Showing posts with label Beats. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Beats. Show all posts

Wednesday, January 27, 2016

"Encountering Buddhism in Twentieth-Century British and American Literature": Book Review


While cross-cultural studies of the transmission and reception of Buddhism within historical and sociological contexts multiply, those examining literary aspects remain less common. These eleven essays examine American and British authors during the past century who have taken up Buddhist themes; some of them have taken refuge in Buddhism. Aimed at an academic audience, these entries generally remain accessible to a broad readership. This collection, despite its high price as sold by an academic press, may appeal to many inquirers intrigued by its wide coverage.

Introducing this book’s range, co-editor Lawrence Normand surveys the reception and adaptation of Buddhism in the West. He cites Donald S. Lopez and David McMahan. He supports their responses to the ways in which Buddhism has been reshaped for twentieth-century concerns. Lopez and McMahon have analyzed how meditation and modernism influence recent cultural trends. Normand notes more of an emphasis on the needs of the body. The contemporary insistence of concentrating on the breath focuses on the mental flow of images. This shift engages more than one of the authors investigated by Normand’s international colleagues.

Erin Louttit in “Reincarnation and Selfhood in Olive Schreiner’s The Buddhist Priest’s Wife and Undine” reminds readers that this South African writer, despite her late-Victorian period of production, looks forward in time. Both the story of the priest’s wife and Schreiner’s novella Undine humanize and normalize Buddhism. Death is blurred. The self survives the body in her post-Christian perspective. Schreiner considers and acknowledges possibilities of reincarnation.
 
Normand’s “Shangri-La and Buddhism in James Hilton’s Lost Horizon and W. H. Auden and Christopher Isherwood’s The Ascent of F6” contrasts two treatments of this earthly paradise. Thanks to its film adaptation, Hilton’s 1933 novel endures as certainly more popular than Auden and Isherwood’s ambitious if flawed drama. Incorporating historical crises and struggles of personal alienation, both channel the appeal of the late-Victorian romances which J. Jeffrey Franklin in The Lotus and the Lion (2008) investigated in imperial and colonial British literature. Hilton’s quest entices the reader as if possible; Auden and Isherwood’s satire demolishes the dream as futile. However, the limits of the duo’s Buddhist sources (including Alexandra David-Neél’s With Mystics and Magicians in Tibet) blunt the dramatic impact of their barbed points.

Via readings of D.T. Suzuki, Erin Lafford and Emma Mason take up another poet’s mid-century approach to Buddhist content. In “‘ears of my ears’: e. e. cummings’ Buddhist prosody,” the pair (sticking to that author’s conventionally unconventional spelling), looks at Cummings by way of Martin Heidegger. This philosopher’s challenge to the ego atomizes the sense of self. Similarly, Cummings’ poems, grounded in the breath’s rhythms, aspire not to human voice but to birdsong, in Lafford and Mason’s report on this poet’s craft. It rewards listening, meditation, and silence.

The center of this anthology finds many names repeating, as Cummings and Suzuki begin to sway other writers and thinkers. “Zen Buddhism as Radical Conviviality in the Works of Henry Miller, Kenneth Rexroth, and Thomas Merton” features three leading advocates during the period during and especially after WWII who begin to react against conformity. Manuel Yang applies Ivan Illich’s “radical conviviality” as akin to the “creative spontaneity and non-attachment” connecting these three countercultural creators. (p. 72) Promoting “spontaneous convergence,” the trio shares a commitment to a “non-action, non-institutional” form of “spiritual assonance,” their non-conformity appealing to dissidents. Yet, many then conformed.

They conformed as the Beats. The appeal of Buddhism for 1950s seekers rebounded off of two other poets based in the Bay Area during this restive postwar period. “Radical Occidentalism: The Zen Anarchism of Gary Snyder and Philip Whalen” offers James Patrick Brown’s analysis. He shows how the Beats adapted Suzuki’s teachings into a nascent counter-cultural milieu. Brown avers: “Suzuki translated Zen into an American idiom that hit some of the keynotes of American anarchism: a rejection of cultural conditioning, institutionalism, and traditionalism; an affirmation of individualism and radical self-reliance in the Thoreauvian vein; and a language of revolutionary aspiration.” (pp. 94-95) For more about these anarchist roots within American Transcendentalism, a translation of the Slovenian professor Ziga Vodovnik’s The Living Spirit of Revolt: The Infrapolitics of Anarchism (Berkeley CA: PM Press, 2013) is recommended.

Unsurprisingly, “Buddhism, Madness and Movement: Triangulating Jack Kerouac’s Belief System” follows. Any analysis of American Buddhist literature should include Kerouac. What has been less examined, as it lacks pop culture appeal, is his retreat back to boyhood Catholicism after his 1950s immersion into Buddhism. Bent Sørensen explains the breakdown of his “hybrid system of faith,” triggered by a 1960 visit to those whom Kerouac called the “Mexican Fellaheen” or poor peasants. (p. 106) He pivoted from a romanticized fatalism to “a complete lack of compassion” for those who refused to better their condition. Kerouac, fueled by drink, flirted with madness as his guilt persisted and his sense of sin returned. His characters by the 1960s often entered silence, before death. Kerouac accounted for their dire straits by resorting to Christian rationales “as a punishment for sin.” (p. 118) Like their author, his protagonists try to move on, but samsara catches up with them and thwarts their doomed quests to escape justice.

