony that once stretched across pre-Iron Age Eurasia. Inevitably, her claims have been contested, and Taylor stands on firmer ground in suspecting her "Great Mother" vision reconstructed from figurines and postholes as too ameliorative, given the endemic legacy of war and greed that makes us forget that "hand tools" were most likely weapons first. Violence within our genes, for him, turns idylls suspect. I think of the scene opening "2001" in reverse. Yet, I also think of the travel narrative I re-started last night, after finishing it twenty years ago, Andrew Harvey's "A Journey in Ladakh." He entered in the 1970s that enclave, nearly free then of strife in a contentedly Buddhist fastness, a last redoubt already eroding by Kashmiri and Hindi frontier battles.
Taylor admits that hunter-gatherers cooperated, and that farming communities competed. Land ownership demanded paternity must be established, inheritance sorted out, and women, ground down by a sedentary existence, had to give up some relative freedom once they settled down. Down meant into a posture bent over, grinding grain, where babies had to be weaned earlier, so as to allow mothers a stance to keep toiling. Slings for babies out of sinews or fiber may have been the first tool invented, millions of years ago. Gathering women can walk with a baby (not with babies) and live among nomadic hunters.
But, when they farm, men and women must stay, and their babies that used to be spaced out in succession by longer breastfeeding and contraceptive knowledge gleaned from wild plants therefore get taken off the teat quicker. Mom's got to get back to work. Her infants are fed gruel from grown grain cooked in newfangled pottery. Mothers then get pregnant again more quickly and more often. Their bones wear out quicker, they may die off faster, and polygamy may turn status symbol. Maternal and infant mortality increase with more births: I recall that the odds were, until industrial time in the West, 1:10 that a mother would die in childbirth.
As sharper weapons hastened bloodier battle over newly stored wealth, violence meant that more men died, too, outpacing female mortality. Taylor estimates that even in the settlements praised by Gimbutas in present-day Turkey, males met a sudden end more often. More "surplus" women may have led-- this is me now ruminating-- to the "Solomon's 300 wives and thousand concubines" exaggeration of a cultural disparity that endures in the Arab and Muslim realms Haddad seeks to reform by pulp and photos and poets for promotion today. Starting in her native Middle East, as grain grows and animals breed in captivity, calorically-boosted, well-fed populations increase, land gets devoured, fences loom, plows harden, and spears bristle. Forested frontiers recede as farmers push out hunters and gatherers.
Taylor faces his own challenges to present his grimmer prehistorical perspective. He argues that settling down for the newly agricultural domesticators meant that they shifted their sexual understanding. He posits that "hunter-gatherer sex had been modeled on an idea of sharing and complementarity," while its replacement "was voyeuristic, repressive, homophobic, and focused on reproduction. Afraid of the wild, farmers set out to destroy it." (142-3) One way they did this was, in post-Ice Age expansion, to insist on their dominance over their landscapes. Rather than fitting in and wandering about, settlers set boundaries. The Hebrews obsessed over separation of categories, clean and unclean, meat and milk, chosen and gentile, sinner and saved. Taylor figures that such peoples feared cross-dressers, homosexuals, and any who deviated from reproductive duties.
Those passages about leprosy and casting out the scarred and lame from Leviticus stun many students. A dim recollection that "ivrit" for the first Hebrew tribe meant "boundary crosser" came to mind just now. Within a land they defended, such a people might be sensitive to defining what became justified as divinely granted patrimony with a vehemence and a vengeance against interlopers, transgressors, and those who resisted their commands. Taylor reasons that Middle Eastern farmers responded to control dangerous sexual impulses by watching the cattle they lived among, modelling their own treatment of women after the rutting bull's rapid function lorded over "relatively passive females."
His next chapter, halfway into his book, begins: "I do not believe a women built Stonehenge." One may have been sacrificed in its ditches, however. "I believe that the making of Stonehenge was ordered by a man and that he was unhappy." (167) Its alignment to invite the midsummer's sun's penetration with a shaft of light stays potent. But for Taylor, it's too boastful, betraying a recumbent earth-goddess resigned to her fate within a society which fears its untamed surroundings. He cites Peter Ellis's 1994 conception of the New Stone Age's psychological profile as a "collectively held obsession" erecting "a landscape of detached sexual objects." (qtd. 189)
Taylor considers how weaning infants earlier, in a warrior culture, may trigger what in Martin Seligman's theory's called "learned helplessness." Cry all you want, you won't get the bottle. In a society where the mother's withdrawn the nipple, energy's costly, the "weans" get ignored, and the wee'uns capitulate, instinctively following the natural rule that yelling out exposes a bird or beast to danger. But before the baby cries itself to sleep, it feels detached from reality, and cannot figure out how to regain power. The only way? Control one's surroundings. Rigid routines help this culture (and perhaps that of we, their genetic inheritors) regain a predictable way to "compensate for their primal distrust of the world." (191)
If the sun can be compelled to slip in just-so same time same place next year, there might be hope for those who try to conquer nature. Only the stones remain, with a few scratches of primal engorgement, primitive erections (one from Bronze Age Finland Taylor captions-- the figure looks like he wears a baseball cap as he pumps his free arm in the air in enthusiasm or frustration, I add-- as "skier attempting intercourse with moose") and primordial lumps carved into bosomy, considerably callipgyian globs which make Oprah not of Lebanon look like Lindsay Lohan.
Taylor examines more monumental configurations, passage-tombs arrayed like vast granite wombs to overcome death's dark tyranny by inviting the release of injected light, or what my demure consort has labeled in relation to the Tibetan yab-yum depiction of male-female energies (euphemism or profundity) "another big-dick thing." Standing pillars as massive maximizers hoisted to the bearded sky gods of the incoming Iron Age, memorialize as physical graffiti what we many boast (males at least, and at least the randier matriarchs of today's females I imagine given the phallic plethora of what scholars of the Upper Paleolithic gingerly label as "spear-straighteners") still: size matters, quantity over quality.
Surplus labor indeed, long before Marx, who with Engels knew far less about early civilization's family, state, and society. Subsequent radical thinkers strive to fit their theories into bold suppositions. Julian Cope, who symbolizes for me the root of the border-crossing heathen, the gnomic, genial, genuine oracle of chant and ritual and wonder and fear from the heath, the outlier, the pagani left behind by the populi who bow to emperor and then Rome, compiled two monumental edifices of his own complex odyssey.
First he went across Britain, to photograph, contemplate, and puzzle over more than 300 prehistoric sites in "The Modern Antiquarian" (1997). Then, in a book I just tracked down (neither has appeared in the U.S., nor have his excellent earlier memoirs of his post-punk personal odyssey through hell and back, "Head On" and "Repossessed"), "The Megalithic European," he expands to Ireland and the Continent. By now, thousands of miles Cope's searched another 300-plus of these oldest of remaining markers left to attest to a newly aware humanity's permanence, "defiant acts against the transitory nature of life."
Cope does not cite Taylor, so I'm left wondering how he'd respond to his Neolithic critique. But, as a self-taught interpreter of megalithic culture, who insists that he will not write about where he has not been, Cope's imaginative powers circle into the venerable echoes of these mysterious traditions. On his gothic-folk, ambient-meets-krautrock, Mellotron-metal recordings, he seeks to recover distant voices. He channels what for the stodgy professor may alienate as much as the typical rock listener, but for me, even if I prefer his books to some of his sounds these past couple decades (I favor his pioneering post-punk propulsion), he represents for me an admirable model of inspired reinvention and daring restoration.
His later book's a bit calmer in its approach, as he shares his acceptance of what some early-Celtic Christians tried to do to keep some pagan customs before Rome and the Synod of Whitby shut down resistance to Celtic practices. For instance, these fringe dwellers, against the Saxon incursion, kept Passover's lunar date for commemorating Easter; pro-Roman clerics dispatched soon cracked down on the restive Celts. The reformers of the papal mission to keep Britain tidy demanded an end to observing the central but now movable Christian feast same as the Jewish spring barley harvest.
(As an aside, Exodus appears to scholars if not congregants or celebrants today as a vastly exaggerated account, a post-dated rationale. Although you'd be hard-pressed to discern Pesach's Canaanite "origins" as I looked up now if the festival originated for barley or wheat-- I get Shavout and Pesach jumbled with which grain commemorates which. Shavuot-turned-Pentecost marks the pilgrimage fifty days later at the end of the wheat gathering. By the way, if you opt as I did experimentally for Bing to fact-check, you get About.com first, which led me to "Ask the Rabbi" about Ur and Terah. Wikipedia's Canaan-rein as Liebensraum for echt ur-Zionists uber alles in its origin myth as "Origins of Pesach" coverage, I note "hoeuretically" in the spirit of Cope v.i. [=vide infra, "see below."])
My linguistic, spring-fed friskiness prefaces Cope's discussion of similarly Easter-bunnied, seder-egg plated, lamb-shanked feasts of fertility. Almost randomly, "Megalithic" in a sample passage reveals Cope's scope. He doesn't deign to guess unless he signals such, but his introduction does remind us of how as nomads drifted into farming, their fixed views turned into compelling reasons for them to stay. He glances at how Jerusalem's Holy Land, the rock of Golgotha, the Temple Mount, the shrines at Mecca literally stand for "inward-looking world centres" that may faith-fully settle a religion into its sturdy roots. This foundation may also be viewed fatally: contrast the Chinese destruction of Tibet's culture by the simple means of obliterating its shrines and overcrowding their land with foreigners bent on atheism.
Home bases mean enclosure of animals, crops, and ourselves. Control brings a heightened sensitivity, and a mythologized response, to one's territory. Terra turns turf, as it were.
Cope reflects how this vantage point might have taken on the weight that (as contemplates Taylor v.s., "vide supra, see above"), our ancestors imposed upon its trees (hewn down as was Queen Maacha's grove), vegetables (as dust no less than Queen Macha's bones under her grave mound), or as stones, all from this period two, three, four or even five thousand years ago that can be somewhat still seen today.
The rock, Cope suggests, where children played twenty years on may be pointed out to their children. One may have once fallen asleep, dreamed on that sunny rock, and told friends of what was vividly dreamt. This story may be related to one's own children. They may play on "parent's rock" and what was dream may in time turn ritual. Others may try to fall asleep on the rock, to dream dreams, and some eventually will recount a dream worth recounting to others in the settlement. So the practice begins, of the dreaming-rock, and this may be conjured by the community as "the stone that speaks."
I think of the Kaaba-- a enormous arena surrounding the cube embedding a now-half invisible, ancient, fabled, space-dropped junk-chunk draped in enormous gold black silk-- as a metaphor for what Cope seeks to unveil. Behind the sanctum sanctorum, the holy of holies, the curtain beckons to us as we who are not worthy line up to pay the unseen its due homage. Haddad no more than heathen me will never touch such a protected, venerated yet monitored monolith as that dominating her Levantine world and the wide tropical belt that cinctures more than a billion who, as Roy studies, spread their faith and mores across a globe where people never heard of the Qur'an until perhaps the Net, the news, their new neighbors.
