Showing posts with label First Amendment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label First Amendment. Show all posts

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Stephen Prothero's "The American Bible": Book Review

"Why allow John Boehner or Nancy Pelosi to dominate your book club when Jefferson, Lincoln, and King are in the room?" To arrange such a conversation, Stephen Prothero compiles our nation's "core texts" from our "de facto public canon" into an "American Talmud," offering speeches, songs, stories, and sayings to spark discussion and debate as primary "books." Following each inclusion, he chronologically arranges dissenting and affirming comments from activists, lawyers, politicians, writers, and scholars. Ten "scriptural" sections comprise this biblical inspiration, mixing at first predominantly religiously infused arguments with, as the nation evolves, more secular and diverse texts. Furthering this Boston University professor's survey of contributions to our public discussion of issues that matter, it's a logical follow-up to his 2007 study "Religious Literacy."

Professor Prothero aims "not to create a canon but to report upon one." He seeks to overcome our bipartisan antagonism and our weariness with policies, parties, and principles which seem to shift. Returning key texts that matter to our public conversation, he hopes to renew hope among Americans. In this affordable, thoughtful, and balanced collection, Prothero invites us to listen to what our fellow Americans have discussed over almost four centuries as our necessary exercise in self-government, an experiment as open-ended as any ever attempted by citizens anywhere, anytime.

The book begins, logically, with "Genesis": colonial calls that often reenacted the Exodus story. "Law" follows as constitutional traditions and Supreme Court decisions from Brown in 1954 and Roe v. Wade in 1973. "Chronicles" relate "Uncle Tom's Cabin" and "Huck Finn" excerpts on slavery neatly, while a telling absence of an intended excerpt, denied by the estate of Ayn Rand, allows "Atlas Shrugged" to enter only in its commentaries, not the original text! Surely a moral lurks in this refusal.

Songs as "Psalms" follow, and for "God Bless America," even an Indiana billboard attests to its power, alongside "This Land Is Your Land" for a sharper counterpart to jingoism and patriotic cant. "Proverbs" places aphorisms around a Talmudic pattern of surrounding voices, before "Prophets" announces "Civil Disobedience," Eisenhower's farewell address about the military-industrial complex, King's "I Have a Dream," and Malcolm X's autobiographical defense of his "demagogue" role with a predictably if astutely chosen chorus of dissenting as well as assenting voices joining in as commentary in the decades since, with our current president among poets, pacifists, and preachers.

Lincoln's "Gettysburg Address" opens "Lamentations" fittingly; Prothero prefaces this with an exegesis of how this "new gospel" elevated the Address above not only the "letter of the Constitution" but the "spirit of the Declaration of Independence." It redefined America as more revolutionary than conservative, in the professor's perspective. He then juxtaposes this with another dramatic response to war, Maya Lin's Vietnam Veterans Memorial, and ends that section with Bill Clinton invoking in turn Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address to heal the damage of the Vietnam War.

Appropriately after this division, the book breaks into its "Gospels" with inaugural addresses by Jefferson and FDR, before a surprising entry by Ronald Reagan. Not from his presidency, but from nearly two decades earlier, when on television he endorsed Goldwater and argued against LBJ's Great Society, to set the course for the resurgence of his own career and that of the GOP. Prothero tips his hand perhaps away from the expected tilt of many in academia towards the left. Although his sympathy may hover, he does take pains to present the views of conservatives fairly in such chapters. Examining the comments appended to "The Speech," from Reagan's demythologizing biographer Lou Cannon to his memorialist Sarah Palin, the sharp voices for these polarizing texts prove lively.

After the figures of such bold presidents, "Acts" may seem anticlimactic.  Yet, the Cold War insertion of the "under God" clause into "The Pledge of Allegiance" merits extended analysis in one of the most informative segments. "Epistles" from Washington's "Farewell Address" prove relevant in terms of both the rise of the Religious Right and the controversy over "entangling alliances" as foreign policy. Lesser known one may hazard to nearly any reader than other entries: Jefferson's "Letter to the Danbury Baptists" in 1802, over the separation of church and state. At the time of this letter, a national church was prohibited by the First Amendment, but not by states. The "establishment clause," articulated here by Jefferson, became long a tenet of Democrats--at least until the past decade's return by even many liberal candidates towards espousing in public their own faith.

