Showing posts with label Catholic Worker. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Catholic Worker. Show all posts

Thursday, May 21, 2020

Wendell Berry's "Questionnaire"

 WanderLost: Wendell Berry

How much poison are you willing
to eat for the success of the free
market and global trade? Please
name your preferred poisons.

For the sake of goodness, how much
evil are you willing to do?
Fill in the following blanks
with the names of your favorite
evils and acts of hatred.

What sacrifices are you prepared
to make for culture and civilization?
Please list the monuments, shrines,
and works of art you would
most willingly destroy

In the name of patriotism and
the flag, how much of our beloved
land are you willing to desecrate?
List in the following spaces
the mountains, rivers, towns, farms
you could most readily do without.

State briefly the ideas, ideals, or hopes,
the energy sources, the kinds of security;
for which you would kill a child.
Name, please, the children whom
you would be willing to kill. 

~You can hear this piece, by Wendell Berry, the eminent Henry County, Kentucky, farmer-poet-agrarian philosopher, (photo above) read in inimitable love-it-or-hate-it style by Garrison Keillor, pre-cancel culture, via this public radio link to his "Writer's Almanac."  I learned of this through a Front Porch Republic link on the American Solidarity Party. I learned of this movement based on distributism, in the spirit of Dorothy Day, Mennonites, Catholic Worker or a "consistent life ethic" through grassroots non-sectarian organization. And that finally came through this "weird" article in the NY Times my friend alerted me to.

In turn, FPR updates the poem for the "pseudo choice, a choice that is no real choice at all."

~FPR deigns that "Wendell Berry’s provocative 'Questionnaire' might be put into prose and updated for the 2020 election with these new, dismal choices:
  1. What is your preferred method of killing babies: abortion, pollution, or ICE detention?
     
  2. Do you want the US to pursue endless wars abroad, or do you want the president to lurch spasmodically into and out of conflicts?
     
  3. Do you want the US to respond to climate change with head-in-the-sand denialism, or do you want a Green New Deal that would empower our federal government to manage the entire economy?
     
  4. Do you want the national debt to grow quickly or very quickly?
     
  5. Do you want to fund our medical bureaucracy through private insurance companies that extort more money from you each year in premiums and other fees, or do you prefer to be a helpless pawn in a vast, government-run healthcare system?
     
  6. Do you want free trade with countries that put their citizens in re-education camps, or do you want the US to impose tariffs in haphazard fashion on various foreign countries? (Alternatively, you might prefer to leave moralizing about foreign governments to NBA players and the successors to Steve Jobs.)
     
  7. Do you want the president to use Christianity as a cover for his racism and misogyny, or should the president tax all churches and nonprofits whose theology he disagrees with?
     
  8. Do you want the president to be a blatant nepotist and hire his children, or do you want the president to rely on foreign governments to enrich his children?
     
  9. Should the president get interest groups and foreign governments to patronize his businesses while in office, or should the president wait until after his term of service to receive scads of money from foreign governments and corporate executives? 
Me: Yeah, I know that "unprecedented events, uncertain times, unanticipated challenges etc." all upturn the world as we knew it again, since this was revamped last November. But the choices appear the dismal same, with the incumbent vs. the blue-state's safe corporate mouthpiece. For better or worse, latter party chose to reject a more radical choice, and here we are, another election with the lesser of two evils insisting he cares about us, every 4 years.

Monday, May 25, 2015

Industry of death

When I was in college, I showed my dad an op-ed column in the L.A. Times. Our cardinal, Timothy Manning, whom I had shaken hands with and exchanged cordialities at my high school graduation, was a soft-spoken emigrant from County Cork. But his editorial castigated, in Reagan's first term, the "industry of death" (or terms like that) which profited off of a Cold or hot war, and which employed hundreds of thousands in the "defense industry" that in that time still dominated much of the regional economy in aerospace and in manufacturing.

My blue-collar, Reagan Democrat dad responded evenly but with a touch of bitterness: those priests never had to support a family with a job. He reminded me, the know-it-all at the Jesuit university that, although full of working-class undergrads (and many middle-class, true), we were removed from the realities of the economy. My dad had worked at many tool-and-die machine shops, many factories, for decades in this industry.

So, when I share such citations from a clergy with whom I otherwise often disagree, what's the point? I have been convinced that war is not the answer since my teens. Somehow, exposure to St. Francis, to Thomas Merton, to a hint of the Catholic Worker movement, drew me away from my childhood fascination with conflict, one so strong it unsettled a second-grade teacher. At the height of the Vietnam War, I kept changing every creative writing opportunity into a little guy's fiery combat tale.

I was the first year to have to register for the Selective Service imposed by Jimmy Carter late in his term. Those males turning 18 had to sign up at the Post Office on a small card, I recall. The Persian Gulf Doctrine mandated a ready force of young men on call. Protecting oil, as we have seen for decades since, became in the wake of OPEC and the embargoes of the Seventies today's key priority.

So, I also sent a letter to Pax Christi in Boston. I went on record as a conscientious objector to such war. Back then, at least then I could admit some use in serving to help people even in the military in a non-combat capacity, but my preference, not that the government cared, was to not support the service, but to do whatever duty I had to do if required in a domestic role, not furthering conflict.

Now I am not sure about that. Finding out in '07 about my murdered Fenian great-grandfather threw me for a loop, given my seemingly inherited bent against the Butcher's Apron and the Crown. It made me wonder if I, the boy with the crayons drawing tanks and fire and soldiers, revealed a violent gene. Or maybe I carry an idealistic one, romantic and impractical, that ordinary people deserve control.

The War of Independence left Ireland a partitioned nation and sparked civil war, and long decades of hatred and political rancor. The guerrillas in the Six Counties did not wrench that province away from Britain. Thousands died, many more wounded in the soul or in the body. Still, as with some revolutions, I can't tell if a peaceful Irish movement against the Empire might have succeeded.

If asked now by my nation, with the anarchist leanings I have discovered I had formulated without knowing earlier in my life those definitions, I'd opt out from aiding war. I have written about J.F. Powers, who was sent to prison for refusing to buy war bonds in WWII, and I have learned recently about those who turned away from even the "good war"; my father mused one day to me--perhaps after reflecting on the Gold Star flag hung in my mother's house for the death of her only sibling, my namesake Uncle Jack, on the shores of Saipan--that nobody really ever won a war. I turn away more than ever from slogans, jingoism, and ribbons. So, I post this with another Jesuit's chastisement, on another Memorial Day. My students from Iraq and Afghanistan still return, still wounded, if hidden.

Thursday, August 29, 2013

Katharine Anne Powers' "Suitable Accommodations": Book Review

As the oldest child of a long-suffering writer bent on evading any 9-to-5 routine, Katharine Anne Powers presents her father, J. F. (James Farl known also as Jim) Powers, in a sensitive yet honest "autobiographical story of family life" between 1943 and 1963. He never finished the fictional depiction of his real-life predicament, always chafing against conformity as a conservative Catholic intellectual during the war and the boom years, but as Katharine shows, Jim channeled self-pity and satirical send-ups into his correspondence. From thousands of his letters and some of his journals, she depicts how Jim "worked up the theme of life mowing him down" (xx).

Resigned but never stoic, bitter yet motivated, J. F. took life's difficulties personally. Born in 1917 in small-town Illinois, grandson of an Irish immigrant, early on he opposed giving in. Encouraged by pacifists, inspired by the little-known Detachment movement within the mid-century Catholic counterculture, the Powers family tried to turn away from the capitalist, consumerist, materialist, and militarist majority of FDR's deals and Ike's likes. He dropped out of night school at Northwestern. He groused while catering to a rich man as a chauffeur. Fired from a bookseller's job for refusing to buy war bonds, denied his conscientious objector status as a Catholic (due to "just war" theory), indicted by a grand jury in 1943 for refusing induction, he served thirteen months in a federal penitentiary. His children found out about their father's conviction only in 1959, when a classmate called him a "jailbird".

Certainly, reticence combines with frankness in the Powers clan. These letters reveal a young man determined to go his own way, somehow wrangling the respect of others who would support his desire to simply hide away in the woods, to farm (not a likely vocation), and to write stories. Paroled, assigned as a hospital orderly in St. Paul, he yearns to quit, "But I know it's a forlorn project. I have only my reasons. I can't think of a single one of theirs--and them's the ones that count." (13) This snippet shows Powers' hop between introspection, stubbornness, and slang. Like his characters in the deft short stories, spare and cutting, that he began to publish in literary magazines, their creator enjoyed examining his pain, and expressing his quiet desire for release from his pal, dissatisfaction.