The transmission of old stories and "just-so myths" gravitates for over 1500 years around a meteorite landed in Mecca. The respect paid by those coming from all over the globe on the "haj" to the Black Stone set in a suggestively recessed concavity in the side of the Kaaba's cube--a building attributed by the Qur'an to Abraham and Ishmael's efforts--we are told, does not constitute idolatry. Pilgrims also stone the devil at the pillars of Mina nearby. For once, the site was filled with competition.
Back when this shrine to Allah housed hundreds of gods and goddesses, "al-lat" was a term for a female deity as was "al-lah" for a male god, among hundreds before Islam. Remember how "elohim" created the heaven and the earth in the first lines of Genesis: the concept of many gods predates even in scripture the rule by the One before whom no others dare cut in line. Mecca for Mother-goddess worshipping Muhammed's clan, Koraites, these "Koeur-ites" assembled amid the houris, the "Houer-ees" of the doe-dark eyes who survive, perpetuated as 72 recurring maidens promised a Muslim male in the firmament.
This babble will become slighter clearer now. Concerning etymology and sexuality, chapter five in Cope's "Modern" compiles "The Book of Ur." Not Abraham's Ur of the Chaldees birthplace-- although the midrash of 1) how honest lil' Abe predicted his patriarchical covenant by despoiling dad Terah's shelf of the idols he sold at this crossroads down the road from the fallen Tower of Babel, and 2) this rabbi's expounding of how the Hebrew Ur=fire via G-d's predictably cranky, infernal payback bolsters Cope's thesis-- but in this "etymosophy," a list of words related to ancient goddess-wisdom. Cope offers three packed pages of miniscule if well-arranged (his books are easy to consult and fun to view) definitions.
Ur leads us to Eriu, Erin, and Erse-- alongside Eros-- as wordy relatives nearest my home-turf. Koeur, Hoeur, Bree, and Ma may be discerned even by the Lindsey Lohans and Oprah-fans of today as nestled into terms such as "core, corpse, corn, kernel, chord", as "her, whore, house, heretic, haughty, hurricane," as "Bridget, pregnant, pretty, pray, braid," and as "matrimony, marry, mate, Amazon, and Macha"--whom he links between the "pre-Keltic" formidable queen of Emain Macha in Ulster with a grove-spirit burnt by the River Kidron by her son King Asa in 1 Kings 15:13. That shows the scope of this elucidation.
While some of this may be suspect, and some lacks sources, this sort of cross-cultural, multi-lingual, ecumenical mindset inspires me. Taylor and other scholars concur that Cernunnos, the Celtic horned-god, may be the figure on the Gundestrup Cauldron that my own articles have examined. Cope reminds me that this god's title too comes down from "Coeur." He also notes how this horned god morphed, under Christians, into their depiction of the devil. Christians at this same time feared their rivals, the Jews, as Passover had to be wrenched apart from Easter, the Celts apart from their constructions of another form of Catholicity. And, the same Church feared the Jews and mocked Moses by a mistranslation of that pesky vowel-parsimonous Hebrew. St. Jerome attributed not "rays of light" post-Sinai, as celebrated at Shavuot fifty days after the Exodus-feast of deliverance as the giving of the Torah to Moses, but the "horns"--which then grew into those, by medieval antisemitic calumny, of the devil.
Salman Rushdie (in)famously wrote of similarly marginalized stories, dangerous tales relegated as heresy, and misattributions by those frantic that a Mother-goddess might endure her overthrow by the monotheist prophets and priests. "The Satanic Verses" considers this alternative history of feminist and devilish influences upon Muhammed's message and its promotion. Unlike Gimbutas, Taylor, or Cope, Rushdie's "what-if" assumptions even disguised as fiction and not possible fact met with those as eager to destroy him as prelate, rabbi, and imam have condemned their pagan, gentile, infidel dissenters.
I started today with a reflection on a forbidden zone. I end up at the same place. That which we bow to, circle as sacred, lift up as hallowed separates us from those who despise, envy, or admire us. This may be natural to our humanity, the side that outside of a redoubt in the Himalayas we all find ourselves clinging to out of fear as the ghosts rally, the famine deepens, the foes march, and the fires flare. Sacred calves at Sinai, neo-pagans at Stonehenge, reviewers as on this blog of "The Satanic Verses": I stepped aside from critical hosannas for a tale I found ramshackle, too flimsy to tower as a literary monument.
The latest in a series of sexual and ideological rebels, as with her fellow border-crosser Rushdie, Joumana Haddad might roam into where words come from, and how they form our ideas. She might, in her forthcoming book, for all I know find feminist fodder in attributions to Muhammed's own tribe, named after a Koeur-goddess, and a Hoeur-temple. Preserved as "haram" the Kaaba lurks under a big black veil ever since the Prophet's inventions, projections, and revampings. Twice today, once by chance I can't recall where, then eerily by Georges Perec as quoted in a cameo in Harvey's Ladakh, the same E.M. Cioran quote:
Haddad refuses what many men claim that which other women claim they want. As an infidel, a suspect, a lapsed onlooker, I will forever lack full insight. I've been born into a category; its boundaries set me apart. My mind may strive to understand. My maleness keeps me ignorant. Names can never hurt me?
Photo: Taylor (198-99) interprets this Letnitsa 4c BCE silver-gilt bridle from today's Bulgaria imaginatively. I figured it fit today's April (Cope links this word to Bree) Fool's atmosphere of topsy as turvy. Taylor conjectures that this dramatizes not a "'hierogamy' as sacred marriage" but a seduction of a woman who plies a man with drink from the vessel held by her accomplice. The dominant female straddles the man, compliant as he sits and she squats. The attendant holds a leafy branch over the face of the woman on top, so the man cannot see who she is. It may be simply love is blind, but Taylor suspects mischief's Amazonially afoot. Barefoot, or underfoot, Amazons were fabled by Herodotus to lurk up from Danubia along the Don (both keep the name of one of the most ancient of female goddesses) river, east of Scythia in Sauromatia. ("Mas"= an Indo-European root word for softness and fleshiness as in the Irish word for "thigh"-- a+mazos= without a breast in ancient Greek.)
(Portions of this will appear soon tidied, trimmed, and tamed into censored, if perky book reviews for Taylor and Cope on Amazon US.)
In the New York Times glossy Travel magazine, amid articles touting a Laguna Beach yoga-camp where you could eat 1200 calories a day while yanking your dog up scenic vistas, for a mere $3900 a week (a bargain next to a $5k ashram up/down this coddled, mansed, and condofied fiefdom of the once open access Pacific coast), Sean Penn glowering from noble Haitian relief work, and ways to spend money in London, I stumbled upon Joumana Haddad, by a journalist puffed (if more svelte from her elegantly swathed stance than her tagline's inspiration suggests) as "the Oprah of Lebanon."
Sex and the Souk doesn't delve very deep, but Haddad raises a cogent point among the posing and preening. She does strike me as a bit disingenuous, for as a Christian, why'd she make a big stand about never having worn an hijab, which is a Muslim practice? But given her affluence, her two kids by two different men, and her ambiguously affluent status now due to what seems hinted as a sugar daddy out of her current boudoir, a high life in Beirut's high rises appears to afford her a windowed vista above the city, a corner office, a laptop, and sniper's perch. A scenic vista along another urban coast, from where she can target the chauvinist hordes.
One wonders where sexual politics fits into this volatile setting. “People tell me, ‘There are so many things wrong with the Arab world, why do you just talk about sex?’ And I say, ‘This is the main link.’ Who decides what’s haram — what’s allowed and not allowed? The religious figures. They are linked with the political powers, and together they work to control the society through this medium, the sex drive. If you break the power over sex, you can start undermining and questioning the religious and political powers. You cannot do it the other way around.”
Nina Burleigh gives her subject more attention for her hand-rolled cigs, her "J" tattoo for her own "racy" magazine "Jasad" ("body" in Arabic), and her gushing over Steven Colbert. She'll land five minutes near his televised lap on the inevitable promo tour for her forthcoming tell-all book, I predict.
If Jasad's "articles by intellectuals and poets about masturbation, homosexuality, fetishism and polygamy alongside antique photos of nude Arab boys luxuriating in voluptuous Ottoman settings and close-ups of female genitalia" comprise "tame fare by Western standards," I guess I need to watch less TV, or change the channels more. She claims at twelve that finding de Sade's "Justine" proved her "baptism by subversion." (I'd recommend Joachim Neugroschel's witty Penguin translation of the Marquis' cheerier "Philosophy in the Bedroom," or even "Juliette," over the depressing, decidedly morbid "Justine," but as Haddad mastered it in French, I'll give her the benefit of my doubts, being one language distant from her magazine and another from the decidedly un-erotic, to my tastes, de Sade. His point's not to titillate, but to flagellate, the body politique.)
But at least her comment reminds us of the current, and perpetual, if often undercover, subversion that powers impose to suppress. I've just reviewed Islamic scholar Olivier Roy's "Holy Ignorance: When Religion and Culture Part Ways" featured at PopMatters. This French professor might agree with Haddad: the globalization of religious identities as they drift from their cultural moorings may lead to the Net, books, and magazines as media by which change will occur, which no imam, prelate, or eruv can shut out. If people want to believe and behave a certain way, they may find that they can do this from anywhere in the world, with a freedom never afforded their ancestors. The struggle to freely wield the lash, in de Sade vs. Saudi Arabia, certainly invites its own clash of provocations and imprecations.
Any whip my Connacht progenitors raised must have been against only a cow or horse. So I reckon, even though my maternal line appears to have been feisty enough to provoke paternal lack of paternalistic pacifism. My ancestors never likely met up with Jewish traders let alone Buddhist adherents. Although I possess a great-great grandmother with a bonafide Traveller (don't call them Tinkers or "Irish Gypsies") surname and provenance.
With the exception of a few Scouts in one place I partly (!) grew up, where college town sophisticates mingled with us barely non-gypsy rubes (my best friend had a pet goat, my family couldn't stop breeding pups, and two neighbors smelled up the still then semi-rural acreage with two horses), I'd remained ignorant long, never seeing a bagel until college. I met non-Catholic friends only in grad school. As Diarmaid Ferriter documents in Occasion of Sin: Sex and society in modern Ireland, reviewed by me at The New York Journal of Books, within my diasporic "living memory," the impositions of the Church weighed upon many of us who were raised in supposedly post-Vatican II guitar-Mass disco-ball Sodom.