Faith supports the second document from King, "Letter from Birmingham Jail." No book of revelation or apocalypse concludes this compendium, although the Civil Rights Movement has its own eloquent speakers in the commentaries that follow, if oddly nearly all after the initial unrest during which King's letter was delivered. The epilogue wraps up the presentation with more on the race question, which Prothero emphasizes as the key question in all the "American Bible," as a melting pot has not endured as a model, but a fiercely partisan, multicultural, and multiethnic polity.

Prothero reminds us of competing readings we bring to this anthology's issues. Dissent erupts, even as it's channeled into conversation, as heroes rise and fall and politicians come and go. This dynamic, as this edition represents handsomely (even if the parchment-type of background for primary texts may jostle aesthetically against the brown-on-beige commentary footnoted therein), may not resolve these worthwhile wrangles Americans love to engage in, but they stand for our "shared practice" to argue the public good (I think of the ideal of the founders, a "res publica") as regularly as some go to Mass, attend sermons, or visit temples. (Amazon US 5-29-12 via a review copy; author's website)

Sunday, July 12, 2009

"Brüno" Comes Out

Opening night, my wife (we are permissive when it comes to film; my wife and many of the families we socialize with work in Hollywood so my kids have grown up with a lot of films that others would not see until older; I admit even the ticket seller was warning us) and my younger, if über-sophisticated, son (he wanted to see it without us separately with friends as his 16-year-old brother was--somehow at another theater in the trust-fund boho district-- but little bro could not) saw "Brüno." Quite a few older people walked out during the film, even in hipster downtown L.A. (Older son says nobody did in the Los Feliz-Silver Lake venue, unsurprisingly.) Sacha Baron Cohen as with "Borat" takes on a daring mix of satire and social commentary in his comedy that both celebrates and denigrates how gays often perform in front of straights and how many straights fear and hate gays. Note the verbal distinctions.

This reminded me of [in the threaded discussion for the class I teach in a topic about ethics vs. free speech, a student's] comment about porn-- the film barely got an "R" rather that "NC" rating; I figured better to have my kid see it with us so we could put it into context; my older son is very film-savvy and understands what Baron Cohen's getting at with his satire. One person's erotica is another's smut, I suppose. Although no sexual images or scenes in "Brüno" any more than "Borat" can be seen as titillating! When sexual excess is paraded so comically and obviously, it turns either to humor at its sheer ridiculousness at our body's lusts and longings, or it makes people, as in the movie, walk away in disgust at such revelations.

That's I guess how satire works: it exaggerates our hidden desires and secret behaviors until, as with a stand-up comedian or a gross-out comedy, we can only shrink away in horror or learn to laugh at ourselves and our weak, desperate, and perhaps frightening human desires for attention, satisfaction, fun, and greed. A difficult set of rights to protect by the First Amendment from a time when the Founding Fathers may never have dreamed up what "Borat" & "Brüno" parade on the screen, but I am glad we have the flexibility to have a country that allows such freedom. Others of course condemn America for such folly and warn us of damnation.

Ironic that the film has jokes about Jesus, the Holocaust, Osama, and Hasidic Jews, but when it comes to Michael Jackson, the scene with LaToya had to be cut at the last moment, so as not to offend. Talk about a skewed sense of moral priorities.

The above was my response in the on-line component of the college speech course I have started teaching, to a student body generally very conservative, from immigrant/ first-generation poor or working class backgrounds; so far students in the discussion thread have defended the right to speak about Christianity vs. school restrictions, and debated hate-speech restrictions on campuses vs. claims for First Amendment rights.


P.S. I add that older brother told me only this week that younger brother did not know until only this week what "heterosexual" meant. Although they both doubtless have heard "metrosexual" for years now. Seeing where we live, what they see, and whom they know, is this progress?

See promo film's trailer-- and click for the "Englisch" link but this may have been hacked-- at one of the rare domain names not yet taken, until by the "hottest white guy since Jesus": "MeinSpace.com". Photo from the "Elephant Journal" with links to NY Times review and videos re: film's plea for gay tolerance, or lack of: "Delicious Journeys Through America for the Purpose of Making Heterosexual Males Visibly Uncomfortable in the Presence of a Gay Foreigner in a Mesh T-Shirt"