Chief among his targets, and characteristic of his best fiction in story or novel form, the Church and its complacent clergy compelled his sharp gaze. The Church Jim wanted would challenge the secular powers; the Church he found perpetuated its foibles, "second only to Standard Oil", sunk into corruption and incompetence. Powers refused to take a steady paycheck: "eight hours out of my life daily so the system may prosper and the crapshooters running it". (40) What Katharine labels as her father's "intransigence" against working for a living (in a steady job) sparked tension with his wife, Betty Wahl. A diligent writer herself, fresh out of a Minnesota Catholic college, she attracted J. F. He proposed to her two days after he met her. They wrote each other nearly every day before their marriage less than six months later. But, they had met only five times during their courtship. 

A few days before their nuptials, Jim lashes out at Betty by letter after she demurred sharing what would be their first small dwelling with Jim's longtime pal, now a priest. A miscarriage soon after their wedding, a desperation in his letters whenever he and Betty are apart, and Jim's insistence on moving away from the city led to evident stress. Raised first in a dugout with a tar-paper roof, in a Minnesota November, Katharine was born in 1948. The Powers dwelling was set into the ground, fifty degrees inside, barely heated, but with much damp and no running water.

Jim resents sharing Betty's parents' summer cabin--loaned out to the newlyweds despite the Wahls' suspicions about their gangly in-law as an ex-prisoner, pacifist, and  deadbeat--with her family. The Powers return to St. Paul, but the new father finds no contentment. Doggedly impecunious, he bemoans his thrift. But he refuses a job, teaching creative writing now and then if he has to; he turns down an offer at Bennington. When Betty wants to spend five dollars on a cabinet for Katharine, Jim complains in a telling phrase drawn from their religious inculcation: "if we are two in one flesh, we are not yet two in spirit" (98) While their daughter keeps her own italicized commentary spare, one wonders when reading these letters her own reaction to the revelations of one parent to another here.

Katharine's editorial asides tend towards her father's own reticence regarding the inspiration let alone content for his stories. The family appears detached. This may frustrate readers new to Jim's fiction. While all of it is back in print in the NYRB Classics series, neither father nor daughter mention much to clue us in. One of J.F.'s best submissions to The New Yorker is dismissed as "another cat story" as its sole detail; normally Jim satisfies his correspondent with "a story" as the entirety of its reference.

Instead, his letters fill with homely and exasperated content. By the 1950s, Powers attained respect (and among clerics and some outraged faithful, notoriety on a small scale) as a leading writer, however humbly paid, of Catholic mores in the short story form. He longed to work on a novel. Both of his novels draw from his stories, most of which appeared in the postwar decades. His best work limns in spare, direct prose many seething or ambitious characters in the imaginary Ostergothenburg diocese. Put-upon curates, preening pastors and business-first bishops contend against meddling housekeepers, sly nuns, and their pious, annoying, and inept parishioners in small-town, German Catholic and Scandinavian Protestant Minnesota. Jim's fiction presents the petty chancery conflicts and rectory politics within the environment whose liturgically reforming, rural counterculture in a conservative Catholic community had attracted Jim to find Betty (her brother was a monk at the center of this movement, St. John's Abbey and University) and try to live for a while in that dugout.

Unsurprisingly, Jim tensed up. The letters to his bride-to-be demonstrate this. Confronted by responsibility, he resented his procrastination. Children soon followed, five over a decade beginning with Katharine Anne. While Marquette and later Ann Arbor provide him with part-time and sporadic teaching, he rejects a steady position elsewhere. He visits the most frequent recipient of these letters, Fr. Harvey Egan, often staying with him on extended stays, as well as with his parents, who had moved to Albuquerque with a sister. Meanwhile, Fr. Egan keeps supporting him by writing checks.

In between Jim's Minnesota stints in St. Cloud--writing, browsing at Gopher Surplus, watching minor league baseball, listening to boxing matches, and teaching only if he must--the Powers clan lived in Ireland as long as their breadwinner could support them, on the sales of his stories. They moved back and forth a total of four times; three of which are documented by wry Katharine in the span of these letters. This peripatetic decision to keep uprooted attests to both Jim's small budget, in an era when Ireland was affordable compared to the U.S., and to the patriarch's own knowingly romanticized but also realistic appraisals of his ancestral homeland. He longs for Ireland but his visions soon fade. As he silences his local parish priest after the family relocates the first time to staid Greystones to rent a home south of Dublin: "I knew the torture of marriage, had dreamt of the beauties of celibacy." (187)

Yet, from afar (a pattern that seems to increase with time), he writes to Betty--with three small youngsters to care for--on her birthday in 1953: "It's a sad state of affairs when a man's most carnal thoughts are of his wife. See that you are worthy of them." (169) Within whatever these letters disclose or hint, he remained skeptical that marriage or fatherhood would fulfill him. He mocks himself for the lack of "sex" in his fiction, and titles himself "America's Cleanest Lay Author". He longs to run off to a cabin, to keep writing. "I am not by nature cut out for this life, as it's defined in these parts by the chamber of commerce and our bishop, who is devoted to Christian family living, as everyone knows." (212) This deadpan tone suits Powers and his conflicted, capitalist priests well.

On a side trip to St. John's, the Trappist monk Thomas Merton summed up astutely his host for dinner in St. Cloud for his "mixture of dryness and spontaneity, a thin sensitive person whose vocation is to go through many unbearable experiences". (qtd. 228) But by 1957, with a Kenyon Review fellowship, J.F.'s letters express hints of satisfaction. His affection for his greatest fictional creation, Fr. Urban (whose name before he entered the Clementine Order was Harvey Roche), begins to emerge.

The Powers had rented the "red house", St. Cloud's oldest, but when that site was targeted for expansion of the state college, Jim had to carry out a second "removal" of the family to Ireland.  While moving from Greystones to Dalkey nearby, they learned Betty was pregnant with their fifth child. They pass Ireland's coldest Christmas in sixty years, without central heating, in a drafty place.

At 40, despair deepens, despite Jim's recourse to a favorite pastime, sometimes in the company of writer Seán O'Faolain, betting on the horses. He rents a Dublin office only to fritter away most of his time writing letters as well as going to estate auctions, bookbinding, and gluing old furniture. He confides in Fr. Egan: "I personally dislike this stretch of life ahead of me: the father of numerous children; the husband of a woman with no talent for motherhood (once she's conceived); and with the prospect of making no more money than in the past." (294) Yet, he will not let give up his office. He insists that Betty, about to give birth, forget about vacating what she calls a "freezing mausoleum".

He avers that he and Betty will not realize each mistake until they make it, not in the least surprised by each of them. A few of Betty's terse journal entries intersperse with a few of her husband's: "Jim as divinely inspired gadfly" sums him up in his wife's phrase. He abandons trying to make it abroad. Back in St. Cloud, seven Powerses share for awhile another house with Betty's folks.

The Powers move, but Jim loses chapters of his Fr. Urban novel in progress. He tells his confidante Fr. Egan: "You see I have this parrot, who lives in a rectory, and says: God love you!" The Great Plains, as usual, wear him down. Powers hates poses by Twin Cities literati as if poetry matters more than museum fundraisers "hobnobbing with the wives of chain drugstore magnates".  He laments to Betty that he'd rather have good reading vanish than sustain the farce that highbrow culture trumps lowbrow. Shutting himself up rather than retort at a Catholic Worker talk by Dorothy Day, his journal records he has "little faith in the common people to save themselves from themselves". (349)

The slow pace of producing quality fiction defined Powers' long career. Three short story collections total thirty stories over four decades; his two novels in 1962 and 1988 expand some of the clerical settings. Morte d'Urban, the first published, was mishandled by Doubleday. Misprints and text breaks cluttered it; few copies were kept in stock. Evelyn Waugh's blurb was bungled. Still, it won the National Book Award, beating out not only John Updike's Pigeon Feathers but Vladimir Nabokov's Pale Fire, and Ship of Fools by Jim's friend and his daughter's namesake, Katharine Anne Porter.

He tells Fr. Egan ten days before the award was announced how he turned down lecturing at Columbia and the University of Chicago; he tried on "used dress cloth-lined" galoshes at Goodwill. He dismisses St. Cloud to novelist Jack Conroy: Morte shares the bestseller list there with Happiness is a Warm Puppy. He meets Walter Winchell and Hedda Hopper at his acceptance speech, but the awardees' appearance on the Today show is cancelled. He rejects more job offers, dreaming of  buying an Irish house on royalties. Sales of Morte in hardcover by the following summer tally 25,000, half of what he had estimated.