I wonder what my pre-Christian forebears from the isle might have venerated. Even as a kid, I rooted for Druids over Patrick, and felt bad about the copses felled where crosses rose. Evidence for sexual mores, naturally, remains notoriously difficult to interpret, given the lack of testimonies, the clerical censors, the surviving palimpsests of even medieval depositions and ancient lyrics confounding scholars. Compare with primordial scraps we rummage among, wondering what troglodytes did when they did what they did.
One archeologist compares what we know about pre-literate sexual activity to a few thousand bits of a billion-piece jigsaw puzzle. Timothy Taylor has mused, as I've addressed less imaginatively and more stolidly in my research (link may be down to pdf) on "the invention of 'Celtic Buddhism' as a concept," that the enigmatic find in Jutland of the Transylvanian-made Gundestrup Cauldron displays in its androgynous and shamanic figures an ambiguous glimpse at "tantric sex in Iron Age Denmark." (215) While as I have argued Taylor overstates his case, this giant decorated silver bowl represents for him a possibility that might have been. (Qualifications weigh down any sentence I can compose about this topic.) If Tantric yogic traditions could have spread from India to the West, by way of intersexed, torqued figures as the wisdom carriers of knowledge and dream, what a world might have evolved.
Taylor briefly entertains an alternative history: "the courts of medieval Europe might have thrilled to the erotic dances of Indian-style courtesans, surrounded by voluptuous sexual imagery, as on the Hindu temples of the Deccan." (218) This passage appears in his "The Prehistory of Sex" (1996). It attempts to make sense out of such fragmented evidence from "four million years of human sexual culture." I found it (inevitably?) patchy and erratic, as the curious glimpses into shadowed contexts shifted so often and the focus, given the scattered fragments of evidence, endures as it always will, mysteriously suggestive, but his section on Neolithic megaliths captured my attention.
I once glimpsed Marija Gimbutas, the late Lithuanian-born archeologist, as I passed her open office door, deep in a green-painted, subterranean passage in a UCLA science building. This setting, cold and austere, may have suited her, for her studies during the decade I walked by her lab, praised by feminists, inspired notions of a goddess culture, a matriarchical hegemony that once stretched across pre-Iron Age Eurasia. Inevitably, her claims have been contested, and Taylor stands on firmer ground in suspecting her "Great Mother" vision reconstructed from figurines and postholes as too ameliorative, given the endemic legacy of war and greed that makes us forget that "hand tools" were most likely weapons first. Violence within our genes, for him, turns idylls suspect. I think of the scene opening "2001" in reverse. Yet, I also think of the travel narrative I re-started last night, after finishing it twenty years ago, Andrew Harvey's "A Journey in Ladakh." He entered in the 1970s that enclave, nearly free then of strife in a contentedly Buddhist fastness, a last redoubt already eroding by Kashmiri and Hindi frontier battles.
Taylor admits that hunter-gatherers cooperated, and that farming communities competed. Land ownership demanded paternity must be established, inheritance sorted out, and women, ground down by a sedentary existence, had to give up some relative freedom once they settled down. Down meant into a posture bent over, grinding grain, where babies had to be weaned earlier, so as to allow mothers a stance to keep toiling. Slings for babies out of sinews or fiber may have been the first tool invented, millions of years ago. Gathering women can walk with a baby (not with babies) and live among nomadic hunters.
But, when they farm, men and women must stay, and their babies that used to be spaced out in succession by longer breastfeeding and contraceptive knowledge gleaned from wild plants therefore get taken off the teat quicker. Mom's got to get back to work. Her infants are fed gruel from grown grain cooked in newfangled pottery. Mothers then get pregnant again more quickly and more often. Their bones wear out quicker, they may die off faster, and polygamy may turn status symbol. Maternal and infant mortality increase with more births: I recall that the odds were, until industrial time in the West, 1:10 that a mother would die in childbirth.
As sharper weapons hastened bloodier battle over newly stored wealth, violence meant that more men died, too, outpacing female mortality. Taylor estimates that even in the settlements praised by Gimbutas in present-day Turkey, males met a sudden end more often. More "surplus" women may have led-- this is me now ruminating-- to the "Solomon's 300 wives and thousand concubines" exaggeration of a cultural disparity that endures in the Arab and Muslim realms Haddad seeks to reform by pulp and photos and poets for promotion today. Starting in her native Middle East, as grain grows and animals breed in captivity, calorically-boosted, well-fed populations increase, land gets devoured, fences loom, plows harden, and spears bristle. Forested frontiers recede as farmers push out hunters and gatherers.
Taylor faces his own challenges to present his grimmer prehistorical perspective. He argues that settling down for the newly agricultural domesticators meant that they shifted their sexual understanding. He posits that "hunter-gatherer sex had been modeled on an idea of sharing and complementarity," while its replacement "was voyeuristic, repressive, homophobic, and focused on reproduction. Afraid of the wild, farmers set out to destroy it." (142-3) One way they did this was, in post-Ice Age expansion, to insist on their dominance over their landscapes. Rather than fitting in and wandering about, settlers set boundaries. The Hebrews obsessed over separation of categories, clean and unclean, meat and milk, chosen and gentile, sinner and saved. Taylor figures that such peoples feared cross-dressers, homosexuals, and any who deviated from reproductive duties.
Those passages about leprosy and casting out the scarred and lame from Leviticus stun many students. A dim recollection that "ivrit" for the first Hebrew tribe meant "boundary crosser" came to mind just now. Within a land they defended, such a people might be sensitive to defining what became justified as divinely granted patrimony with a vehemence and a vengeance against interlopers, transgressors, and those who resisted their commands. Taylor reasons that Middle Eastern farmers responded to control dangerous sexual impulses by watching the cattle they lived among, modelling their own treatment of women after the rutting bull's rapid function lorded over "relatively passive females."
His next chapter, halfway into his book, begins: "I do not believe a women built Stonehenge." One may have been sacrificed in its ditches, however. "I believe that the making of Stonehenge was ordered by a man and that he was unhappy." (167) Its alignment to invite the midsummer's sun's penetration with a shaft of light stays potent. But for Taylor, it's too boastful, betraying a recumbent earth-goddess resigned to her fate within a society which fears its untamed surroundings. He cites Peter Ellis's 1994 conception of the New Stone Age's psychological profile as a "collectively held obsession" erecting "a landscape of detached sexual objects." (qtd. 189)
Taylor considers how weaning infants earlier, in a warrior culture, may trigger what in Martin Seligman's theory's called "learned helplessness." Cry all you want, you won't get the bottle. In a society where the mother's withdrawn the nipple, energy's costly, the "weans" get ignored, and the wee'uns capitulate, instinctively following the natural rule that yelling out exposes a bird or beast to danger. But before the baby cries itself to sleep, it feels detached from reality, and cannot figure out how to regain power. The only way? Control one's surroundings. Rigid routines help this culture (and perhaps that of we, their genetic inheritors) regain a predictable way to "compensate for their primal distrust of the world." (191)
If the sun can be compelled to slip in just-so same time same place next year, there might be hope for those who try to conquer nature. Only the stones remain, with a few scratches of primal engorgement, primitive erections (one from Bronze Age Finland Taylor captions-- the figure looks like he wears a baseball cap as he pumps his free arm in the air in enthusiasm or frustration, I add-- as "skier attempting intercourse with moose") and primordial lumps carved into bosomy, considerably callipgyian globs which make Oprah not of Lebanon look like Lindsay Lohan.
Taylor examines more monumental configurations, passage-tombs arrayed like vast granite wombs to overcome death's dark tyranny by inviting the release of injected light, or what my demure consort has labeled in relation to the Tibetan yab-yum depiction of male-female energies (euphemism or profundity) "another big-dick thing." Standing pillars as massive maximizers hoisted to the bearded sky gods of the incoming Iron Age, memorialize as physical graffiti what we many boast (males at least, and at least the randier matriarchs of today's females I imagine given the phallic plethora of what scholars of the Upper Paleolithic gingerly label as "spear-straighteners") still: size matters, quantity over quality.
Surplus labor indeed, long before Marx, who with Engels knew far less about early civilization's family, state, and society. Subsequent radical thinkers strive to fit their theories into bold suppositions. Julian Cope, who symbolizes for me the root of the border-crossing heathen, the gnomic, genial, genuine oracle of chant and ritual and wonder and fear from the heath, the outlier, the pagani left behind by the populi who bow to emperor and then Rome, compiled two monumental edifices of his own complex odyssey.
First he went across Britain, to photograph, contemplate, and puzzle over more than 300 prehistoric sites in "The Modern Antiquarian" (1997). Then, in a book I just tracked down (neither has appeared in the U.S., nor have his excellent earlier memoirs of his post-punk personal odyssey through hell and back, "Head On" and "Repossessed"), "The Megalithic European," he expands to Ireland and the Continent. By now, thousands of miles Cope's searched another 300-plus of these oldest of remaining markers left to attest to a newly aware humanity's permanence, "defiant acts against the transitory nature of life."
Cope does not cite Taylor, so I'm left wondering how he'd respond to his Neolithic critique. But, as a self-taught interpreter of megalithic culture, who insists that he will not write about where he has not been, Cope's imaginative powers circle into the venerable echoes of these mysterious traditions. On his gothic-folk, ambient-meets-krautrock, Mellotron-metal recordings, he seeks to recover distant voices. He channels what for the stodgy professor may alienate as much as the typical rock listener, but for me, even if I prefer his books to some of his sounds these past couple decades (I favor his pioneering post-punk propulsion), he represents for me an admirable model of inspired reinvention and daring restoration.
His later book's a bit calmer in its approach, as he shares his acceptance of what some early-Celtic Christians tried to do to keep some pagan customs before Rome and the Synod of Whitby shut down resistance to Celtic practices. For instance, these fringe dwellers, against the Saxon incursion, kept Passover's lunar date for commemorating Easter; pro-Roman clerics dispatched soon cracked down on the restive Celts. The reformers of the papal mission to keep Britain tidy demanded an end to observing the central but now movable Christian feast same as the Jewish spring barley harvest.
(As an aside, Exodus appears to scholars if not congregants or celebrants today as a vastly exaggerated account, a post-dated rationale. Although you'd be hard-pressed to discern Pesach's Canaanite "origins" as I looked up now if the festival originated for barley or wheat-- I get Shavout and Pesach jumbled with which grain commemorates which. Shavuot-turned-Pentecost marks the pilgrimage fifty days later at the end of the wheat gathering. By the way, if you opt as I did experimentally for Bing to fact-check, you get About.com first, which led me to "Ask the Rabbi" about Ur and Terah. Wikipedia's Canaan-rein as Liebensraum for echt ur-Zionists uber alles in its origin myth as "Origins of Pesach" coverage, I note "hoeuretically" in the spirit of Cope v.i. [=vide infra, "see below."])