Tuesday, June 17, 2008


Canada's Unfree Speech

I suppose Islam really does mean submission. Mark Steyn's on trial in Canadian court for his Maclean's cover story (October 23, 2006). He quoted a Norwegian mullah's claim that Muslims are multiplying "like mosquitoes." Steyn now finds himself accused of a hate crime. His predicament reveals not only Canadian tolerance at its most ludicrous, but the New York Times' complicity. I agree--which is not often-- with this perspective advanced by Beltway neo-con journalist Vivienne Goldberg's son Jonah in his op-ed column in today's Los Angeles Times. Goldberg, a token right-winger in an overwhelmingly liberal newspaper, shows up the NYT's own posturing in its craven coverage of Steyn's trial. I might add that it was the first I heard of this trial, when I read Adam Liptak's June 12, 2008, NYT piece. I remember how it surprised me. Liptak's bias tilted away from First Amendment sympathies. He appeared to favor in his selection of viewpoints those who called for censorship of opinions. America, it seemed, was in the minority here and perhaps foolishly so. Liptak included many advocates of restrictions on free speech that offended large groups or caused unease.

In Canada, as Goldberg explains, all that's needed for a claim to go forward is a claim that someone's offended. The process, in Goldberg's judgment, sets up a kangaroo court. Taking offense at Steyn, a New Hampshire-based reporter, the Canadian Islamic Congress filed charges. Maclean's had denied them a forum for rebuttal. Even though the sources number Muslims who are quoted as demanding accommodation with the West, the CIC fumed. Rather ironically, the CIC turned its own complaint into an Exhibit A of free speech in the West under attack by those who wish to place the assertions of belief above those of reason. Even if the assertions leap from the lips of fellow Muslims, they are still seen as damaging to the gentle Muslim sensibilities in Canada. The accused finds himself trapped in an Orwellian star-chamber.

Steyn cannot even summon claims by ecumenical supporters of Islam in his defense. For instance, he cannot borrow the Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan William's infamous estimation that shariah would have to be incorporated in some form into future British law. Such opinions support Steyn's investigation into the spread of restrictive Muslim culture and archaic attitudes across the Western democracies. For, Williams' remarks appeared after Steyn's excerpt from his book, "America Alone," and so are inadmissible. The additional twist that Steyn quotes a Nordic-based imam's triumphalist prediction of the demographic victory of Islam also finds itself distorted by the British Columbian tribunal of the Canadian Human Rights Commission. I suppose unless you can find an anodyne utterance from a believer, best to mention nothing at all. The Human Rights Commission has never in thirty-one years dismissed a case as unfounded.

Steyn is charged with fomenting hate even when-- or because-- he chooses an Islamic cleric's own boast. Free speech, a government prosecutor explains, is an American concept to which this Canadian spokesman (or spokesperson who chooses an identity of the male gender?) gives no value. A judicial haven for anyone infatuated with the politics of victimization, we find Steyn crossing a border into where the burden of proof rests on the one summoned to court. This legal burden makes judges in America (I mean the U.S.) look enlightened still, for once. For the sensitive Canucks, filing the protest itself serves as proof of "guilt" against the one denounced. Talk about blaming the victim. Truly a topsy-turvy rabbit-hole. Perhaps British law has not receded so far from the land where the Queen's profile looms along with the loon.

Two days ago (here and on Amazon), I reviewed the Onion's atlas, "Our Dumb World." Turning to p. 023 ("For the United States, See Pages 9-22," the headline advises), I admit in its defense that our frostier neighbor earns its distinctions. "Nearly as prosperous as the U.S., Canada wastes its resources lowering greenhouse gas emissions and offering paid maternity leave to new mothers, all the while allowing its lagging entertainment industry, struggling fast-food businesses, and weak military to go tragically underfunded."

I suppose I should not be so unsettled at the Steyn case. The Canadians might charge me with ethnocentrism as egregious as that mocked on every page of the atlas. After all, speaking of prejudices from the dominion "where the past comes alive and bores you to death," it's a clash of one typical image against another. On the atlas' next page, I found on the map a citizen "who says 'eh,' 'shoot,' and 'stereotypes are social constructs that not only divide groups of people, but create an oppressive mind-set that hinders progress for all.'"

An oppressive mind-set: look at that Maclean's headline again. "Why the Future Belongs to Islam." Women shrouded, a girl's glowering eyes half-downcast. Hindering progress for all. Satire or prediction?

Adam Liptak: New York Times. June 12, 2008. "Unlike Others, U.S. Defends Freedom to Offend in Speech".