Naturally, the Powerses move back to occupy a drafty hotel in Greystones. This experiment led to the only story Jim wrote about Ireland, "Tinkers" (1975) and to Betty's only novel, Rafferty & Co. (1969). (I critique both in a recent article published before Jim's letters were compiled in the galley proof I review here; Katharine Anne Powers' long-awaited edition of her father's correspondence enriches the limited source material previously available on J.F. Powers and Betty Wahl.)

Katharine shares an afterword, reacting to reading twenty-one years of letters. Jim's droll wit and turns of phrase "won me over"; she felt a distance from herself and the situations described. Her sister Jane, while "bowled over" by J.F.'s warmth in the early letters for Betty, ultimately felt saddened. Their father's "truculence" rankled, and the extent of his determined impracticality rouses uneasiness.

His oldest daughter cuts off her father's garrulous or telegraphic reminiscences at the end of 1963. She conjectures this as when and where the "family novel" mooted by Jim would have concluded. He had moved to Ireland to evade popular culture, but as his children matured during the 1960s, Katharine predicts that J.F. could not have handled their evolution during this--of all decades. She alludes to a crucial fact downplayed tactfully by Betty's fictional counterpart in her own family novel: "it was based in a gentle way, far too gentle, I would say, on life in Ireland with a man something like Jim". (420) Katharine's mother tried to write daily when she was not cooking, cleaning, scrimping, and saving. A shy or evasive sense within these letters, I add, is the tacit presence of Betty's devotion.

While Jim frittered away years, Betty followed a strict schedule and tried to bring in some money by stories in The Kenyon Review and The New Yorker. They share with Jim's stories economic prose, no sex, and a bemused eye cast upon domestic distress, greed, folly, fate, and gullibility. Thrift, schemes, and restlessness characterize both writers. Her satirical, poignant, if a bit uneven (a subplot sprawls) Rafferty spun off her shorter fiction, similar to her husband's stories extended into Morte and Wheat That Springeth Green. That appeared the same year Betty died of cancer, 1988. Jim held out to 1999. A professor at St. Cloud State, the college whose expansion uprooted the "red house" and sparking "removal" two to Ireland, told me that he feared approaching Jim, who suffered no fool gladly. (To Amazon US in shorter, revised form 8-20-13; as above 8-13-13 to RePrint/ PopMatters)

Tuesday, August 6, 2013

Nathan Schneider's "Thank You, Anarchy": Book Review

Why a subtitled "apocalypse"? It derives from "the lifting of a veil," so when a fresh revelation appears, it transforms the past as well as the present: then, there's no going back, only forward. Fresh from finishing a study of attempts to verify the divine presence, God in Proof, Nathan Schneider, jittery and curious, reports "notes" from the revelations emanating from Occupy Wall Street in the late summer of 2011. He investigates an energy more tangible than most theology: yet sharing the spirited, mass appeal of what may elude those less fervent.

Idealistic enough to cheer on the Occupy protests, realistic enough to catalogue their failures, Schneider brings the same alert witness and affable analysis that his book on belief featured. As with any cabal of devotees, Occupy began with commitment by a spellbound few. Zuccotti Park, rechristened by the encampment with its pre-corporate name as Liberty Square, "was a place especially conducive to those of us with obsessive tendencies, who like to be consumed in a given interest or project to the exclusion of all else. There, the god of ordinary life was dead, resurrected in the business of self-reliance."

The difficulties of staying fed, wired (by caffeine and cellphones), and calm soon weighed upon Occupiers. Encircled by police at first and then the media and bystanders, as crowds grew in the autumn,demonstrators' tensions grew. Schneider contrasts the "rampant volunteerism" of the initial Wall Street-adjacent site squaring off against the iconic Charging Bull of financial acumen with Freedom Plaza in Washington D.C. There, hesitation cowed those gathered to square off against political might. Occupiers in D.C. waited for "directives to come from on high."

Yet, when they did, such dicta were resented, by those complaining about the lack of democratic process. "There was a general assembly, but nobody seemed sure how to run it." Schneider distinguishes the "instinctive anarchists" (he chats with "anti-leader" David Graeber, one of the instigators of the core New York contingent) from those who flocked to enclaves while remaining unsure of their next move.

Certainly, the lack of "one demand" from Occupy met with media mockery and bipartisan disdain. Yet Schneider insists that the flexibility supported not only the disparate concerns but the diverse membership of protesters. He suggests how an "anarchist utopia" in economic, environmental, educational, and egalitarian terms turns transparent and liberating on a global, "open-source" scale.

While this glimpse remains brief, it sketches what Occupy envisioned beyond borders, fences, or property. A problem persisted. Those articulating direct "participatory democracy" tended to be white, male, and often with leisure or income to detach from workaday, less privileged or more dutiful adults unable to pitch a tent or stand in solidarity from dawn to dusk, let alone into the increasingly chilly nights. (Schneider notes the lack of parents, for example.) Still, Schneider nods in approval as those less used to taking command and speaking out began to do so. "Those used to talking had to learn to listen more, and those used to shutting up had to learn how to teach."

I can attest to the difficulties of this attitudinal adjustment, from my insights gleaned at Occupy L.A. and from friends who tried to channel the energy within enclaves as large as Oakland and small as a Sierra Nevada tourist destination; those used to being in charge (often with pedigrees from counterculture, global justice, and progressive cadres) found it unsettling to give in to those around them from disparate, non-credentialed backgrounds and from younger cohorts, resigned to following the lead from 1960s veterans. The non-authoritarian, elusive essence of Occupy by its nature slipped away from many grasps. Why it stayed mercurial, Schneider reasons, depended on its darting targets.

Whereas the lunch counter sit-ins for Civil Rights aimed "specifically at the laws they oppose," civil disobedience faltered when Big Pharma, banker malfeasance, SuperPACs, bailouts, Citizens United, student debt, foreclosures, drones, McJobs, and income disparity loomed over Americans in the Obama era. The disparate manifestations of these millennial monoliths required different tactics than civil disobedience. Rather than accept political institutions as legitimate, while resisting immoral laws, "political disobedience" (Schneider credits here Bernard Harcourt) brushes aside partisanship, policy reform, or 20th century post-war ideologies. Within this cleared space, Occupy blossomed.

After all, "Occupiers weren't even capable of breaking many of the laws they opposed in the first place." "Diversity of tactics" by autonomous spontaneity meant collaboration in a permissive manner, to evade police crackdowns from its hierarchical command, The NYPD knew by now how to squelch marches. Authority could not control chaos, as the Direct Action "affinity group" exemplified at the Brooklyn Bridge. Non-violent principles sustained Occupiers; pragmatism wedged in its own force.

All the same, Schneider, deep into part two by now of his account, betrays weariness. Mayor Bloomberg tightens the city's grip around Liberty Square. The police dump off homeless people and addicts there, while the unsettled attracted to its safe space increase unease. In this "particular mix of overeducated, underemployed, postindustrial primitivism," Schneider locates the "organic expression of the movement," confounding facile definition. The cause that the encampment represents ties itself to liberating a place, but can that place alone represent the diverse demands of its residents?

Socialists rally for benefits and education; anarchists dismiss government as we know it. Anonymous hovers with its "lulz" sensibility casting its sly wink within the crowds. Online, it and other entities jostle for influence over the movement, trained by the decentralized nature of such fora. Tea Party and right-wing libertarians, who in the nascent stages might have helped broaden the movement through populist appeals, find themselves relegated to leftist caricatures. Journalists and comedians jeer at Occupy. Unions, non-profits, and certain cautious Democrats try to jump on its bandwagon, all with their own calculation.

Free speech contends within what constitutes peaceful assembly: it's the mayor vs. the tent-dwellers. "The call to occupy was meant to be adjudicated not so much by legal right to free speech as by the one inscribed in conscience." Schneider attempts to align this idea with how Occupy undermined law and order as backed by "soldiers posing as police, rigged by and for corporate profits." This observation merited more depth; his analysis wavers in its aim throughout this account. Ultimately, Occupiers waver too. They debate: should they stay or should they go now? 

The very term reminds us of its meaning. "Seizing space and time, and holding them, was how Occupy caused its rupture." It spreads nationwide but in Schneider's sometimes seemingly random "notes," he can evade its force. The day after evictions at Liberty Square, he's off to the Bay Area, but he finds little of lasting substance to comment upon from California for the three-month anniversary of action on November 17th. In the e-galley provided me for review, there is a sudden departure for Greece where Schneider speaks with local and Argentinian activists, who warn of the lure of funds amassed rather than tangible goods to sustain an alternate economy, exchanges of goods and food. Then, anti-eviction sit-ins to take over houses foreclosed draw displaced New York Occupiers to act. Post-evictions, from December into 2012, energy dissipates while Schneider searches in what seems a “lucid dream” for Occupy’s meaning.