My linguistic, spring-fed friskiness prefaces Cope's discussion of similarly Easter-bunnied, seder-egg plated, lamb-shanked feasts of fertility. Almost randomly, "Megalithic" in a sample passage reveals Cope's scope. He doesn't deign to guess unless he signals such, but his introduction does remind us of how as nomads drifted into farming, their fixed views turned into compelling reasons for them to stay. He glances at how Jerusalem's Holy Land, the rock of Golgotha, the Temple Mount, the shrines at Mecca literally stand for "inward-looking world centres" that may faith-fully settle a religion into its sturdy roots. This foundation may also be viewed fatally: contrast the Chinese destruction of Tibet's culture by the simple means of obliterating its shrines and overcrowding their land with foreigners bent on atheism.
Home bases mean enclosure of animals, crops, and ourselves. Control brings a heightened sensitivity, and a mythologized response, to one's territory. Terra turns turf, as it were.
Cope reflects how this vantage point might have taken on the weight that (as contemplates Taylor v.s., "vide supra, see above"), our ancestors imposed upon its trees (hewn down as was Queen Maacha's grove), vegetables (as dust no less than Queen Macha's bones under her grave mound), or as stones, all from this period two, three, four or even five thousand years ago that can be somewhat still seen today.
Generations may come and go, but the great oak or yew on the edge of the grove remains the same. Mother's back grows crooked and bent, but the valley where the sun rises at the hottest time of the year shows no sign of change whatsoever. In a physical world awash with new significance, the new settlers will return again and again to marvel at the permanence of landscape features that they may have seen only fleetingly during nomadic times.(24)
The rock, Cope suggests, where children played twenty years on may be pointed out to their children. One may have once fallen asleep, dreamed on that sunny rock, and told friends of what was vividly dreamt. This story may be related to one's own children. They may play on "parent's rock" and what was dream may in time turn ritual. Others may try to fall asleep on the rock, to dream dreams, and some eventually will recount a dream worth recounting to others in the settlement. So the practice begins, of the dreaming-rock, and this may be conjured by the community as "the stone that speaks."
I think of the Kaaba-- a enormous arena surrounding the cube embedding a now-half invisible, ancient, fabled, space-dropped junk-chunk draped in enormous gold black silk-- as a metaphor for what Cope seeks to unveil. Behind the sanctum sanctorum, the holy of holies, the curtain beckons to us as we who are not worthy line up to pay the unseen its due homage. Haddad no more than heathen me will never touch such a protected, venerated yet monitored monolith as that dominating her Levantine world and the wide tropical belt that cinctures more than a billion who, as Roy studies, spread their faith and mores across a globe where people never heard of the Qur'an until perhaps the Net, the news, their new neighbors.
The transmission of old stories and "just-so myths" gravitates for over 1500 years around a meteorite landed in Mecca. The respect paid by those coming from all over the globe on the "haj" to the Black Stone set in a suggestively recessed concavity in the side of the Kaaba's cube--a building attributed by the Qur'an to Abraham and Ishmael's efforts--we are told, does not constitute idolatry. Pilgrims also stone the devil at the pillars of Mina nearby. For once, the site was filled with competition.
Back when this shrine to Allah housed hundreds of gods and goddesses, "al-lat" was a term for a female deity as was "al-lah" for a male god, among hundreds before Islam. Remember how "elohim" created the heaven and the earth in the first lines of Genesis: the concept of many gods predates even in scripture the rule by the One before whom no others dare cut in line. Mecca for Mother-goddess worshipping Muhammed's clan, Koraites, these "Koeur-ites" assembled amid the houris, the "Houer-ees" of the doe-dark eyes who survive, perpetuated as 72 recurring maidens promised a Muslim male in the firmament.
This babble will become slighter clearer now. Concerning etymology and sexuality, chapter five in Cope's "Modern" compiles "The Book of Ur." Not Abraham's Ur of the Chaldees birthplace-- although the midrash of 1) how honest lil' Abe predicted his patriarchical covenant by despoiling dad Terah's shelf of the idols he sold at this crossroads down the road from the fallen Tower of Babel, and 2) this rabbi's expounding of how the Hebrew Ur=fire via G-d's predictably cranky, infernal payback bolsters Cope's thesis-- but in this "etymosophy," a list of words related to ancient goddess-wisdom. Cope offers three packed pages of miniscule if well-arranged (his books are easy to consult and fun to view) definitions.
Ur leads us to Eriu, Erin, and Erse-- alongside Eros-- as wordy relatives nearest my home-turf. Koeur, Hoeur, Bree, and Ma may be discerned even by the Lindsey Lohans and Oprah-fans of today as nestled into terms such as "core, corpse, corn, kernel, chord", as "her, whore, house, heretic, haughty, hurricane," as "Bridget, pregnant, pretty, pray, braid," and as "matrimony, marry, mate, Amazon, and Macha"--whom he links between the "pre-Keltic" formidable queen of Emain Macha in Ulster with a grove-spirit burnt by the River Kidron by her son King Asa in 1 Kings 15:13. That shows the scope of this elucidation.
While some of this may be suspect, and some lacks sources, this sort of cross-cultural, multi-lingual, ecumenical mindset inspires me. Taylor and other scholars concur that Cernunnos, the Celtic horned-god, may be the figure on the Gundestrup Cauldron that my own articles have examined. Cope reminds me that this god's title too comes down from "Coeur." He also notes how this horned god morphed, under Christians, into their depiction of the devil. Christians at this same time feared their rivals, the Jews, as Passover had to be wrenched apart from Easter, the Celts apart from their constructions of another form of Catholicity. And, the same Church feared the Jews and mocked Moses by a mistranslation of that pesky vowel-parsimonous Hebrew. St. Jerome attributed not "rays of light" post-Sinai, as celebrated at Shavuot fifty days after the Exodus-feast of deliverance as the giving of the Torah to Moses, but the "horns"--which then grew into those, by medieval antisemitic calumny, of the devil.
Salman Rushdie (in)famously wrote of similarly marginalized stories, dangerous tales relegated as heresy, and misattributions by those frantic that a Mother-goddess might endure her overthrow by the monotheist prophets and priests. "The Satanic Verses" considers this alternative history of feminist and devilish influences upon Muhammed's message and its promotion. Unlike Gimbutas, Taylor, or Cope, Rushdie's "what-if" assumptions even disguised as fiction and not possible fact met with those as eager to destroy him as prelate, rabbi, and imam have condemned their pagan, gentile, infidel dissenters.
I started today with a reflection on a forbidden zone. I end up at the same place. That which we bow to, circle as sacred, lift up as hallowed separates us from those who despise, envy, or admire us. This may be natural to our humanity, the side that outside of a redoubt in the Himalayas we all find ourselves clinging to out of fear as the ghosts rally, the famine deepens, the foes march, and the fires flare. Sacred calves at Sinai, neo-pagans at Stonehenge, reviewers as on this blog of "The Satanic Verses": I stepped aside from critical hosannas for a tale I found ramshackle, too flimsy to tower as a literary monument.
The latest in a series of sexual and ideological rebels, as with her fellow border-crosser Rushdie, Joumana Haddad might roam into where words come from, and how they form our ideas. She might, in her forthcoming book, for all I know find feminist fodder in attributions to Muhammed's own tribe, named after a Koeur-goddess, and a Hoeur-temple. Preserved as "haram" the Kaaba lurks under a big black veil ever since the Prophet's inventions, projections, and revampings. Twice today, once by chance I can't recall where, then eerily by Georges Perec as quoted in a cameo in Harvey's Ladakh, the same E.M. Cioran quote:
In every moment there is a prophet asleep...and when that prophet awakes there's a little more evil in the world.Women still stand apart, at Mecca and throughout temples and sanctuaries the world over. They don scarves, they cover their knees and elbows, they submit as Paul and haredi and the ummah expect. These women may welcome their hijab, their mehitzah, their cloister, their blinders from my male gaze.
Haddad refuses what many men claim that which other women claim they want. As an infidel, a suspect, a lapsed onlooker, I will forever lack full insight. I've been born into a category; its boundaries set me apart. My mind may strive to understand. My maleness keeps me ignorant. Names can never hurt me?
Photo: Taylor (198-99) interprets this Letnitsa 4c BCE silver-gilt bridle from today's Bulgaria imaginatively. I figured it fit today's April (Cope links this word to Bree) Fool's atmosphere of topsy as turvy. Taylor conjectures that this dramatizes not a "'hierogamy' as sacred marriage" but a seduction of a woman who plies a man with drink from the vessel held by her accomplice. The dominant female straddles the man, compliant as he sits and she squats. The attendant holds a leafy branch over the face of the woman on top, so the man cannot see who she is. It may be simply love is blind, but Taylor suspects mischief's Amazonially afoot. Barefoot, or underfoot, Amazons were fabled by Herodotus to lurk up from Danubia along the Don (both keep the name of one of the most ancient of female goddesses) river, east of Scythia in Sauromatia. ("Mas"= an Indo-European root word for softness and fleshiness as in the Irish word for "thigh"-- a+mazos= without a breast in ancient Greek.)
(Portions of this will appear soon tidied, trimmed, and tamed into censored, if perky book reviews for Taylor and Cope on Amazon US.)
Labels:
Arabs,
archeology,
Bible,
Catholicism,
Celtic Buddhism,
Celtic lore,
Classics,
feminism,
Indo-European,
Irish Middle East connections,
Islam,
Judaism,
Julian Cope,
My book reviews,
Sade,
sexuality
Monday, October 18, 2010
"The Marquis de Sade: a Study by Simone de Beauvoir with selections from his writings": Review
"Must We Burn Sade?" de Beauvoir's 1951-52 essay, cautiously answers no. She explains how this most notorious libertine sought a sort of liberty from convention. He tried to wrestle and pummel and seduce Nature into submission; he failed to escape his body and his desires once slaked returned to torment him, and the cycle escalated as he tried to overcome the indifference of Nature to man's most outrageous actions, and as he tried to resist the powers of the State who imprisoned him for his dangerous actions, not only his infamous writings.
He created in his surname a byword for perversion, yet as an author, "talking to himself" at great length he prattled on about political philosophy as often as the other activities that earned him censorship. Simone de Beauvoir places the Marquis de Sade's struggle within the difficulty we all have: to stay autonomous but to aspire to a universal condition, an integration into a community. This may turn as it did in real life and on the page for de Sade into a twisted utopia bent on orgies, infamies, and communal property and no claim to one's body, and as de Beauvoir shows, he failed to "turn the real world of hard fact into a theater."
She suggests that he suffered a form of "autism." That is, he could not forget himself in the transports of the violent, the idealistic, or the erotic, and he lacked being "genuinely aware of the other person." He wore himself out inventing new ways to assault the body that seemed a barrier to be overcome in the way to freedom. He grew obese, he prattled, yet his contradictions forced himself to compel others to watch himself, for even in prison, he invented an audience. "In order to amaze or frighten oneself, one must observe oneself from a distance, through foreign eyes."