Jonah Goldberg: Los Angeles Times. June 17, 2008. "Canada's Thought Police"

Wednesday, June 20, 2007


Judaism & the Culture of Outburst

Jay Michaelson writes in the May 11 Forward, that I finally got around to unearthing in the clutter amidst remodeling, this article about the recent hypocritical contretemps and manufactured outrage around the remarks by Ann Coulter, Don Imus, and Michael Allen among others. Frankly, the Forverts in our mamaloshen needs to take more credit itself. It first covered the Allen "macaca" remark, tracing it back to a Tunisian Sephardic term of mild abuse, made the linguistic connection with Allen's own less than haimishe mama, and her own evident secrecy over What Did You Do In the (Second) Great War? Allen's own fumbling of the matter amidst "I ate a ham sandwich today" and "my mom boy does she love her pork chops" when confronted with the matter of his own matrilineal links forged with the lost tribes of Israel caused him to freefall in the polls, losing his safe GOP Virginia seat and thus the control of the Senate.

Well, my wife mentioned this article that I did leave out for her. Since I am the Green Party member (but as well as granola I do eat meat, recycle but am not a bicyclist, hate solicitations on doorstep or phone due to this political affiliation) and suspect the purported candidate who ran to show the need for a third party, blame me for Al Gore's loss (while he didn't carry even his own Volunteer State) and all else that's gone wrong in the era of Lil' Bush. Everyone complains about the lack of an alternative. Without voters on the rolls, however, the party cannot keep its presence on the state ballot. Miniscule and quixotic, yet the Greens represent a possibility. And, they even formed with Bertie Ahern's Fianna Fail a coalition in Ireland last week. Like Irish politics, the curse of the craven hangs low over our own elected reps. But, don't expect changes if we get millionaires in office like Hilary or Edwards or even Obama, as they too are all beholden to the same rubber chicken circuit that funds Nancy Pelosi mayor's daughter, and all the silver spoon Rodham- Clinton- Gore- Kennedy Dem dynastic successions themselves. Barring tactical nuclear strikes on the Capitol and fifty state legislatures, no ordinary folks will ever get elected president again. None can afford it.

Those who do pretend to feel our pain love cheap labor illegal or legal. I wonder if the reforms up for debate will only result in another 20 million crossing our borders once the 12 million are legalized. Remember, legality means minimum wages, and business and you and I and anyone needing inexpensive maids or desparate gardeners or cash-paid drywallers will simply drive up to Home Depot or the "hiring center" established for "undocumented" women. Underground economy, that of swap meets and taco trucks and ATMs for payroll, has been estimated at 15-20% of our city's economy. So, who pays for the services these people demand? Teaching and caring for them and their children? America, caught between financial greed and humanitarian morality. Daddy Warbucks loves this situation, can threaten the rest of us with outsourcing or let us off as hired hands by the hour, sans benefits, if we remaining gainfully and legally employed natives raise a fuss. Dems love the new voters, and GOP gets the profiteers.

Yes, Michaelson here tells the truth. This populist, anti-capitalist, pro-American, middle-class position gets nothing but contempt from those who call racist what many ordinary people here want. Yesterday, my speech students decided on a class debate on immigration policy for their final exam. Both illegal and legal immigrants spoke, as well as many whose families fled Pol Pot, or left Malaysia, El Salvador, or India in search of that dream we all share. Mexico, using la frontera as its escape valve, tidily gains $60 billion, at least according to one immigrant who spoke up, sent back that we Americans do not see, either in taxes or investment or profits going into the communities were these immigrants live. One part of me resents this loss to our coffers, the other part hopes this will entice people to stay at home to better themselves rather than make the trek that 10% of all Mexicans already have to El Norte.

Meanwhile, our hospitals totter, our schools groan, and our freeways clog. Many of my students related what they thought was unfair, that they had to learn English right away to survive while millions stay in their enclaves and never fit in. I told them about the matricula consular and the legal fiction that allows illegal residents here to acquire all the accoutrements of our lifestyle. A Belizean woman described how the government gives back tax money paid by illegal immigrants for their children, by allowing numbers to replace non-existent Social Security numbers. Another student spoke of his parents' motel in Bakersfield. Yes, his surname was Patel. They never could take vacations, the workers they hired stole the petty cash, and the parents looked forward to going back to India after three decades here. But, with the wealth they amassed, they would live like rajahs in India while being able to live in the U.S. on and off in retirement, so as to be close to the Americanized kids. The student drives a $90k Mercedes. A Mexican student told that while his father wanted to go back home, he would not. He had to be near his family here. This anchors so many homesick immigrant matriarchs and patriarchs here.