It returns via his conversion to Catholicism, documented in his previous book. He praises spiritual activists, who testify to the "higher standard" of "resisting oppression" which transcends civil disobedience and becomes a moral imperative. Trinity Episcopal Church, an historic bastion of the 1%, for all the symbolic vitriol spewed by some Occupiers, stands nonetheless--if in its own fumbled attempts to respond to the movement--for the possibility of assistance to the 99% especially within the underclass. Schneider stays sharp enough to recognize this nuance. He crosses the "line between observer and instigator" with fellow Catholics to respond to his faith's "calling to justice."

In part three, he contrasts 2012. The Obama administration tightened detention of U.S. citizens and upped penalties for protests near Secret Service-protected people or events "of national significance." After a hard winter, the Occupy Wall Street hardcore diminished and toughened. Direct Action advocates contended with the "peace police" of OWS who advised non-violence. Chris Hedges' "The Cancer of Occupy" divides comrades after he denounces Black Bloc tactics others defend. Up against "an essentially paramilitary institution like the NYPD," Schneider tallies the odds for victory at zilch. 

Six months on, Occupy betrays weariness. Stop and Frisk, the DREAM Act, Stand Your Ground incite new marches. Uncertain or committed activists look inward, even as Plus Brigades, The Yes Men, Strike Anywhere, viral videos, cartography, and clowns make their presences felt among the dwindling few. An International Pillow Fight Day attracts more college students than OWS, but the loss of strategic sources of power and location pushes some into a second wind to organize May Day.

Learning of the demise of the New Left after a failed 1971 May Day effort, Schneider fears "we were causing our own undoing." He resigns himself to the reality of organizing after the cameras have left, while the police toughen their stance and the movement diversifies, freeing itself from physical roots.

He finds solace in the culture of photocopied pamphlets and within alliances as venerable as the Catholic Worker Movement as much as Twitter. Yet, OWS signals a shift. Founded not by preachers but by artists (the first glimmer in Adbusters), Schneider defines Occupy's ethos. "Come for the dream, trudge through the reality." Schneider cheers when he sees ecological protests revive, while debt relief jubilee efforts spread and world unrest continues against capitalism.

On May Day 2012, Chris Hedges returns to where it began, near Wall Street. His dour condemnation of violence spurs Schneider to label him as humorless; he does win over the middle-aged or older listeners at Occupy. Younger folks cheer his appointed foil, B. Traven of the anarchist collective CrimethInc: "Just keep with it, basically." Yet, Schneider pegs Traven's pronouncements as preaching to a "self-referential subculture speaking by and for itself." Meanwhile, practically unnoticed by either side, a few still slept in front of Trinity Church.

Another leap, if not a great jump, forward: the first anniversary of Occupy suddenly enters the book. Rosh Hashanah is commemorated while a protester carries a sign against theocracy; a Muslim man unrolls his prayer rug; an Episcopal priest and Catholic nun lead "a solemn march to Zuccotti." Traffic on Broadway halts, Wall Street commuters crowd nearby, police swarm in on the protesters.

As during the previous year and as with such demonstrations, an act of faith endures as testament to Occupy. Whether a revolution will arrive appears as elusive as a Second Coming or a first messiah. Fittingly, Schneider credits the final scene of Fight Club, "with its vision of postyuppie liberation," as playing its part in training those who "birthed Occupy Wall Street" a dozen years later. That is, the finale of crumbling skyscrapers and the prospect of erasure of all financial transactions lingers as appealing and appalling: how is everything "going to be fine"?

After the apocalypse, Schneider feels its grip on him. He concludes with anniversary reflections on the inchoate potential of Occupy, and the practical nature of it, as helping victims of Hurricane Sandy took precedence soon enough. Reacting to such unpredictable forces, no maps or no plans show activists the path forward or a gospel truth. "The beginning is near," as he cites a "popular slogan on Occupy's cardboard signs." (Slightly edited 9-20-13 at New Clear Vision; in shorter form Amazon US 9-15-13.)

Tuesday, April 9, 2013

Joe Beil's "Beyond the Music": Book Review

Interviewing an actress, bicyclist, Catholic Worker, chef, chocolatier, Cuban-American fan of Green Day, Fulbright Scholar working for Cambodia, a psychologist specializing in males, and lots of graphic designers, printers, and publishers, Joe Biel reveals the range of those who use the mechanisms of punk's self-motivated and communally based ethos to change our world by action. Biel, as a filmmaker and zine journalist, collates his conversations from 2008-2012 with over forty who try to make a difference. He introduces this collection with an analogy to "relentless dandelions." That is, tenacious "pioneer plants" dig in taproots deep to extract minerals below an exhausted topsoil, enrich their ground, host other creatures, and out of the darkness, nourish energy.

Aaron Smith, working for the venerable and often rabble-rousing Harper's, connects its radical tradition within the mainstream to his own efforts to parallel the capitalist system. Yet, decades after punk first burst out, after there is "a 'DIY' section in every chain bookstore across the country," he asks, what about its too-often "self-congratulatory impulse"? He elaborates: "The underlying assumption seems to be: If we form enough collectives, print enough stickers and get people reading zines, everything will be alright." Detect Smith's cautious tone and you will hear the theme of realism combined with the abundant idealism articulated by many in these discussions with editor Biel.

As punks age, the camaraderie and intensity which attracted them as teens to the movement shifts into a desire to branch off from the mosh-pit, the noisy clubs, and the relentless demands of life lived rough. You learn here how to assemble a light table from dumpster diving, and how police barricades can be dismantled for window frames when squatting. (While a sense of humor may be recommended, many in these pages--too closely typeset in a font difficult for greying readers like myself to easily navigate--appear quite serious. Perhaps the disproportionate amount of interviewees who left the East Coast and Midwest for the Bay Area and especially Portland stands to blame or credit.) However, as some here gave up living rough circa the Reagan Administration, many of their lessons reflect years of paying bills, needing healthcare, raising children, or learning how not to do everything for free to help a community which may expect too much from too few over the long haul.

Illustrator Matt Gauck raises the moral dilemma: "Is it more punk to steal from Whole Foods, buy food for cash from a supermarket, or use food stamps at your local co-op? I love questions like that, because I'm not sure about the answers, but it helps define where punk fits into the grander social scheme." Biel founded Cantankerous Titles as an offshoot of his Microcosm Publishing to push such challenges into the movement, and to address the DIY system's workings, which tend to be ignored by studies of punk emphasizing the music, the fashion, and the commodification of its sounds.

He highlights the spunk of the participants, and those who try to sustain workable solutions outside the mainstream. The problem, as the recent economic meltdown exposes, is the lack of viable, true, alternatives that can survive the capitalist crisis. Putting people before profit remains altruistic, rare, and fragile as a method to make a living in a harsh climate with frayed protection against disaster.

Anarchists typify one time-tested possibility. Ramsey Kanaan of first AK and now PM Press, Sparkplug underground comics distributor Dylan Williams, and successful mainstream (?) short story writer (and former guitarist for Hellbender) Wells Tower exemplify those able to continue careers. The NYC-based artist Fly, with her spirited if understandably weary tales of life lived rough on the Lower East Side, serves as a telling case study in the desire expended to carry on outside the typical trajectory, once launched by punk into the possibilities outside the expected path. Mark Andersen's concluding essay, with its reference to Jello Biafra's analogy of punk as a virus spread by intimate contact, demonstrates the force that pulls a boy out of 1977 small-town Montana into Positive Force DC, one of the first punk collectives.

Others may, to use a few of many examples: convert restaurant grease into vegetable oil for fossil-free fuel; co-found Dischord Records; star on Friday Night Lights; investigate political malfeasance on behalf of Pro Publica; start up not one but two enduring progressive publishers; edit zines; lobby for a skatepark in a barrio. That last example is from the neighborhood next to mine, showing how the punk-driven activism may well happen around the corner from where you read this.

Forging community spaces becomes crucial for many advocates. A bookstore, an alliance to fight sexual assault, a group therapy resource for non-profits, bio-energy, a radical d.j., or vegan dessert cookbooks show the ways in which better choices may enrich customers, clients, and consumers. Theories may attract some into these causes, but Biel stresses how action emanates from the grind, the discipline, and the motivation. These require commitment to a choice that makes the political slogans and catchy lyrics once shouted a more subtle, if no less compelling, call to transformation. (Amazon US 11-9-12 and to PopMatters 11-19-12)

Monday, April 1, 2013

Pharaoh's hard heart

Commenting on my review last year of the "New American Haggadah," Matthew A. Levine asked c/o Amazon:
I just wonder about the version of the ten plagues that you mention, is the comparison to FDR, Truman, and Lincoln really applicable? Even though I personally don't believe that violent means are ever justified, at least, according to the official version of history, in these cases it was necessary to achieve a good end. According to the Passover story, the Pharaoh was ready to let the Jews go free, and then God "hardened his heart," so in this case liberation could have been achieved without any violence whatsoever. What was the point of that, and how can it possibly be morally justified?
This refers to my statement in the original review: "the Ten Plagues again by [Jeffrey] Goldberg find memorable comparisons. The power of a God who hardened the heart of the evil Pharaoh grows mysterious. Lincoln, FDR, and Truman all are shown as presidents who took the lives of many innocents in their determination to bring about a greater good. If emancipation ends or fascism succumbs, do the ends justify the means?"