De Beauvoir reminds us of his opposition to state-sponsored capital punishment, his uneasy switch from pre-Revolution pleasure to post-guillotine depredation, and his many irreconcilable positions on matters of the mind and body, the State and the individual, law and anarchy. "In choosing eroticism, Sade chose the make-believe." There he could live without being disappointed by a world unable to understand his strange rebellion. She concludes that he "drained to the dregs the moment of selfishness, injustice, and misery, and he insisted upon its truth. The supreme value of his testimony is that it disturbs us." He forces us to wonder again how much we truly care for each other, if there is no God and if Nature does rule supreme over our destinies.
De Beauvoir more than once draws our attention to the "Pensee," a side of de Sade that the modern reader may not anticipate. He wrote: "God, then, no more exists than colors do for men born blind; and man is, then, as right to maintain there is no God as the blind man is to hold that there are no colors, for colors are not real things but simply matters of convention and all matters of convention acquire reality in men's minds only in so far as they affect their senses and are capable of being understood by them." He goes on to argue how our senses cannot perceive God, and that God has no reality in terms of whatever people can comprehend.
(As an aside, a new book by Guy Deutscher, "Through the Language Glass," explains the color convention in how different cultures invent or lack vocabulary for the spectrum; see my review in October 2010. See also my review of Pierre Klossowski's "Sade My Neighbor," which de Beauvoir critiques for its reliance on a Freudian reduction of de Sade's reaction to his hated mother.)
This edition works better for giving us the essay by de Beauvoir than the anthologized passages that here follow her article. The prose selections from the Marquis included here after "Faut-il brûler Sade?" have been superseded by fuller, unexpurgated translations. Presumably due to censorship laws or fear of prosecution, this anthology was published 1953-54 with careful renderings of a few political, religious, sexual, and philosophical excerpts chosen by Paul Dinnage. The original French often remains to disguise the lubricity, the homosexuality, and assorted brands of "sodomy," while the atheism, moralizing, and murder is intact in English.
These selections, often less engrossing than dull, give some sense for the curious reader of the range of his thought, and the narrowness of its depths, but as in the case of poor Olympe tossed by her companions (after two hours of outrages) into a volcano simply because she "bores" them seem more puerile than philosophical, compared to the "Pensee" above. He cites Voltaire to sum up his own outlook: "Love is the fabric of nature embroidered by the imagination." De Sade may bore you more than you might suspect, but as in the excerpt above, he does cloak within his verbosity moments that you will remember, if not the ones you might have first expected.
(Posted to Lunch.com & Amazon US 10-13-10. For more on Klossowski, search by that keyword on my blog, and see Benjamin Ivry's "ArtForum" 2001 essay, reproduced today on Words Undone here. In turn, Ivry wrote a wonderful article on Simone Weil in the Forward that I blogged about here: "Simone Weil: Chain-Smoking, Self-Starving, Jewish Mystical Malcontent?". That leads to my review of Grahame Davies' astonishingly poised novel comparing and contrasting Weil's ambition with that of a latter-day Welsh language activist, "Everything Must Change.". Bookers, Pulitzers, and Nobels have been granted for far less. I rarely praise a novel so, but this I do.)
He created in his surname a byword for perversion, yet as an author, "talking to himself" at great length he prattled on about political philosophy as often as the other activities that earned him censorship. Simone de Beauvoir places the Marquis de Sade's struggle within the difficulty we all have: to stay autonomous but to aspire to a universal condition, an integration into a community. This may turn as it did in real life and on the page for de Sade into a twisted utopia bent on orgies, infamies, and communal property and no claim to one's body, and as de Beauvoir shows, he failed to "turn the real world of hard fact into a theater."
She suggests that he suffered a form of "autism." That is, he could not forget himself in the transports of the violent, the idealistic, or the erotic, and he lacked being "genuinely aware of the other person." He wore himself out inventing new ways to assault the body that seemed a barrier to be overcome in the way to freedom. He grew obese, he prattled, yet his contradictions forced himself to compel others to watch himself, for even in prison, he invented an audience. "In order to amaze or frighten oneself, one must observe oneself from a distance, through foreign eyes."
De Beauvoir reminds us of his opposition to state-sponsored capital punishment, his uneasy switch from pre-Revolution pleasure to post-guillotine depredation, and his many irreconcilable positions on matters of the mind and body, the State and the individual, law and anarchy. "In choosing eroticism, Sade chose the make-believe." There he could live without being disappointed by a world unable to understand his strange rebellion. She concludes that he "drained to the dregs the moment of selfishness, injustice, and misery, and he insisted upon its truth. The supreme value of his testimony is that it disturbs us." He forces us to wonder again how much we truly care for each other, if there is no God and if Nature does rule supreme over our destinies.
De Beauvoir more than once draws our attention to the "Pensee," a side of de Sade that the modern reader may not anticipate. He wrote: "God, then, no more exists than colors do for men born blind; and man is, then, as right to maintain there is no God as the blind man is to hold that there are no colors, for colors are not real things but simply matters of convention and all matters of convention acquire reality in men's minds only in so far as they affect their senses and are capable of being understood by them." He goes on to argue how our senses cannot perceive God, and that God has no reality in terms of whatever people can comprehend.
(As an aside, a new book by Guy Deutscher, "Through the Language Glass," explains the color convention in how different cultures invent or lack vocabulary for the spectrum; see my review in October 2010. See also my review of Pierre Klossowski's "Sade My Neighbor," which de Beauvoir critiques for its reliance on a Freudian reduction of de Sade's reaction to his hated mother.)
This edition works better for giving us the essay by de Beauvoir than the anthologized passages that here follow her article. The prose selections from the Marquis included here after "Faut-il brûler Sade?" have been superseded by fuller, unexpurgated translations. Presumably due to censorship laws or fear of prosecution, this anthology was published 1953-54 with careful renderings of a few political, religious, sexual, and philosophical excerpts chosen by Paul Dinnage. The original French often remains to disguise the lubricity, the homosexuality, and assorted brands of "sodomy," while the atheism, moralizing, and murder is intact in English.
These selections, often less engrossing than dull, give some sense for the curious reader of the range of his thought, and the narrowness of its depths, but as in the case of poor Olympe tossed by her companions (after two hours of outrages) into a volcano simply because she "bores" them seem more puerile than philosophical, compared to the "Pensee" above. He cites Voltaire to sum up his own outlook: "Love is the fabric of nature embroidered by the imagination." De Sade may bore you more than you might suspect, but as in the excerpt above, he does cloak within his verbosity moments that you will remember, if not the ones you might have first expected.
(Posted to Lunch.com & Amazon US 10-13-10. For more on Klossowski, search by that keyword on my blog, and see Benjamin Ivry's "ArtForum" 2001 essay, reproduced today on Words Undone here. In turn, Ivry wrote a wonderful article on Simone Weil in the Forward that I blogged about here: "Simone Weil: Chain-Smoking, Self-Starving, Jewish Mystical Malcontent?". That leads to my review of Grahame Davies' astonishingly poised novel comparing and contrasting Weil's ambition with that of a latter-day Welsh language activist, "Everything Must Change.". Bookers, Pulitzers, and Nobels have been granted for far less. I rarely praise a novel so, but this I do.)
Thursday, September 30, 2010
Clive Bloom's "Gothic Histories": Book Review
Drawn to the hallucinatory, enchanted by the morbid, the gothic sensibility mixes incarceration with necromancy, technology with architecture, vampires with séances. The bizarre and wild, Professor Bloom explains in this spirited survey, emerged with the European fear of modernity. Beginning with Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto in 1764, authors disturbed by the loss of control presented by democracy, rebellion, and technology reacted. They revived antiquarian settings, scientific subversion, and macabre predicaments. How could a style of ecclesiastical architecture claim the same adjective as erotic and violent tales? Medievalism and a return to Catholic caricatures compete with God-denying, sexual, and sadistic torment. Bloom accounts for their common ambiguity. Gothic set the “mind in relationship to the supernatural, the universal and the divine.” (4) Gothic tropes preceded psychology by a century and a half as they revealed hidden, repressed, and alienated fears. The dead return as if alive, the imprisoned claw towards release, and the restrained writhe against their bonds.
This introduction moves rapidly through the two-hundred-and-fifty years of this genre. English and German writers sparked the movement. Female sensibilities imbued early British stories, while Teutonic terror tended toward brooding Byronic anti-heroes, the occult, the metaphysical, and the irrational. “Gothic horror,” Bloom elaborates, “is about that which should not be.” (64) Its characters face the abyss and the end of sanity. Their moment of awful recognition allows the spectator to enjoy a frisson of annihilation while the distance between action and witness toys with the safety of the viewer. A reader glimpses the “otherness of cosmic indifference” which lies at the core of the gothic encounter.
The Romantic era rushed into emotional, despairing, destructive tendencies that revolution and industrialization hastened. Frankenstein's “monster’s self-questioning is the first real expression during the nineteenth century of the existential crisis of those who felt they were abandoned by God and who sought revenge for this abandonment.” (71) Mary Shelley’s story roams a ruined landscape, articulating the bewilderment of the stranger, wandering where salvation eludes those who never asked to be created. Her predecessors toyed with humanist progress as an answer, but Shelley and later gothic authors began to stand for refusal. Denial of transcendence and a rejection of liberation darkened tales.
The French Revolution tinted this gothic tone. Social collapse, feared by the aristocracy, gave way to psychic decay. Penetration and violation flooded the vulnerable self. The body turned into a prison. Tales told “the language of ruin.” Bloom defines this mode: “Gothic is the map of a border, a mapping of the edge always illuminated by the shadow of night and the rays of the moon.” (79) The gothic forays into that unknown territory within the self, he adds, predicted what psychoanalysis would later confirm. Instead of goodness and creativity, violent will and self-destructive tendencies lurked.
By the middle of the nineteenth century, however, these themes turned clichés. Thomas Love Peacock and Jane Austen satirized sinister storylines soon after Shelley’s success. Poe, Dickens, the Bronte sisters sketched upon the templates of such imaginative novels as Charles Maturin’s nihilistic Melmoth. Both wordsmiths and hacks -- encouraged by a demand among the newly literate for pulp fiction and melodramatic theater -- broadened gothic conventions into detective novels, romances, thrillers, and mysteries. Such remain the patterns for today’s diverse and gloomy entertainments. Theosophy, mesmerism, spiritualism, Marxism, and the rise of soulless corporations that live on forever: these Victorian innovations also furthered in surprising ways the cultural and ideological rule of the gothic.
Although the gothic mood domesticated as it infiltrated the city and the household to inflict its terrors, vaudeville emerged as another stage for its shudders of delight. In turn, film inherited the dramaturgical patterns familiar to those who attended séances or sideshows. Early cinema spread the appeal of the uncanny. Vampires, automatons, and undead filled the screens of Europe with a visual language that illuminated the literary and theatrical applications of an elongated, ectoplasmic, distorted conflict.