Another student from Cambodia who served in the U.S. military told of the sanctuary movement that gave a cousin his first chance after he got here illegally. One student from Santa Rosa told of his aunt's job in the courthouse processing summonses for those arrested without papers to show up again in court. None ever bother to return; they skip bail to vanish. I doubt if the immigration bill now under debate will improve this chaos.

Tax credits for the rich, subsidies for the poor, and those of us in between get the squeeze. Get your war on. Housing: yesterday I arrived home (after standing up on all three train lines due to overcrowding) to see on our once-empty hillside two new lots for sale. Looming over our vista ten feet away and a hundred yards away, the skies will end and shadows will glow.

Glass & stucco, garishly designed nightmares, supersized sloth to house the new teeming masses. Demographic growth: equivalent of two Chicagos moving or already here by 2025 or so. 100,000 new residents a year in L.A. County alone. In my class of three dozen that I teach at night, none of us had even one grandparent born in Southern California. I know, I live here, I benefit from the labor savings, I drive (but except when stuck with that night class, I do take the bus and train to commute!), and I plug my snout up the cornucopia that we all pig out on, Zayde Allen's trayf or kosher-style, in America. Guilty as charged, j'me accuse, mon frere.

But lately, getting back to my more rarified, idealistic, other blog post today, I do find myself craving less the new CD, the book I have to acquire, the latest this or that. Perhaps this is age. Perhaps wisdom. Perhaps, as the fate of that May 11 Forward shows, too much junk.

I'll let Michaelson shut up my rant with these snippets:

[Speaking of Imus, Michael Richards, & Allen but not Coulter] these offenders were found guilty in the court of public opinion, no matter the profuseness of their apologies — not because they offended American public opinion, but because they expressed it: These celebrities expressed anger, fear and prejudice that many people feel, and feel guilty about feeling, and in language that we, like frightened schoolchildren terrified of punishment, have been sternly warned not to use. Indeed, we have a very Jewish system of condemning certain acts, and a very Christian one of implying evil intents. The result? A cultural moment of intense anger roiling under ubiquitous false speech. And when someone’s ire comes bursting to the surface so publicly, we can’t help but stop and stare.

Consider first the rage, which transcends political ideology. For those on the Left, the reasons include a lost and pointless war, unstoppable globalization, an inept president, climate change, the homogenization of American culture and a shocking erosion of civil liberties. For those on the Right, they include a loss of American prestige, an implacable and barbaric enemy, the “pornographication” of American society, the loss of traditional values and, not least, the loss of European-American hegemony: Classical music and classic rock both giving way to the barbaric beats of rap. Indeed, fully a quarter of the nation thinks that we are trapped in a doomsday war of civilizations, and that “American culture” is being destroyed by unchecked immigration and loss of “values.”

Yet on both the Right and the Left, the rage that is at the heart of these concerns goes unaddressed, even unspoken. Not since Barry Goldwater (or perhaps Pat Buchanan) has a mainstream conservative politician “told it like it is” and given voice to anti-multiculturalist rage — unlike in Europe, where French, Dutch and German elites do so all the time. And on the Left, the last politician to seriously criticize American imperialism, hyper-capitalism and globalization was Ralph Nader, and we all know how that turned out. With mainstream public figures having calibrated their message for maximum inoffensiveness, to actually give voice to any of these deep concerns relegates one to the blogosphere.


. . .

Juxtaposed with this infuriating cocktail of rage and repression is a pervasive culture of B.S., surrounding us with meaningless nonspeech and pointless legalism. By now we’re all used to endless phone trees (“To ensure customer service, this call may be recorded”); operators in Bangalore pretending to be from Topeka; divesting ourselves of shoes and fluids at the airport; flight attendants reciting legal formulae from rote and ubiquitous “customer service” initiatives.

Enter the outburst. Again, the press tends to treat these explosions as if they’re offenses against the American way, but really they’re expressions of it. These bigoted outbursts are angry, honest and against the rules — rules with which many, many people do not agree. No wonder we can’t help but watch; we get both the frisson of a taboo being transgressed and the sense that there but for the grace of God go I.