I responded: "Matthew, that's precisely the type of question this Haggadah might inspire for a seder, or your own reflection. I recently re-read Nicholson Baker's 'Harper's' essay about the reaction to his own claims in 'Human Smoke' about the folly of violence even in WWII, and his remarks remind me of yours about the hardening of a heart, and how war might have done that to the Allied foes. Perhaps the collective authors strain for relevance and parts of this smack of appealing to a certain demographic, but if its contents can spark a question such as yours (and mine), it's worthwhile."

At the risk of ostracism as a wicked son (if without a Jewish father), this recent exchange stimulated my Pesach planning. My wife wondered if a seder could avoid a mention of "God," and given the spectrum of those attending this year spans secular to atheist, and skeptics with a healthy proportion of lawyers, I figured the timing was perfect for contemplating taking this on tour, if around my table.

(Update: it went well enough, given my own probable or inevitable lapse into professorial mode. After a viewing of the South Park episode, I didn't get into the WWII-Shoah context much which may have been just as well. The youngest son answered many questions from my older son's guest who did not know about the tale much. We skipped the Four Questions, but made up by our Maggid, the narrative we retold--I checked three guests' claim that Moses found out he was Hebrew from a garment shown him by sister Miriam. Not in Exodus; a charming but non-scriptural addition?)

My investigation--as a not-wicked but too-diligent son of my own has waylaid my (admittedly Reform, so perhaps while it may lean towards refuseniks even they may not agree with Baker's pacifism) Torah, detouring me from study of its gleanings--has led me to study Baker's Human Smoke: the Beginnings of World War II, the End of Civilization.  Levine acknowledged by his own glance at its Amazon raters (where my review at that link appears 3/25/13) a massive negative swell of criticism directed at it. I was dimly aware of it when it came out in 2007 but very attentive to "Why I Am a Pacifist" in Harper's for May 2011.

In the book, Baker cites Hitler on January 30, 1941, vowing to fulfill his "prewar threat: If international Jewry pushed Germany into a world war, the Jews would be finished in Europe." (283) Baker does not hold the Allies as free of culpability. The RAF, soon under "Bomber Harris," would continue its remorseless retaliation as retribution (these three terms appear over and over in his sources by late summer of 1941). The defiant British refused to negotiate and the more Hitler bombed their homeland, the more Churchill calculated FDR would send aid and be drawn into global war.

"The bombing offensive fed Hitler's wrath, in direct connection with his concept of the 'Jew's war' against him, and helped unite his nation behind him and justify further Nazi atrocities against the remaining Jews." (qtd. 391) Historian Schlomo Aaronson's assertion supports Baker's cause and effect. Churchill's bellicosity and desire for FDR's lend-lease of weaponry to Britain implies that the Allies were partially responsible by warlust of accelerating the mayhem and backlash of the Shoah.

Civilians displaced by carpet bombing were told the Jews were at fault, and German residences were appropriated by the Nazis who then sent their former occupants off to ghettos. This blame game, as American armaments intensified British raids on innocent Germans, may have hastened the Final Solution. U.S. entry spurred ever more destruction of the Jews, as they lost their hostage status as bargaining chips with the Allies. Death camps emerged, the first readied as it were the day after Pearl Harbor. Analyzing this escalation inspired Baker's Harper's May 2011 essay "Why I Am a Pacifist," which continued the story after the end of 1941, and predictably sparked a firestorm of controversy.

So far, reflecting on Pharaoh's tale, with little commentary--as a fundamentalist might advise-- Exodus makes me wonder about who's to blame. I can't avoid the mention of God, but he may share in the blame game, if not by venerable scholars; Biblical marginalia favor an Augustinian approach. That is, the Pharaoh could have chosen mercy, but he let himself act tough, as this fit a severe ruler in the Middle Eastern model and it showed all the more the comeback of the Hebrews against overwhelming odds and a Memphis home team's martial and mental advantage at Luxor Stadium.

In a 2011 Slate essay, "Sympathy for the Pharaoh," Michael David Lukas considers various rationales advanced by theologians and critics. He notes: "Towards the beginning of the story, Pharaoh hardens his own heart (or it "is hardened" in the passive voice). Following the sixth plague, however, Pharaoh seems to lose his nerve and God steps in, hardening his heart for him." While the likes of Martin Luther King and Erich Fromm aver that the hardening is due to Pharaoh's own defiance of compassion and his decision to use free will to defy Moses' appeal, Lukas reminds us that such apologists for justice and resistance to evil stay mute as to why God steps in to harden the heart that appeared to waver after the infliction upon the recalcitrant Egyptians of boils. (I confess this always impressed or repulsed me as particularly nasty, given my adolescent reaction to skin blemishes.)

My family's search for inspirational fare led to "Jewpacabra," aired March 14, 2012, episode 4, season 16. We join the action as Cartman's dream of being transported back to ancient times leads to why frogs are raining down, God's hand in this curious trajectory, and how that seems unfair to frogs. 

Kyle: It doesn't matter. Because God is going to harden the Pharaoh's heart!
Cartman: What does that mean?
Kyle: It means Jehovah is going to use his powers to keep the Pharaoh from letting us go.
Cartman: Well that doesn't seem very fair, Kyle. I mean, if God is going to make Pharaoh say no, then why would he punish him for saying no?

South Park's script is on to something, as satire snaps. A few minutes it devotes to the depiction of the plagues and Passover: here it hones in on this conundrum. Cartman continues to dream as P's son:

Cartman: Daaad, when's it gonna stop raining frogs?
Pharaoh: It'll be okay, my son. The weather will clear.
Cartman: But my friend Kyle, he says that the reason we've had all these plagues and stuff because you won't let all the Jews leave.
Pharaoh: [sighs] It's a complicated political issue, my son. An economic social issue that needs time. We can't let them leave, but is it really all that different from when the north didn't let the confederate states leave the USA?
Cartman: Wow, that makes sense. Don't think anyone can deny that. [a bloody frog lands over the edge]
Pharaoh: Poor frogs. I feel so badly for them.
Cartman: But dad, my friend Kyle says that if we don't do whatever the Hebrews want us to do, God is gonna kill little Egyptian boys.
Pharaoh: Hah, I don't think God would do such a thing, little one. No matter what happens, we can't let ourselves believe in the Hebrew version of God. We believe in a just Lord who would never murder innocent children.
Cartman: I love you, dad.
Pharaoh: And I love you son. And our love grows.

Speaking of dad, I've mused at DeMille-epic length about my own college-age antiwar stance four years ago at Pax Christi-Passover; the elevation of a pope named Francis may align with this spring's paschal ritual. In that 2009 entry, I raised many of recollections as a child hearing my dad remark "nobody ever wins a war; there are only losers" and my own naming after my mom's only brother dead on the shores of 1944 Saipan lingered. Raised with Vietnam footage on network t.v., I recalled to Niall the "Welcome Home POWs" bracelets worn by my hippie-spawned grade-school classmates from the far more liberal side of town. I credit as an teen my own surprised encounters via Thomas Merton's autobiography and J.F. Powers' incarceration to learn that Catholic Workers and pacifists during even the "good war" and the "greatest generation" existed as fellow communicants next to my presumably unaware mom and dad as they worked day and night in factories for the "war effort."

No, they were no saints, no Franciscans jailed as Fr. Louis Vitale has been (see "Pax Christi"). During the days of the Evil Empire and the contras, I showed my dad an article by L.A.'s Cardinal Timothy Manning decrying the "culture of war" and our local "defense industry." My dad and mom had worked at such factories (as did Layne's--both our dads were turned down for induction due to punctured eardrum and stuttering respectively); my machine shop, further-deafened by tool-and-die, dad looked the prelate's op-ed over with a glance and almost sneered: the Cardinal never had to worry about how his bills were to be paid or where his next meal was coming from.