Bloom conjures up its cinematic captivation: “This is a weird world of shadow and light, theatrical make up and the stagy rhetorical gestures of silent film, but it is also a powerful world of floating images and of monsters who combine stillness with spastic urgency, their spectral gliding and glances to camera the basis of dreamlike fear.” (174)
Movies channel today’s dissimulations. Our printed stories, Bloom avers, rely upon vampires far more than monsters. He suggests in passing why this may appeal to their largely female readership. Vampires combine “male domination with female empowerment.” Also, they can blend in better than ghouls or zombies into everyday haunts. Their “protean nature allows them to appear in bars or nightclubs as well as high schools.” (187) This book’s short scope hurries its final chapter. Bloom hastens over the persistence of the gothic essence in gaming, cyberspace, music (if he errs in my opinion in crediting the very few bands he does as primarily Goth), sexuality, and fashion.
He addresses gothic transformation. Horror has moved from the external force taking away a body, or coming back from the dead. Instead of the gothic itself, a new kind of “soft-machinic body horror” permeates the contemporary body. It fears submission to a force that impels it by “torture and extreme violence” as the body “is split open and anatomized.” De Sade delineated vast labyrinthine dungeons where victims were immured; today’s gothic interiors make bodies themselves “the new architectural spaces of fear.” (182)
Currently, Bloom finds the gothic energy less in bestselling spin-offs than a corollary culture that horror films and television have spawned. Video games enable fans to enter spaces of fear. “So vivid can these games become that some of their creators try to build in the sort of mental confusion to their players that might be expected in real life encounters with monsters in order to enhance the imaginative and dream-like quality of play.” (189) Rather than escaping reality, Bloom argues that those dressing up, filling dance floors, or losing themselves in role-playing continue a venerable tradition of excess, artifice, and safe play that frustrates the mundane and opens up the inexplicable.
This is a brisk primer, with generous excerpts from primary sources, free of jargon or academic posturing. Selected reading lists guide inquirers, while Professor Bloom spans a lot in a little book. It is recommended to anyone curious about why the gothic craze began, why it has lasted so long, and how it continues to translate its shape-shifting spells.
(Featured 6-15-10 on New York Journal of Books; brief summation not quoting from the above review posted 6-15 to Amazon US.)
Tuesday, February 16, 2010
Camille Paglia's "Sexual Personae": Book Review
Her first chapter dazzles. 39 pages astonished me with her passion. I wondered if she'd sustain this intensity. "Out with stereotypes, feminism proclaims. But stereotypes are the west's stunning sexual personae, the vehicles of art's assault against nature. The moment there is imagination, there is myth. We may have to accept an ethical cleavage between art and reality, tolerating horrors, rapes, and mutilations in art that we would not tolerate in society. For art is our message from the beyond, telling us what nature is up to. Not sex but cruelty is the great neglected or suppressed item on the modern humanistic agenda. We must honor the chthonian but not necessarily yield to it."(39)So section one concludes.
She surveys the history of these personae in the West. Prehistory, Egypt (a fine evocation of its eerie gaze, its monolithic agenda), Greece & Rome, then a skip over to the Renaissance, the Enlightenment, and especially the Romantic and Victorian eras. Much of it reads like a literary critical thesis (as you'd expect from Yale UP) and this tone may have discouraged many attracted by the initial fireworks of the start of her show. I finished this in a hardcover, issued before Paglia's fame, before her leatherjacketed stance adorned mass-market paperbacks full of her essays that followed the surprise breakthrough of what's an erudite, energetic, and weighty tome. On it, a blurb by mentor Harold Bloom shows Paglia's Yale connection, a few other intellectuals nod to her, and the book's presentation's much more sober.
This demands attention to its dense contents. After these, me coming two decades too late to its initial and excited reader reception, the pace can slacken over 673 long pages. Still, I always admired Paglia for her attention to lively details within the usual academic accrual of texts, citations, theories, and analysis.
For instance, she enlivens the Dionysian cult of "sparagmos" or tearing the god's body in ritual ecstasy to devour or scatter it. Osiris, Jesus, the sacrifice of the Mass: these combine with cannibalism and dismembering a grocery chicken and oral sex. Paglia reminds us how "swallowing the god's parts was an act of physical love." (93) Then she turns to a news account of a plane crash, full of body parts. In such sensations of transformation, she excavates "the grotesque truth about reality."
She returns to Rousseau but champions Sade. "For Sade, sex is violence. Violence is the authentic spirit of mother nature." (235) She has little patience for caressing the urges we all are trapped within. "We are skin drums on which nature beats." (95)
She tracks the will-to-power of the Western male. The "Birth of Venus" reminds her of today's pornography. Wolf-whistles appear in ancient comedy as well as on the corner from leering men. Her take on stodgy pieties within academia can be bracing: "The reform of a college English department cuts no ice down at the corner garage." (22) As a working-class Catholic girl turned Ivy League Ph.D., Paglia speaks to her audience in a more diverse, and more innovative, fashion than her colleagues content to preach diversity from behind a safely tenured stance. Her outsider status lecturing at a little-known college when this book was published gives her a fresher, sassier style that's not the usual fare from a professor.
She compares the etymology of matzah with Amazon; she chastises those who'd not get their bridges built by macho men in our brutish society that rewards brawn. She compares women's intimate smell with fish, and takes this as a humbling, persistent reminder of our primeval origins. To enliven her broader thesis, she recruits Black Flag roach motels, Lucille Ball, Bob Dylan, Gracie Allen, and the Beach Boys.
She can be so taken with her arguments that they lose slight clarity. She delineates how rapists claim "she wanted it, she asked for it." But she then elides over how this can clearly prove that "{c]oercion requires free will, in both homosexual and heterosexual acts." (254)
The closing sections tend to drag once her foundations have been established, and I found the later chapters stodgier. Their high points diminished. But they deserve to be quoted. Blake's "child-slaves advance from childhood to old age without passing through adult virility. As in the penalty card of capitalist Monopoly: 'Go directly to Jail. Do not pass Go. Do not collect $200.'" (271)
Tackling Virginia Woolf's query about why so many books showed men wondering what women want rather than vice-versa: "from the beginning of time men have been struggling with the threat of woman's domination. The flood of books was prompted not by woman's weakness but by her strength, her complexity and impenetrability, her dreadful omnipresence." Then, Pagila leaps as she may from explication into her own poetry. "No man has yet been born, even Jesus himself, who was not spun from a pitiful speck of plasma to a conscious being on the secret loom from within a woman's body. That body is the cradle and soft pillow of woman's love, but it is also the torture rack of nature." (296)
Later on Woolf, within her final chapter on Dickinson, Paglia challenges us. "Culture, I said, was invented by men, because it is by culture that they make themselves whole." (653) She notes how rare's a woman even today "driven by artistic or intellectual obsession, that self-mutilating derangement of social relationship which, in its alternate form of crime and ideation, is the disgrace and glory of the human species." (653-4) This is not your usual professor seeking security by another footnoted monograph.
Instead, the reason Paglia's work drives into the popular culture's zeitgeist's due to her ambition, her push to plunge ideas from herself into us by a primal, erotic, and death-haunted penetration. Deep into power-play in Coleridge's "Christabel," Paglia diverts us a typical moment: "Murder here is sexual intercourse, for sex is how mother nature kills us, how she enslaves the imagination. Nature draws first blood, of virgins, of us." (335-6)
In her chapter on Poe, when reaching "The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym," similar observations wake a perhaps weary reader. "The white curtain over life's mystery parts, and the frail soul-boat plunges into the birth canal. At degree zero, a seminal torrent rushes eternally into the womb of matter. The smothering white shower is phenomena sinking back to primeval origins. White noise, white hole, the birth and death of stars: this spectacle of soundless sensory deprivation is a Romantic triumph. All hysteria resolves into oppressive calm." (579) From this, you won't get much of a context, if unfamiliar with Poe, about the novella in question, but you may well remember such a passage long after you close a dozen other commentaries on Poe written by lesser colleagues.
She can, finally, even make Henry James' "obscure late style," never a favorite of mine, a tad less oppressive. "Page by page, the metaphors are sharp points of visibility that, like a matador's cape, make the reader lunge past a protective center. Their function is to pretend something is being revealed, when it is not. The metaphors are 'apotropaia,' like the ugly gorgoneion hung on the oven door to ward off evil spirits. The reader, both invited guest and intruder, is lured and misled. We are pulled into a labyrinth or meander, then left in the dark." (620) I felt better after my own grad school difficulties with James after all.
And in such a way, this skilled teacher shows how she reacts to texts, and how we can pull our own anxieties (as with her mentor Bloom) into our own reactions to many books and poems and myths. The length of the resulting volume and the depth of her explorations did tire me out, but in this ambitious expedition, for the patient reader, sights of wonder do emerge out of the murk and the chasms. And, you'll never find so many mentions, if applicable for once, of "chthonian" outside a Scrabble or crossword puzzlers convention, I predict. (P.S. I wish she'd finish the follow-up to the 20th century she promised to write circa 1990.)(Posted to Amazon US 12-7-09)
Tuesday, January 1, 2008

Sade's "Dialogue Between a Priest & a Dying Man"
Happy New Year. Perhaps for those readers a morning after a debauch, this excerpt from de Sade's "Dialogue between a Priest and a Dying Man" (1782) might perk up festivities. Reading Jay Michaelson (see yesterday's blog) about "The New Atheism" reminded me about this argument employing Occam's razor. Sade, like Gibbon and Voltaire, appears to have been among the first extant skeptics who managed to elude the censors and further the causes of their various Enlightenments. How far have we advanced or regressed since? For better or worse? The jury's out, but I welcome the disputation. Of course, as le Comte would find a decade after he penned "Dialogue," Goya's "el sueno del razón produce monstruos" would unveil the bloody hand of revenge beneath Liberté's exposed bosom, once the barricades were won. The guillotine and the tumbril showed, perhaps, how difficult it'd be to "refine your reason."
Most of Sade's work was burned by his son. Much of remains in French can be found on the Net (at the site below); in English we electronically curious only have translated at that site this Dialogue (which deserves a look) and Anthony Walker's reductively ameliorative but lively summation of the philosopher-rake-prisoner's notorious career.
http://www.sade-ecrivain.com/docs/sade.html
PRIEST - Who is there can penetrate God’s vast and infinite designs regarding man, and who can grasp all that makes up the universal scheme?