Americans have never much liked double-talk, at least in theory; “fancy speech” is for the Europeans, and “Give ’em hell, Harry” Truman is the kind of hero only this country could produce. But our current culture offends an even deeper norm: that people are supposed to be judged not by how best they conform to a set of written rules, but by the truth of their souls. In our idealized town squares, courtrooms and homes, we’re meant to be judged on who we really are, not just on what we say or do. After all, aren’t we supposed to evaluate our fellow citizens by “the content of their character”?

If this sounds religious, it’s because it is. Our current agon around political correctness is a direct repetition of one of the fundamental struggles of Judaism and Christianity: the great debate between Paul and the talmudic rabbis. In Jewish law, the emphasis is on acts, not intentions; deed, not creed; external duties, not internal predilections — circumcise the flesh; avoid forbidden foods; do not do work on the Sabbath. Early Christianity, in contrast, places the emphasis on the internal rather than the external — circumcise the heart, not the flesh (“Real circumcision,” said Paul in Romans 2:29, “is a matter of the heart — it is spiritual and not literal”); act with love, not with ritual purity; have faith. The Talmud spelled out the details of tort law, but Jesus asked us to love our enemies. Jewish law governs the body (what you say, what you do), Christian faith the soul (what you feel, what you believe). For biblical and talmudic Judaism, there is no “who we really are” apart from what we actually do, but Jesus called the Pharisees “whitewashed tombs, which on the outside are beautiful, but inside… full of the bones of the dead and of all kinds of filth.” (Matthew 23:27)

Today we have cooked up a toxic brew of the Jewish and the Protestant. On the one hand, our taboos are very “Jewish.” They govern the external (what one says), not the internal (what one feels); in the hyper-PC world, you can be as racist or communist as you like, as long as you keep your mouth shut. (Indeed, the whole post-outburst conversation is like some political parody of “Seinfeld,” parsing the meanings of “nappy-headed” and “macaca,” condemning the utterers of these talismanic phrases.) On the other hand, our response to these Old Testament transgressions is a New Testament assumption that racist speech means a racist heart. At the risk of oversimplification, the Jewish approach is “Thou shalt not say this word.” The Christian approach is “Thou shalt not have this thought.” And our current approach is “If you say this word, you probably have this thought, and so we condemn you.” Thus by necessity we’ve all become whitewashed tombs, ever on the lookout for the slightest trace of filth.


. . .

Without a respectable forum for conservative concerns about race, sexuality and ethnicity, or liberal ones about economic and social justice, we’re reduced to a nation of pathetic and puritanical detectives, looking for hints of animus in cryptic utterances, and ever more closely holding the reins of what we are and are not allowed to say. Yes, our Pharisaic system of speech-patrol has made hate speech unacceptable in polite circles. But is enforced politeness really the way to truth — or reconciliation?


http://www.forward.com/articles/judaism-and-the-culture-of-outburst/

Monday, May 7, 2007




J. F. Powers: Hissing of Suburban (Rectory) Lawns


J.F. (James Farl Powers) was born in Jacksonville, Illinois, the same year as my dad and a year before my father-in-law, 1917, dying in 1999 at Collegeville, Minnesota (home of St. John's the largest Benedictine monastery in America and its adjoining, well, former college!). Powers was once highly regarded in the decades when Thomas Merton, Flannery O'Connor, Dorothy Day and Walker Percy spoke along with Powers about American Catholic culture. I never knew until researching this blog entry that he was a CO in WWII (takes some commitment) and at the height of the war joined the Catholic Worker Movement. Thirteen months in jail for draft resistance in 1943 in what must have been a difficult experience, to say the least. His sharp wit and fierce commitment may have mellowed a bit with the years, but his photo shows a man with a scowl, as much at himself than at the world he knows he too is haplessly and helplessly tangled up in, as much as his priests who must deal with bills to pay and prayers to say with equal devotion. Jim Powers hit his stride in the late 40s, and he's linked with postwar Catholic triumphalism-- not his but that of his subjects, mainly small-town clergy stuck between the Windy City and the Twin Cities in the fictional dioceses of Great Plains and Ostergothenburg. I think of Iggy Pop from Ypsilanti, last name Osterberg, born around, well, 1947.