Yes, I have seen the numbers cut into the arms of the elderly; Leo and I heard Dario Gabbai tell of his fate as a sonderkommando fueling the furnaces of Auschwitz. The more I study Irish republicanism over decades, the more attentive I am to what I didn't notice once upon a time: the perpetuation of "whataboutery." What about Hitler, what about the Battle of the Boyne, what about the Irish Civil War after the one that tried to gain independence, but left in the wake of a cleverly phrased and jerry-rigged treaty dividing the Free State a legacy of bitterness for generations. Baker's allies would insist any treaty brokered ought to be preferable to more death. It's hard not to disagree, despite my clan sympathies. I remain cognizant of perhaps cognitive dissonance here, but I state my case nonetheless.

Teaching PTSD vets, kids with plates in their backs and pins in their knees, wives with babies to care for while their husbands are off in Afghanistan, students called up for reserves, active duty, or desert training in the middle of a term; survivors of firefights in Fallouja who went three months without bathing in over a hundred lbs. of cloth and gear in 140-degrees: what some must undergo to qualify for an education on a GI Bill. I despise a nation and a mindset which rewards only those who may have risked their life and their sanity to cull a few thousand dollars for improving their livelihood and their mentality. I'm not naive enough to acknowledge my own desires lurk for revenge or reprisal; my Fenian blood can run deep. Yet, my maturity demands that I seek and support calmer ways to redress wrongs and right injustices. As Einstein challenged in 1930: "If only 2 percent of the men liable for war service were to refuse, there would not be enough jails in the world to take care of them." (23)

Thursday, April 9, 2009

Pax Christi, Passover

Yesterday I read about Franciscan friar Louis Vitale, 76, arrested for one of his hundreds of protests against nuclear weapons. This inspired my memory. I registered as a "selective conscientious objector" in college with Pax Christi. Reagan thundered as El Salvador and nukes rather than global warming and Iraq filled headlines, alongside perennials: economic crises and political anxiety. My bad dreams anticipated a second Bay of Pigs, sparked by Central American Cold Wars.

Fr. Vitale's energetic and media-savvy stance as covered in the hometown paper, him white bearded and bespectacled in his brown habit and knotted cord, reminded me of the more circumspect but similarly garbed Irish Capuchins with whom I stayed the summer I turned nineteen. I was thinking of joining them, but as I'd fallen predictably in love my freshman year before my visit, I suppose I was fated not to stay. However, as the Mexican nuns at Poverello of Assisi kindergarten inspired me as a lad of five, and as I chose the clunky name "Francis" as my confirmation patron, I like the saint if not his nerdy moniker.

I learned how to count to ten in Spanish from nuns in habits as distinctive as those of friars, same cord, same color; Vatican II ended a couple of years before. Convents had not yet emptied. They soon did at the parish of my teens. Immaculate Heart's women deserted en masse. Their leftist, artsy community after bitter battles with the Los Angeles cardinal largely laicized. One of the parish's liberated sisters joined the sugarcane harvest in Castro's Cuba.

My attraction to Francis paralled mine to the Jesuits; that congregation may number as few today at my alma mater as friars who still wear habits, not to mention the dwindling veterans of the counterculture once Immaculate Heart's conventual sisters, but the restlessly combative scholarly and ideological legacy of the Jesuits did linger, if you sought it out, at the campus I attended. (California's Franciscans had a radical reputation similar to Jesuits and IHC; unfortunately the Order locally's been embroiled in a $2 million lawsuit for sexual abuse of boys occurring in the 1970s.) I'm glad that at least the original spirit of the founder has been continued by such as the frail feisty friar. Fr. Vitale (who also earned a doctorate where I did, at UCLA) went to my college too, but three decades earlier I imagine its ambiance might have been very different: all-male back then, and probably far more regimented.

If you attended LMU when I did, outside of the chapel's bells and curricular requirement for two philosophy and two theology (renamed after I was there from "religious studies") courses, you might barely register its Catholic imprint. I sought it out, despite or because of my own wavering faith in its tenets, I served on a student committee then with a phrase still not clichéd, "Social Justice." I later worked for an ex-Immaculate Heart professor and studied under ex-Jesuits. Such ex-clergy taught at LMU; they probably outnumbered those colleagues still vowed!

At UCLA, I was busier with my studies, but a classmate told me she'd gone to hear Martin Sheen one evening; this was at the height of the Contra debacle. After the talk, she asked him if he'd like to continue the chat over coffee, and he did. This kindness impressed me, and in the article I learned that Sheen's inspiration came from such men in turn as Fr. Vitale. Despite my on-again, off-again fidelity to the Church during my college and grad school years that decade, my involvement in principled opposition to the voices demanding death plunged me into a formative milieu full of Catholic Workers, who believed utterly in total pacifism. "Pax" is the simple, eloquent, and uncompromising Franciscan motto: a hardcore word, "Peace."

I am not a pacifist; I registered as required legally. I also had to if I wanted financial aid for LMU. The accident of my birth date entered me in the first year ever called up for Selective Service under Carter's doomed end-of-term Persian Gulf Doctrine. As a pessimist, I didn't count on my myopia or even my recent and severe knee ligament injury-- which happened when I was at the Capuchin friary visiting one weekend, providentially perhaps, playing sports-- keeping me out of what loomed as inevitable conflict. I figured we pencil-necks would get dragooned into being stretcher-bearers in a malarial Salvadoran swamp. In hindsight perhaps I exaggerate the call-up threat, but more than once I felt the pressure exerted in the early 80s. One night I talked over tequila with a friend and his older brother in the dorms; older brother attended LMU ten years before. Until drafted for Vietnam. He told us of what he had seen, and of the fate of earlier classmates from our same dorms.

I also asserted, in my letter on file with Pax Christi, a Boston organization, that I was a "selective C.O." who did not equate a moral struggle against Nazis with a geopolitical foray against Contras. This nuanced explanation did not jibe with Draft Board definitions, but it did document that prior to any Armageddon that might erupt as we stared down the Evil Empire, how I was no sudden shrinking violet. I admired Thomas Merton's stance as a total C.O. during WWII, and recalled his sorrow at his brother's death fighting in that same war. But, I knew I lacked the conviction that Merton held, and as a shadow of my boyhood defense against schoolyard bullies, I suppose as a snarly Irishman I also recognized the necessity for putting up your fists, even if no geopolitical brawl met facile slogans as "the good fight." As I've matured, I cannot even cheer on the demise of Spanish fascists or screen Nazis. I wonder why I've changed. I'm still rather mean-spirited and misanthropic otherwise!

At the same time I opposed U.S. policy, I favored the Irish physical-force tradition, as its republicans parsed that phrase. I defended the IRA as a legitimate reaction to the abuse of power and the imposition of illegal rule over a people seeking freedom against another empire. This was also the time of the H-Blocks, the blanketmen, and the hunger strikers, speaking of another legacy that ran askew from that aligning martyrdom with devotion, defiance for a cause, and the suppression of the body's desires so as to empower those of the spirit. Against imprisoned and scourged figures draped in rags akin to the first friars and the perpetual poverellos, far more gaunt than many Franciscans to follow, there were arrayed the police, the troops, and the will of one statelet ruled figuratively by an wicked queen and truly by an Iron Maiden. During the 1916 Rising, Dublin's Capuchins counselled the rebels in prison and heard their confessions before their executions.

I knew less as a child about those Irish revolutionaries-- also "voices demanding death" in a complicated moral calculus that as a younger man I could not sum up and still try to reckon but clumsily now-- than Yanks vs. Krauts. I grew up pretending that my baseball bat tucked under my arm was a rifle, as I played with bags of plastic soldiers I tried to melt under a magnified glass's sunbeam. But even my conservative parents never let me hold a toy gun. Fascinated by WWII as a child, I pored over histories. I received an illustrated tome, full of Life-magazine types of black-and-white photos that documented six years of terror. One shot, of a three dead Marines sprawled in the half-ebb on a deserted Pacific beach, moved me greatly. "From Here to Eternity" indeed. That may have been the crucial image that turned me away from a boyhood dream of entering (if my vision cleared) the "Silent Service" like two of my cousins had recently, in Navy subs off the embattled Vietnamese coast.


Named after my mother's only brother who died (while navigating a "duck" or small landing craft as you see in this photo taken by Life magazine in 1943) in the invasion of Saipan in WWII, I inherited an awareness of both war's futility and its necessity. Neither of my parents despite their considerable leanings towards the right cheered on any hostilities abroad. My mom once remarked on her inability to forget the day the telegram arrived with news of her only sibling's death. My dad commented once, despite his blue-collar Reagan Democrat, lunch-pail conservatism, of how nobody wins in war.

He remarked one night to me, when I was probably about seven or eight, as Walter Cronkite recited on CBS the day's duly reported totals of US, South Vietnamese, and Viet Cong casualties, how unbelievable the count seemed. Our enemy died in numbers far exceeding ours and even our allies, but still, we were losing. This lesson, only a casual aside by him, but the sort of conversation you grow up never forgetting.