DYING MAN - Anyone who simplifies matters, my friend, anyone, above all, who refrains from multiplying causes in order to confuse effects all the more. What need have you of a second difficulty when you are unable to resolve the first, and once it is possible that Nature may have all alone done what you attribute to your god, why must you go looking for someone to be her overlord? The cause and explanation of what you do not understand may perhaps be the simplest thing in the world. Perfect your physics and you will understand Nature better, refine your reason, banish your prejudices and you’ll have no further need of your god.
http://www.sade-ecrivain.com/Dialogue-Between-a-Priest-and-a-Dying-Man.html
Image credit: with my "safe search on," there's not a lot of striking pictorials for "Sade"-- 936 images of Halloween costumes, a French rock band, salacious 1960s B-movie art, stills from the film "Quills," or the "Smooth Operator" chanteuse. Quaint to see it hawked by a pamphleteer (note title's changed from generic "Man" to daring "Atheist"), "the finest in rabble-rousing literature since 1984," but there it is, $2 or 5 copies for $8, all 16 pp.: http://www.seesharppress.com/
Monday, December 10, 2007

Georges Bataille's "Erotism" Book Review
My wife saw me reading this and mistook it for a dirty book. I replied that it was densely argued, far from erotica, and would more likely put most readers to sleep rather than delay them from such. Bataille, as with many French thinkers-- at least in translation-- takes a convoluted, intricate, and often bewildering intellectual journey that proves demanding for even the erudite scholar or patient seeker to follow. This combines a 150-page monograph expounding his thesis with shorter talks and reviews that compress it. He argues that the moment of sexual abandon into the "little death" represents the closest we mortals will come to death in this life. The moment of ultimate "knowing" another peers into an abyss. Life engendered by this action triggers our own obsolescence. The contradictions abound at this "pinnacle of being." (276)
Discontinuous individuals "we perish in isolation in the midst of an incomprehensible adventure," but we seek nostalgia, in a primal continuity beyond our mortality. (15) But we know such a search dooms us only to knowledge of our limits within the flesh and time. The erotic (why the book is in fact not titled "Eroticism" as a translation of "L'Erotisme" eludes me, for Bataille uses "eroticism" and not "erotism" as rendered in English here) triggers abandonment. "Human life cannot follow the movement which draws it toward death without a shudder and without trying to cheat." (146) Sneaking about, we take paths of marriage, orgy, sacrifice, religion, crime, or -- at their root, violence against our higher nature as our bodies pull us down.
Bataille links pleasure with taboo, and the tension between an order that restricts freedom and a carnival that celebrates excess structures his anthropology. "In human terms the taboo never makes an appearance without suggesting sexual pleasure, nor does the pleasure without evoking the taboo." (108) Going out of bounds charges one's reaction.
"Transgression from what makes us orderly and human and civilized, the workaday world, reminds us of our animal nature. Our "sexual exuberance" thus "prevents us from being reduced to mere things;" our human nature, "geared to specific ends in work, tends to make things of us at the expense of our sexual exuberance." (158) In a review of Kinsey's then-novel studies, Bataille unearths a statistic that those who are thieves have many more weekly orgasms than working folks, although for the rich the amount of luxury and licentiousness appears to be considerably larger as well. From this, he supports his model that the more we work, the less we play. The energy exacted and the expense required for common people vs. the leisured classes reminds me of that curmudgeon from Regency England who of the sexual act mused more or less how "the pleasure is momentary, the expense extravagant, and the position ridiculous."
Nonetheless, when we have sex, we invest differently than we do when we save our hard-earned cash. Spending rather than getting, we reverse the usual accumulation of wealth that rewards our daily labors. This opposite conduct upends our urge to possess and retain; reproduction and courtship, Bataille ponders, lavish color and splendor beyond rational expectation. This erotic excess disorders our routine. "Nakedness wrecks the decency conferred by our clothes." (170)
The frisson of setting bonds only to strain against them illustrates this dark energy released by sex, violence, and their inherent if often subtle or repressed link in our bodies and minds. Out of this negativity comes the body's atavistic challenge to calm reason and enforced dogma. He quotes de Sade: "The best way of enlarging and multiplying one's desires is to try to limit them." (48) Bataille argues that disorder represented by de Sade stands not to be admired, but as a logical if worst-case scenario of silence and unrestrained appetites written down-- in prison. In two essays, he explores the paradox of the Marquis. De Sade attacks in his unreasonable assaults not fools and hypocrites (Bataille counters against those who would praise his predecessor) but the normal, decent person. He's like the sun, "intolerable to the naked eye." (171) Why we should then read him appears less clear; Bataille acknowledges in passing Simone de Beauvoir's critique but seems to shirk the combat. "Misunderstanding and revulsion from the generality of mankind are the only results of de Sade's ideas," he admits rather perplexingly. (191) We cannot applaud him, but refusing to congratulate Sade we at least understand the logic of our stance. For, "this lack of understanding at least keeps" the "essence of Sade's "ideas intact, whilst the admiration accorded him today by some few people proves very little since it does not commend them to the voluptuary's solitude." Bataille appears to leave Sade in the Bastille, to rage on impotently, pen on paper rather than penis in power.
For those of us less inclined to sadism than tenderness, what of our relationships? Bataille reminds us how desire kindles fear. We long to keep our beloved's body always, remain stricken with terror at letting go of our partner, and for some the path from possession in ecstasy to killing rather than surrendering one's lover can be a short step. "The violence of love leads to tenderness, but it brings into the striving of one's heart towards one another the same quality of disorder, the same taste for losing consciousness and the same after-taste of death that is found in the mutual desire for each other's body." (241) Even in the storybook happy home and the domesticated bed, Bataille detects danger.
Tenderness can find balance with violence, but without violence, "sexual love could not have lent its vocabulary as it has done to describe the transports of the mystics." (243) Essays here explore the difficulty that Catholic priests suffer when attempting to equate mystical transport with a sexual orgasm that they vow to refuse-- the contradictions here intrigue Bataille-- who does not mention this, but I believe that he himself lost his faith after he left the seminary for a failed love affair! (Compare his disciple Pierre Klossowski, whose own criticism of Sade shows how much he followed his master in setting Sade's endless vituperation against an order that could not be overcome, for if all were permitted to all, there would be nothing for Sade's selfish libertines to fulminate against.)
He matches ecstasy with death. In a preface to an erotic novel, "Madame Edwarda," he anticipates "the oneness of extreme pleasure and extreme pain, the oneness of being and dying, of knowledge finishing with this dazzling prospect and final darkness." (267) Annihilation depends on our awareness in sex of how close we can teeter towards the emptiness of utter dissolution. Does this bring us near God? While Bataille denied that the priests could by their very chastity approach this ultimate truth, he asserts that in sexual transport we might be carried very close to this apotheosis. Any God worth belief, Bataille hints, must transcend any definition. Even, or especially, a non-believer (I cannot claim him as an atheist, however, based on this book) like himself knows that God must destroy even Bataille's attempt to define God as "nothing at all." For, "we cannot add to language without impunity the word which transcends words, the word God." I am reminded of the cabalistic concept of "Ein Sof," the Hebrew "without end" that defines the indefinable Power.
"What mysticism cannot put into words, eroticism says"-- perhaps in sharing the same silence in which Bataille imagines our last second of life. (269) In "the terrible syncopated dance" of memento mori we also recall our momentary sexual escape from the flesh. "And the moment of torment will always come: how would we overcome it if it were to fail? But of all being ready and open-- for death, joy or torment-- unreservedly open and dying, painful and happy, is there already with its shadowed light, and this light is divine-- and the cry that being -- vainly?-- tries to utter from a twisted mouth is an immense alleluia, lost in endless silence." (270-1) I doubt if Carthusians would ever read this passage in their stony cells, but they might be surprised, when they reach their eternal reward, to speak with Bataille about their shared contemplation of what can only be said in silence. "In the end the articulate man confesses his own impotence." (276) I wonder what the author of the surrealist abandon of "The Story of an Eye" will have to say to the monks about their common experience of ecstasy.
(Posted in shorter form to Amazon US today.)
Labels:
atheism,
belief,
Carthusians,
death,
erotica,
French literature,
Georges Bataille,
library,
Literary criticism,
My book reviews,
philosophy,
Pierre Klossowski,
Sade,
sexuality
Friday, December 7, 2007
Edward Shorter's "Written in the Flesh": Book Review

Edward Shorter's "Written in the Flesh" Book Review
Surprisingly absent from any local public and many a university library, I had to seek out this book subtitled "A History of Desire"-- it deserves a wider readership. Perhaps the fact it comes from the U of Toronto may account for its relative scarcity, or a franker tone (award winning in Canada to boot) suited more to a less puritanical audience than that supposed in America. But, such generalizations, as Shorter, a Toronto-based medical historian with many previous books, would lecture us, now can be revealed as false. He notes, two decades ago, how a "random national survey" of 2700 of my fellow Americans had found about half of them claiming "between eleven and sixty sex partners." Shorter finds "these lifetime numbers of sex partners similar to those of Casanova."
Well, although I confess being well below average here, as one of the final have-nots coming of age during what this book also documents as the "total" collapse in the 1970s of premarital inhibitions (I assure you it was not for many of those with whom I attended starting in the fall of '79 my purportedly Catholic college, alas), and therefore I lagged way behind many of my polled compatriots by 1988-- let alone what will be 2008 standards. Nonetheless, since the 1860s or so, what we tend to think of as the sexual revolution of the later Sixties actually began to stir.
Why so late? The Romantics, Shorter argues, tended to swoon towards matters of the spirit and emotions, while discounting the demands of the body. Not until the Industrial Revolution lured many from the prying community and the surveilled farmhouse where ten to a bed a family might itch and stink and scratch (these are all enlivened with relish) could many men and women find a "room of one's own." With the collapse of the hindrances of dogma and disease, eroticism began to flourish. Yet, Virginia Woolf's assertion that "On or about December 1910 human nature changed" may be a bit delayed. Shorter cites her "Old Bloomsbury" paper for Lytton Strachey's fingerpointing at Vanessa Woolf's white dress with the stain that he ascertained and queried aloud as "Semen?" This admission triggered talk of sex, and as the Bloomsbury crowd overcame their reticence then, so I do now. This kindled "The Great Breakout."
This publicizing of sexual desire took a century. The avant-garde, both hetero- and homosexual, pioneered such talk and behavior, but it took a gradual transmission and often underground methods of expression to spread. It's tricky to base any study of sexual behavior on what we can uncover; Shorter cautions how extracting what John Boswell celebrates as "the bisexuality of the time" from a few cynical Roman poets equates with observers a century from now "relying upon the comic monologues of Chris Rock as evidence" for our own sexual mores. (64)
I have wondered how "everyday" people find out about sexual practices that once were thought outré but now anything goes; Shorter offers little beyond the obvious here. Perhaps urbanization and mass media led to the ease of discovering the frisson if not the shock of the new, but Shorter tends to head off into the S&M and gay subcultures towards the later stages of the past century. (As a relevant aside, Shorter excels on Sade: his "social allegories are not stroke manuals" [211]. The top rules the bottom, the exchange of power truly pricks the domineering over the submissive. He reminds us that, as with the term masochism, sadism took a sensationalist twist distorting the concept when Krafft-Ebing published in 1886 Psychopathia sexualis.) So much of what became licit or licentious depended on one's circle. Tongue kissing proved extremely rare until not too long ago, fellatio almost unheard of for much of the past, and stimulation of the nipples quite uncommon for most of our ancestors. Shorter seems to have his own obsession with male nipples not getting their fair share of the bedroom action, by the way-- this predilection's rarely been noted. To each his own.