Powers for his later reputation as a writer remembered more by his peers than by his audience may be blamed on his own Midwestern humility and commonsense, far removed from the bicoastal swagger. He admired the diligence and industry of the common folks, from which he came, and as a failed salesman in the Depression knew what it was like to tough it out. Couldn't afford college. Had to be a writer even if it meant a hand-to-mouth existence less comfortable than that of many of his fictional creations. However, he had contacts who had moved up, and perhaps dropped him a few tidbits of gossip or insight that he could embed in his stories. At least one contact, a boyhood friend, became a highly influential priest in the pre-Vatican II movement for reform. A reform that perhaps did in the Church as he knew it best. Powers remains self-effacing, perhaps one more reason I have always liked his work. He observes, fades in and out of the presence of his subjects, preferring to let them speak for themselves or, give them enough rope....

Powers, if less dramatically than his better marketed and often more gladhanding peers, examined the Catholic edifice that a century of immigration, financial savvy, and episcopal finagling had erected. Not its triumphalist post-war expansion into sprawling parish-church-convent complexes, acreage of teeming children in uniforms, phalanxes of seminarians pushing dorms to bursting as Vatican II was convening. Out of this, priests had to deal with shaking hands with donor devils. How else were the children of God going to be wise unless they cozened up to the wiser children of the world. What a haunting passage from the admonitions of Jesus in John. The priests in Powers follow this injunction with all its terror and ennui and despair, ultimately having to rely on a faith that their exterior actions, delineated by Powers by action rather than commentary, convey. Rather than Bing Crosby or Jimmy Cagney or even Karl Malden, the priests in Powers deal with less dramatic or less contrived battles. Powers shows us the spiritual malaise of the priests, the ennui of those who had to live another half century after their early piety had ebbed, going through the motions at some concrete and glass monstrosity rising above the new sidewalks and tract homes. Still, perhaps for the last time in American Catholicism, these frontline clergy in their unheralded way soldier on their own viae dolorosae.

A couple of rural dioceses in largely Lutheran Minnesota, Germans with stolid temperaments, some Catholic and some not when such distinctions mattered, and the occasional Irish American priest or layperson thrown in for ethnic color. Unpromising on the surface. All the more challenge for a skilled writer in the waning days of Catholic separatism and parochial "we're number 2 so we try harder" to limn. "Second only to Standard Oil" was titled a chapter of Powers' first novel about a preacher of the Clementines (whose rivals were the Dolomites and Dalmatians, not to mention the Jesuits and Redemptorists) among the Land of Lakes and Chicago and forlorn retreat houses in between, "Morte d'Urban," which won the National Book Award in 1963. Powers takes this mundane subject of a smart, worldly cleric's reassignment to the boondocks and out of it he turned his savage critique of a materialist and almost cruelly calculating society and out of it made a quiet work of art about a priest's immersion, and not only once at a conveniently placed climax but in true Catholic form over and over in bumbling, unexpected, and tragicomic epiphanies, in an incomplete and more realistic form. Protestants stress salvation as known prior to death. Catholics, at least like Fr. Urban and his maker, know better of their creator.

Fallon Evans, with whom I took Brit Lit for credit at LMU and an Irish Lit class for fun at the remnants of Immaculate Heart, compiled in 1968 a thin volume of critics responding to Powers. I see how John V. Hagopian contributed a volume to the Twayne series, which seems to have covered every author alive by now, in 1970, and that's it. Nancy Hynes OSB mentions on the Nimble Spirit writer's site how she's working on the biography of Powers. Moments ago it occurred to me that I had not come across any such lengthier work, so I figured I had better look Powers up before embarking on yet another Grand Project that one day later I find Someone Else has already beaten me to, story of my academic career. I wish Sister Nancy the best of luck, and the reissue by NY Review Press of Powers' two novels "Morte d'Urban" and "Wheat That Springeth Green" (1988) as well as the collected stories from his three anthologies ["Prince of Darkness," (1953), "The Presence of Grace" (1969), and "Look How the Fish Live" (1975)] is welcome. Perhaps, as with many on the NYRP backlist, Powers is a "writer's writer," but we need such guides in our Slough of Despond as we modern day pilgrims trudge our Teva'd and Birkenstocked Pilgrim's Progress.