So, something resisting the dominant media message and affirming the Christian alternative must have stuck with my parents and then with me. Needing a confirmation name, I learned more about my patron saint. I admired his offbeat humor and uncompromising stance, even if as a brainy sort I wished the Franciscans boasted the intellectual passion of their rival Dominicans, not to mention the famed infamous Jesuits (they always seemed to have the coolest and most daring name, the bold congregation of cosmopolitan Sorbonne grads branding their corporate logo not after a Marian apparition or a misogynistic anchorite, but Jesus Christ Himself).

By contrast, Francis chose for his band of brethren a diminutive: "little brothers," to contend against the corrupt popes and the mighty emperors. The reason Fr. Vitale joined the Order was because of its sense of humor. An aspect I doubt inspired any postulant for the cassocked Jesuits. Nobody cements planters of St. Ignatius next to those of jolly Buddha or gentle Poverello preaching to Brother Sparrow by the birdbath. Still, we often forget that Francis could be fearsomely zealous, and his uncompromising abuse of "Brother Ass" his body wore him out at about my age. (You can read a straightforward account of his life by Adrian House, which I reviewed a few years ago on Amazon US.) To me, it's a pity that he did not live to Fr. Vitale's eminence; perhaps Francis could have curbed the rapid dissolution of his ideals. But then, the truly committed share with those committed for insanity perhaps an inability to conform; I could never eat coaldust or kiss lepers as he did.

The Franciscan combination continues memorable showmanship. As the photo shows, Fr. Vitale wears his habit when he's arrested for the two- or three-hundredth time. Yet, at least as originally intended, there's a self-effacing reserve expected of a friar, akin to that in the Jesuits. You've never heard of him. The man matters less than his mission. This energy did endear the friars to me. Yet, for a young man, there's not much of a place to learn from them if you're academically inclined-- given their founder's distrust of scholarship over service. Therefore, nearing their eighth century, Franciscans run hardly any universities. Compare this absence, being instead in parishes and prisons, with the Society of Jesus, who nonetheless faithful to their founder's apostolate are administering if in theory more than practice over two dozen colleges in America.

Apropos of education, and nodding to Fr. Vitale, he speculates if Francis may have suffered PTSD. I have taught students who come back from Iraq as mentally wounded and physically crippled. For years, nearly every course of mine has had veterans; a large VA hospital's nearby and the city where the campus sits also attracts many here for rehabilitation who take college classes under their deservedly earned benefits, along with coping with their recovery from trauma. I see the legacy of our War on Terror, and my wife's loyal worker has two daughters now enlisted, one off to Afghanistan soon, and his third girl's married to a soldier.

The Peace of Christ may be a luxury that only a majority religion can entertain. Moses killed the oppressive overseer beating a slave. Only a miracle drowned pursuing Pharoah's army. Battles against Hebrews tend to favor their opposition, otherwise. That may be why the Zionist army's called the "Israel Defense Force." The folk memory of always having to be on the lookout in hostile territory, even when one's seen-- by history's spectator but not the Hebrew participant-- as safe at home.

The previous night at our seder, Layne announced that there were nearly two billion Christians and almost a billion-and-a-half Muslims. Facing them: fourteen million Jews and declining rapidly. She wondered if Leo and Niall along with their peers gathered amidst matzoh crumbs and sticky grape juice would profess any allegiance to the faith within which we've tried to raise them, and seemed as I do tacitly to doubt this. Our discomfort with eternal verities grows with our age. I guess we transmit this meme. Richard Dawkins would approve, if not the rabbis and priests. Such a cultural meme may be viral, as Jews of our generation finally find themselves not much different than anyone else, unless they want to dress up as so.

Like the nun or friar who chooses to wear the habit, they make the decision now to stand out, while the Jesuit or Immaculate Heart member blends in. In Francis' time, he wore what the peasant wore. In Egyptian times, all women wore the veils that now only a few Sisters, long descended from such monastic recluses, choose. Sartorial status now is theirs, not imposed by the outside-- for some communities in Jewish laity as Catholic clerisy enforce the fashion, and others do not-- so much as sought by one who selects to take on the outward sign of conformity from the interior passion for discipline and faithfulness to one's promise before one's Maker.

Before that ambiguous Creator, some at our seder table denied heaven or Moses. Others, unaware or uncaring of such precision that fails to align the reenacted seder's Exodus with the historical record, regaled-- if college students of another generation as distant from mine as Fr. Vitale's collegiate experience was-- with chat about condoms at the grown-up's table. At the "kid's table," those mostly teens chattered away as is their wont. Those bar mitzvahed dismissed attention to the Four Questions; no youngsters wore the kippah proffered. Perhaps for aesthetic reasons.

Layne spoke to eighteen people in our home. All but one single man and one family of four were from families less than "entirely" Jewish by its strictest standards. And/or by their own preference. We at the table attest to a change in American Judaism equal to that in the past half-century of its Catholicism. Technically minorities, but no longer relegated to the margins. "Bridget Loves Bernie" in my childhood, "Abie's Irish Rose" in that of my parents; in our pantry we have a bottle of "Soy-Vay" sauce hawked by the nice Jewish guy who met the smart Chinese gal, and vice versa: this millennium's model for assimilation, culinary and coitally.

For mass appeal, it's even more lucrative farther downscale: a Judd Apatow casting choice for the caricatured parents of the designated Jew. Usually the groom (as Hollywood's makers enact their family romance onto the screen), less often the pivotal moment around which the screenplay tenses or the obstacle by which its shlub-like protagonist finds his amorous pursuit of the majority's trophy wife-to-be queen bee constrained. (That Jersey director's married to one rather untalented, prototypically blonde shiksa inevitably as earnest life mirrors hamfisted art.)

Of course, as my wife inevitably chimes in, "Jewish enough for Hitler" is another story. I read how the Wittgensteins, children of Catholic converts in that opportunistic if understandable lateral move that Austrian Jews in the early last century often ran, had to apply to no less than Der Fuehrer himself for dispensation from the Nuremberg Laws, for they had three grandparents tainted: this added up to "full Jew." While the Gestapo commandeered the W's considerable assets, the deal the family brokered earned them reclassified by a legal fiction, as if descended from an Aryan count. Newly half-breeds, mischlings, this status allowed a couple of compromised sisters to emigrate-- despite their earlier naivete when they tried to flee with bogus passports procured in some backwater like Serbia. Such are the tragicomic complications of allegiance, change, and survival when we try to slip away from our uncomfortable past to accommodate to an equally shifty present.

She also read from three letters she'd recently received. These too spoke of past pressures leading to present predicaments, under the imposition of law and order. Three long-term prisoners, one in for life without parole, contacted her through an activist group linking those in jail with Jewish pen-pals. George, Alan, and Joe were not raised in Judaism; all of them were no more than "mischling" themselves, if often fractionally less. All three lacked sustained exposure growing up to whomever were their Jewish forebears. In middle-to-late age, they all had begun behind bars to explore their heretofore submerged or unspoken Jewish ancestry. Now, they all groped for meaning within unfamiliar songs, stories, and rumors from their families, less spoken of by them than silenced.

They will probably not pass along such a legacy to their descendants. Our children, like their own, will bear surnames and probably punims that nobody will peg as Ashkenazi. They will blend in. Perhaps their cousins and children may read such letters and look backwards to their stories, as Marranos dared to in secret or those in New Mexico do today in public. The Jewish whisper often gets drowned out by the larger presence, in a family tree or on the local train. The seder, as we hope for our boys and the other children there, may represent a glimmer that will shine in their unpredictable and perhaps dark futures.

We never know when meaning will strike us in our moment of need. Jailhouse conversions, foxhole atheists, wake-up calls. This morning, coming to work, I began pondering Fr. Vitale's witness. He grew up one town over from me, in San Gabriel. But, a generation earlier, he came of age in an era when Catholicism still permeated the culture within which he studied. However, from a wealthy family, like Francis he grew up without much piety. Like Francis, he was in the military. He dated and lived whatever passed for the postwar fast life.

As a navigator in the Air Force, Louis Vitale had been ordered to shoot down an unidentified plane. He hesitated, and saw then two women waving to him through their commercial craft's window. Shaken by such calculation, he gave up his playboy lifestyle, sold the roadster, and entered the Friars Minor. When he was ordained, he emerged into the Civil Rights era, and did then what St. Francis would have done.

He restored a parish sanctuary, St. Boniface's on the Tenderloin, and when century-old pews were polished, he invited back the homeless of his saint's city to sleep there. A very Franciscan action. Francis' first act that set him on the road to sanctity was when he repaired San Damiano's fallen chapel after a voice from the crucifix directed him to, symbolically and practically, fix the broken Church.