College grads appear to have led the way towards liberalizing sex, so perhaps they picked up on the same hints that their professors and peers of Shorter must have. I propose Richard Dawkins' social "memes" could be a model to apply here. I suppose Shorter, as with any historian, must rely upon the fragments of court trials, diaries, pottery shards, and doggerel which, until recently, tended to be all the documentation we have for thousands if not millions of years about how humans before us regarded sexual activity. We have no trace of all the pick-up lines and pillow talk and lover's spats and pub putdowns that could tell us so much. Only inquisitions, testimonies, boasts, confessions, and rumor. Or, has this always been the case with what goes on if not behind closed doors than at least in whispers meant for another pair of ears only?
New notes, and not merely new arrangements, make sex like music. Shorter argues that earlier people had indeed an erotic baseline, a minimum of a charge that would raise sparks, but that many men and women, after the fall of Rome, had perhaps no idea that the body could be used so variably. They did not appear to let themselves go wild. The fear of God, of death, of recrimination suppressed much erotic potency. This state of repression and ignorance lasted nearly until our own century for all but the few who left some gasp of pleasure in the few traces we can find from the past millennia of Western Civ (the East provides another tale beyond the scope of this short book.) He quotes D.H. Lawrence's Connie Chatterly in his 1928 novel: "'The human body is only just coming to life,' she said. 'With the Greeks it gave a lovely flicker, then Plato and Aristotle killed it, and Jesus finished it off. But now the body is coming really to life, is really rising from the tomb.'" (147)
He implies that Foucault's "social construction," Lillian Federman's theory of a butch-femme embedded dynamic, or any "third sex" circa 1700 are all themselves weak arguments compared to an essentialist force that hard-wires us differently. (Shorter also glances at Kinsey's "ten percent" for gays and finds that as he was homosexual himself he tipped the scale in his own sampling of interviews; two percent's more like it.) He shows how the effeminate swish went in and out of favor in the gay community, and how the dyke herself rose into and fell out of lesbian style. Shorter in mapping the dominance for our own generation of "total body sex" opines that our ancestors may not have even considered the erogenous potential of their bodies as they were more fixated on survival. Any sex they were likely to have could be observed by family members, eavesdroppers in the literal sense, or the eye of a censorious neighbor eager to report the sight to priest or judge. The conceptions in same-sex male encounters of what constituted relations also evolved from times when lack of hygeine led to genital contact predominantly. Therefore, homosexual "buggery" that imitated the predominant "missionary position" of heterosexuals shifted more slowly than might be expected to an optional form of release using the mouth. This happened much later, when cities again allowed in the 20c a more anonymous rate of exchange in tea rooms and clubs, unlike the furtive activity that earlier men had often to engage in quickly and under constant fear of discovery-- at least.
Similarly, with the fetish changing from fur a century or more ago to leather, Shorter demonstrates how fashion allied with mass production and technological innovation to create new demands for products sold to wider audiences eager for the next Betty Page or Greenwich/ Castro St. fantasy. (This brisk narrative does whir by too rapidly. For example, Shorter should have given a nod to Village People & Freddie Mercury here; I think of the Dodger Stadium family crowds who now sing along to Queen & "YMCA"-- surely this represents a popularization unwittingly perhaps of what was known largely by only a Tom of Finland bathhouse demographic not that long ago?)
Shorter credits the only in the 1960s the concept that one could let one's senses free to achieve "total body sex" but finds its origins in the fin-de-siecle with the demi-monde. The literary and artistic circles appear to have publicized their derring-do, and gradually in the cities and colleges this appears to have trickled down to the wider populace in a pattern still continuing. But as to the present-day resistance-- in both Christian and Muslim societies-- Shorter tends to ignore.
He concludes by acknowledging that sexual liberation need not be seen as anti-rational or irresponsible. Rather, it signals the breaking of centuries of clerical, communal, and personal taboos enforced. He does find that the more sexually active one is, the more one mistrusts others. He ends his study pondering how the increased bonds between a pair have been diminishing the ties to one's religious practice or social affiliation in an extension of the "bowling alone" thesis. This tendency, he finds, has accelerated in our own times along with the loss of restraints towards sexual choice.
The popularity of sex without reproduction or repercussion-- for the first time in our species-- also could not have emerged without medical improvements. Foremost, the loss of fear by women that they could be one of the 10% who died in childbirth or post-partum-- every coital act was thus a grim roll of the Reaper's dice. We also can go to bed with enthusiasm. Our bodies and those we explore can be free of the stench that would have discouraged even the libertines of the past. Thanks to the hygienic attention that eradicated scabies, lice, and smallpox, our post-Bloomsburian relaxed attitudes towards intimacy can be thanked to clean living. And not only the dirty pictures that come with guiltless and effortless access via the media. Shorter leaves the reader free to wonder about what seems the most natural of activities but in fact remains one of the most mediated, even within the privacy of one's own bedroom in an anonymous city.
(Posted to Amazon US today with obvious excisions.)
Friday, November 30, 2007

Georges Bataille: Into the Realm of the Senses
That scandalous 1976 Japanese film took its climactic scene from Bataille's novellette that dared to blend fornication with termination. The Marquis de Sade boasted that every man thinks himself a tyrant during the sexual act. Bataille, a critic of Sade as were so many of his circle, remains renowned today as an explorer into the realms that few besides the infamous noble had dared to enter. However, unlike Sade, the French philosophers who wondered about the forbidden attempted to leave coded road maps for us to follow; scatology and puerile sputtering gave way, as the philosophers (and sometime novelists) matured, into learned treatises. (Still, we forget that Sade left his share of more even-tempered arguments as well; most of his works of all sorts were burned and we have little extant of his massive oeuvre.)
Bataille and his fellows of the College of Sociology (a respectably titled front for Acéphale among other underground renegades- they apocryphally shared an interest in human sacrifice but while many were willing to be the victim, none even at the promise of amnesty could be found to be executioner) began tramping past Surrealism into the literary, religious, anthropological, and erotic zones. These had been left largely uncharted by intellectuals. His protegé (and another former seminarian) Pierre Klossowski continued in this direction if to less acclaim. In the wake of Modernism, preparing for existentialism, fighting fascism, and attracted to radical self-autonomy, these mid-20 c avant-gardists turned to Sade and Nietzsche, Catholic mystics and secular iconoclasts, for hints of where such a journey into the senses might take scholars. Without them, we'd never have had Zone Books, all those parenthetically altered titles of MLA papers, The Body as its own scholarly pursuit, Derrida, Lacan, Baudrillard, Foucault, and their own spawn-- "cultural studies" in today's "select bookstores" for tenured black-clad acolytes.
Known best for his half-arousing, half-ludicrous "The Story of an Eye," which apparently inspired a Bjork video, Bataille can be daunting. I am re-reading after a quarter-century his "Erotism" and find it tough going. Most of his writing tends towards far less salacious description than "Story." I admit being jilted by his novella "Blue of Noon." (I reviewed it last week here.) Such a genre is not my usual reading, but I find myself, in my own academic trek spurred by a few passages in "Ulysses" past a dizzying vista of ideological terrain recently, reminded of my grad school stumbling upon "Erotism" and its impact. Blame Joyce, or Nora. So, as I stumble into Bataille's study of the intersection between the violent and the sacred, the moment of death and that of erotic dissolution, the stripping of the victim and the silence of consummation, the tangling annihilation and willing sacrifice, I wanted to share a few sites that can assist the overwhelmed sightseer entering the labyrinthine chambers that comprise his formidable, if often scattered and gnomic, reclamation of the hidden.
Thanks to whomever at the University of Warwickshire transcribed the sample entry from the book for a course. These are excerpts from the opening to his "Erotism: Death & Sensuality." City Lights put Bernini's sculpture of St Teresa in ecstasy appropriately on the cover of the English translation. The introduction concludes: "Poetry leads to the same place as all forms of eroticism — to the blending and fusion of separate objects. It leads us to eternity, it leads us to death, and through death to continuity. Poetry is eternity; the sun matched with the sea."
http://pers-www.wlv.ac.uk/~fa1871/battext.html
A fuller version of the introduction, along with excerpts from "Erotism" on "Reproduction & Death" and an essay from "On Nietzsche" about "The Crucifixion," can be found at another site. Bataille again quotes de Sade with his less comforting but typically barbed thought of the day: "There is no better way to know death than to link it with some licentious image." http://www.batailleros.tk/
Bataille & mysticism expounded by a thoughtful Dutch adept at The Mystical Site. "So every marriage ends up killing its own God": http://home.wxs.nl/~brouw724/Bataille.html
Geoffrey Roche, U. of Auckland, discusses at the final link (see below) Bataille's understanding of Sade. Bataille as the critic and heir to the Marquis can be as insistent as le Comte when it comes to the denigration of the female. Bataille tells us: "The whole business of erotism is to strike to the inmost core of the living being, so the heart stands still. The transition from the normal state to that of erotic desire presupposes a partial dissolution of the person as he exists in the realm of discontinuity." The violent climax presages death, the gap between our existence and the void. So far, so good.
But, that "he" --even taking into account Franco-pronominal prejudices-- prepares us for: "In the process of dissolution, the male partner has generally an active role, while the female side is essentially that which is dissolved as a separate entity." (qtd. from pp. 17-18 of text; p. 162 in Roche pdf.) Or, as the song goes "I'll stop the world and melt with you." Bataille does go on to note how the male's power enables his union with the female as she's dissolved, so my allegations that Bataille favors male dominance may be premature.
When discussing the frisson and the swoon, who's to say? We all, as he finds in arguing his convoluted way through "Erotism," must base our objective analysis upon our subjective experience. While Kinsey's paradigms had not yet totally displaced those of Freud when Bataille wrote these lines in 1957, Bataille betrays a fundamental assertion that the man rules the roost. Even the most transgressive of cocksure rebels, in matters of intimacy, cannot shed his Gallic and galling chauvinism.
http://www.janushead.org/9-1/Roche.pdf
Labels:
belief,
death,
erotica,
French literature,
Georges Bataille,
James Joyce,
Literary criticism,
mystics,
philosophy,
Pierre Klossowski,
sacred and profane,
Sade,
sexuality,
Ulysses
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