Lest you pigeonhole JFP as another Catholic Novelist to be patronized and ignored if you do not dip your finger in the holy water font, may I add he has written about cats, Negroes (as they were called in Powers' pacifist days in the wartime of These United States) and the sandlot with equal verve. (The lastmentioned ensured his place in the Library of America's "Baseball: A Literary Anthology" which Spuds will like when a bit older.) Powers for me shines best in his stories. Very droll, midwestern, and poignantly wry. No easy feat. When priests had training not in psychiatry but polyphony. Homiletics-- not that it helped much-- more often than hermeneutics. Reminds me a bit of George Saunders in a pre-cubicle, pre-glass windowed conference room time of "The Office." Grandchildren of Powers' mid-century grey flannel communicants and greying clerics may have abandoned candlelit devotions to crown a plaid-skirted colleen or bambina Queen of the May, K of C, and Legion of Mary for the flickering pleasures of the Wii, plasma HDTV or Blu-Ray, but the discomfort remains. Is that all there is?

Richard Weber's piece in a 2000 issue of Notre Dame magazine sums up the "deadly serious" tragicomic quality of this chronicler of Midwestern dull days and long celibate nights that tempt us all no matter our own vowed state of grace or the number of occupants in the bedroom of our chosen residence. The Noonday Demon, we realize, tormented Powers and his characters relentlessly, amidst these somnolent car lots and TV-droned rec rooms. Powers imagines lives among meddling housekeepers, annoyingly scrupulous penitents, and basement sodality socials. It's also why JFP never had a calling himself-- too reluctant to spend his decades kibitzing with old maids on the front steps after Mass, or kissing up to fat cats so the temperature= dollar gauge on the painted billboard outside those same steps would move up a notch or two to show the building fund's rise. God & Mammon, the priest trying for holiness on the golf course, told to render unto Caesar: JFP finessed these clerical and lay tensions very well. Within a decade, it seemed to him and me, this all vanished.
http://www.nd.edu/~ndmag/w2000_01/weberw00.html

There is also a misleadingly titled Sept. 2006 blog entry on First Things by Joseph Bottum called "Bottum: The Greatest Catholic Writer of the 20th Century" which is actually not self-promoting the blogger but, as it should be, about Powers. Bottum accurately locates the first cause of Powers' subsequent semi-obscurity in the last third of the 20c to the decline of clerical authority, the post-conciliar slump in both priestly vocations and hierarchical pomp, and the assimilation of Catholics into the secularized American mainstream after nearly two hundred years of separatism both wished for and foisted upon them.

The past week, I may add, Boston U.'s Stephen Prothero energetically promotes his new book calling for if not fluency than a barebones "Religious Literacy" by students in college. I suppose high school would be too contentious. Evolution can't even stay in textbooks without disclaimers, so imagine apologists and detractors of a comparative religion course meant to praise every faith-based contingent without offending anyone else that still meets the cleverly worded and magnificently conceived establishment clause of our First Amendment.

Few of my students when I ask them about the curse on Adam & Eve after they're expelled from Eden have any clue what I mean. Most nominally are still Christian, but with growing numbers from Africa and Asia, I am not so sure-- Copts, Hindus, Buddhists, and the unaffiliated mingle with the few who know about the Reformation or Gutenberg. Nobody seems to put those two into a cause and effect relationship, but a college instructor has to justify his pay, no? (Although those ads during Dodgers games for union-trained pipefitters making more than I do on the non-tenured treadmill midcareer and twelve years post PhD tempt me to a midlife crisis.)

The new Steve Carell movie may teach them about Noah, but there's widespread ignorance about Pandora's Box, the flight of Icarus, Dr. Faustus, or even the Sorcerer's Apprentice in "Fantasia." Nobody knows what's a muezzin, what distinguishes Buddhists from Hindus, or what Muslims are enjoined to do five times a day. And yet most profess a vague identification with what used to be known as gospel truths. http://www.firstthings.com/onthesquare/?p=461

(Image note: daughter Mary Farl Powers-- these Irish Catholics I know, not very original with the names over generations as I bear semi-silent and grudging testimony to every day I sign my own moniker-- went to Ireland and became an artist, a member of Aosdana in 1981 and QED a distinguished talent before her own death in 1992. She was born there. JFP and family lived in Greystones south of Dublin twice for two year stints and once in Dalkey for the same. Two times in the 1950s, one in the early 60s. A sign of the times: they could live cheaper in Ireland off his occasional story sales to the likes of The New Yorker than back in Minnesota while he taught creative writing on and off at the U of M or the other U of M[ichigan]-- or Marquette, or the decidedly non-Midwest Smith! P.S. Is not a farl a potato bread roll-- not a bap!-- in the North? This via the NI Arts Council is of Mary's print "Emblements.")