Anthony McIntyre over at "The Pensive Quill" blog exchanged views March 31 ("Kick the Pope") with one anonymous commenter who critiqued A's contempt of what he's called "priestcraft"-- A's supposition that religion cannot be credited with any corner on the market of good works. In his riposte, it's likely that now, such repairs to our shattered world as moved Francis or Fr. Vitale to enter the vowed life may now draw others into, say, Doctors Without Frontiers or a UN-sponsored charity. The secularized expression of one's social conscience can break away from any spiritual foundation.

It's a thoughtful rejoinder to the defense that many make for organized religious communities in need of restoration after so much institutional rot. Yet, I consider the sacrificial weight added to the religious balance in favor, for a few able to take on such a Franciscan level of craziness, of such unworldly obligation. For a few people, and Catholic lay volunteers along with celibate clergy can be counted here, there's an added impetus of giving up one's goods, one's sexual expression, and one's will to do as one wants for a higher cause. I knew a few classmates who entered the "Jesuit Lay Volunteers" on graduation, going off to teach in Micronesia.

The celibacy issue aside-- I argue for parish clergy to marry but not those in religious orders-- I can find relevance for those who, as with the military, give up success for an ideal. Now, the same of course for the U.S. Peace Corps, but it's rarer to find those who give up their whole life in pursuit of ministering to the poor and needy. The structure-- as with the Jesuit program-- appears to shift towards short-term volunteers under supervision of a few "lifers." Most Orders and monasteries can't sustain their schools, hospitals, shelters, and parishes without "layfolk." Post-Vatican II, the Church had to seek this direction out of necessity, even if future popes refuse to alter the stricture for clerical celibacy.

Those who, in a century that offers so many possibilities formerly denied but a few who chose the religious life over a dead-end one, continue to make with sincerity the big commitment earn my respect. Such a lifelong (or if military, career) choice meets with my admiration despite my differences with the particulars of the powerful ideology furthered! I teach those who served in the military, and I have classmates who were ordained priests. They strive towards good lives and aim at good works probably more often than those who carp and snipe at their daily decisions. Their organizations may fail at their lofty goals of protection and persuasion, they do attract the unworthy along with any other human profession, and their ethical stature rises and falls by the same levels of mortal weakness and strength we others live and work within under doubtless less scrutiny.

The military has taken some of my students from the ghetto and barrio out of gangs, away from prison, and given them self-discipline, self-motivation, and self-confidence. Similarly, even if the Catholic model of renunciation is not one I can condone unreservedly, this time-tested regimen does motivate a few very good men and women. Freer from the necessity of making a living and the temptation of wasting one's time away in distractions than the rest of us, they can contemplate great achievements that, if tethered to family, possessions, and selfishness, would not push them to scale such heights of self-sacrifice.

I wish that we had more Peace and fewer Marine Corps within which such aspirations could be achieved, but until lions lie down with lambs, given our evil natures and the need for vigilance, I cannot dictate or fund an alternative to our military structure for many youths who look for a quick way up, out of poverty and ignorance. Fr. Vitale, to his credit, seeks such an alternative, and protests at the military bases. He follows the message of Christ and his Founder. He brings us closer, as do the pen-pal providers and the medical workers in the Congo and the literacy instructors in Kabul, towards the Franciscan vision and the Messianic age of harmony. Maybe Hamas will never lob a rocket from Gaza; maybe Israel will never have to send one back? I admire these utopian panoramas, but until the government funds schools with as much largess as soldiers, this embattled path towards education, through perhaps trauma, is the flawed compromise with Caesar that parallels that paid to Christ. Or, our taxes for the Peace Corps and the U.N. with its olive-branched seal.

I waited for the light rail the day before Good Friday, thinking about Fr. Vitale, who fasts every Friday. I wondered if he ever got used to it. Did he wear his robe out in public when he wasn't protesting? I'd never seen a friar do so. How would you know a Franciscan if he wasn't in his habit? The whole impact of Vatican II appeared to negate this.

But, I wondered, like I did when as a first grader I was shocked when the nuns showed up with hair and not veils one day, and seemingly overnight abandoned the dress within which they were once concealed. Can a Catholic sister or priest, if one blends in totally with one's peers today, as effectively proclaim the Gospel in the cities to which their Founder called them to work among the weak? Those few congregations that insist on traditional habits have drawn more vocations; those like the IHC and Jesuits who did not have not. On the other hand, Jesus would have looked no less Jewish than Moses, no less one rabbi than any other in Jerusalem then as now. He managed to make an impact. Do preachers do so best as anonymous, or when noticed?

I boarded the train to go to work. Near me, a black man about sixty with a bible on his lap lectured loudly a white man about forty with a bicycle helmet on his head. As downtown swung into view, graffiti and abandoned factories, new lofts and bleak concrete river, sluggish freeways under a grey sky, he proclaimed the arrival of the Abomination of Desolation. Homosexuality signified this collapse of morality; the standards had fallen apart all around us in these, definitely the last times. He warned of hostilities and predicted doom.

We passed Fr. Greg Boyle's handsome new Homeboy Enterprises and Homegirl Bakery, nestled near the Chinatown platform, as the man on the Gold Line preached. These businesses help redeem ex-gang members by creating jobs and nurturing skills. I wondered what the Jesuit activist would tell his fellow Christian. How would Fr. Greg exercise his spiritual discernment, as Ignatius counselled, to listen to such a Bible-thumping man out of a Flannery O'Connor story as he'd meet on this MTA train?

That fellow explained his 10/26 arrest. He'd been in jail many times. The train curved around the bend where on one side the tracks look over a few trees under which homeless men camp on a lot full of concrete that promises for lease "4 Acres: Vignes Tower." I see their heads from the angle where I peer out from the train door sharply down. I can see black hair, napped and tight, the same tonsures I have seen many mornings before. The men sit in front of plastic tents, and always appear to be convening for a coffee break from whatever else occupies their time. Among such a raffish crowd, we are told Jesus and the most Jesus-like fanatic of them all, Francis, ministered.

Ignatius, the wounded mercenary who like Fr. Vitale had his epiphany while recovering from the shock of being a soldier, told his elite recruits they could own nothing except in common, forming them into military ranks and steeling them with their own decade-long boot camp as rigorous as any gang initiation homeboys and homegirls might have faced, in and out of incarceration. Across the rail terminus, the L.A. County Jail rises. A lot next to the caffeinated encampment fills with abandoned LAPD cars.

The Gold Line holy man advised his listener to read his 42 books. He encouraged him to look out for his latest, "The Third Tradition." It's "the greatest story never told because it is too long to ever tell," in his parting phrase as we arrived at Union Station.

About a half hour later, on the Metro Blue Line, despite my concentration on my novel-- by a Basque writer from Loyola's homeland, a story opening in San Francisco-- over my iPod I could clearly hear a black woman in her thirties haranguing a black man about the same age across the aisle. I felt again as if transported not past Compton so much as through Carolina. Her exordium culminated in this conclusion: "Which side will you be on? There has been a great falling away but that does not excuse you. Jesus will demand your soul and your life." She then returned to her glowering silence; I don't know what sparked her loud outburst with the man, but her homily may have been in progress before they boarded. Bearing not an olive branch but a sword, the gospel in these streets darkens. In my city Jesus' message resounds apocalyptically this day before billions commemorate that crucifixion of our Prince of Peace.

P.S. As I prepared to post this, I received this Good Friday a Facebook message from an old classmate. Our (now defunct) high school stood next to a mission built two centuries earlier by friars who founded the same province that Fr. Vitale once led. Sister Leo Francis O'Callaghan, CSJ, our chemistry teacher, is now ill. My speech teacher, Sister St. George Skurla, CSJ, and another sister visited her and sent along this report. The names echo on, and only now do I recall that my uncle bore the same confirmation name I do.
Sister St. George and I went to Carondelet Center with Easter baskets today and in the course of it saw Sr. Leo. She looked extremely thin, her hair was a bit disheveled, and I am sure she didn't know who I was. We also met the Sister in charge of the nursing floor, and she told us that they had noticed a definite change in Sister. In fact, they were beginning to do some remote preparation for her funeral vigil and liturgy!
"Protesting Priest's Path Leads Repeatedly to Jail". Richard C. Paddock, Los Angeles Times. April 8, 2009. Photo caption: "Father Louis Vitale greets activist Mariah Klusmire, 19, of Albuquerque before a rally protesting military interrogation training at Ft. Huachuca, Ariz. Klusmire's mother attended events organized by the Franciscan friar before she was born."

P.S. Here's a fine summation:"What St. Francis Did for Humankind."