Another gloomy fiction from the early 1960s depicts this “cyclical nature of suffering.” (p. 136) “Biology, the Buddha and the Beasts: The Influence of Ernst Haeckel and Arthur Schopenhauer on Samuel Beckett’s How It Is” displays Andy Wimbush’s recovery of Haeckel’s A Visit to Ceylon (1882). Beckett mentions this author in his grim 1964 novel (translated from Comment C’est (1961). Both versions plunge into an unsparing reduction of existence through an agonizing series of reincarnations. These enable torture of lower life-forms by the Sinhalese, witnessed by Haeckel. While the natives do not kill beasts and creatures, the Sinhalese justify treating them badly. For, they reason, if they had not merited life in such debased versions, they would not be such. This application of Buddhist concepts to real-world dukkha sobers the reader.

A return to Isherwood, now living in a more congenial incarnation in Southern California, finds him thriving. In “‘That Other Ocean’: Buddhism, Vedanta, and The Perennial Philosophy in Christopher Isherwood’s A Single Man,” Bidhan Roy shows how not only the author’s well-known immersion into Vedanta but his exposure to Buddhism and fellow British expatriate Aldous Huxley enters the 1964 novel, based on Isherwood’s own sojourn. Filtered through popular reinterpretations of Buddhism in vogue by then, Isherwood’s novel reveals his sympathy with Buddhism, contrasted with the arch satire he and Auden had deployed for The Ascent of F6.

For writers closer to our time, “Maxine Hong Kingston’s The Woman Warrior as Mahayana Meditation” finds Sarah Gardam examining Pure Land sutras and Mahāyāna emptiness doctrines. Gardam uses these to explicate Kingston’s Chinese “talk-story” in her 1986 memoir.

Elena Spandri’s “The Aesthetics of Compassion in Iris Murdoch’s The Sea, the Sea” affirms another doctrine, that of the Middle Way, as a compliment to Murdoch’s philosophical career. This champions humanism rather than a Kantian or utilitarian ethics in her 1986 novel. A compassionate ethics wins out, in Spandri’s articulation of Murdoch’s plot and character choices.

The final entry tackles one more formidable topic, arguably more arcane than any philosophy. “Strange Entanglements: Buddhism and Quantum Theory in Contemporary Nonfiction” unravels the tangle of two popular if recondite genres. Anglo-American popularizations of physics and debates or attempts to reconcile debate between science and religion both, in Sean Miller’s energetic chapter, seek to posit parallels between physics formulae and Buddhist or Taoist descriptions of phenomena. Fritjof Capra, B. Alan Wallace, Matthieu Ricard, and Trinh Xuan Thuan typify decontextualized efforts. Miller doubts their truth-claims for dharma as science.

He finds futile their attempts to reconcile Sanskrit texts full of “imaginative parataxes.” (p. 205) Contemporary exegetes wind up at dead-ends. They wriggle in fudge factors and they refuse to admit their results, which tally only as logical incoherence. Miller pinpoints irony in the Vietnamese-born, American-educated astrophysicist Thuan’s deferral to the “ecclesiastical authority of a French-born Buddhist monk who resides in Nepal.” (p. 214) On the other hand, according to the French-language version of his eponymous website, Ricard earned a Ph.D. in cellular genetics in 1972, after which he entered monasticism.  Miller could have delved deeper into Ricard’s scientific training, as how much Ricard has kept up with his past field and that of astrophysics alongside his Tibetan adaptation and practice, granted, remains a relevant topic to debate. All the same, Miller relishes the chance to tackle a topic which diverges drastically in tone and approach from his predecessors, and this intriguing chapter deserves attention for that.

Miller concludes by summing up the current position of Buddhism in the West. “Stripped of its literary and cultural contingencies, in its mildest form, Buddhism becomes a form of self-help therapy contained by a consumerist market-logic, a happy face put on a liberal humanism purified of reductive materialism. And at its most stringent, Buddhism becomes a form of submission to a hierophantic theocracy, however benign.” (p. 213) This collection needed this voice calling out what some of these writers treated tended to sidestep or gloss over: the manner in which messages of Buddhism warp through our capitalist mindset into globalized commodity.
 
Normand in his introduction noted how pre-1945, the textual approach of T.S. Eliot and Hermann Hesse’s Buddhist “engagements” dominated Western reactions. (p. 15) But, neither Normand nor subsequent contributors elaborate sufficiently as to how these “engagements” entered texts during the last century. The earlier impact of Edwin Arnold’s bestselling life of the Buddha as The Light of Asia (1879), J. Jeffrey Franklin has begun to show, reverberated into the next century. This issue, likewise, does not earn any mention beyond Normand’s few references.

All the same, this book’s emphasis on the Beats, more than its scattered coverage of writers after the 1960s, should encourage more research by scholars. Additionally, Sean Miller’s divergent if necessary exploration of a dimension of Buddhism in non-fictional literature may encourage scholars to pursue the portrayals of Buddhism in other scientific and philosophical contexts, a subject needing as much if not more attention than, say, Kerouac’s appropriations of the dharma. For now, this anthology serves readers as a portal, opening up into a display of texts which have integrated Buddhist characters, settings, debates, and insights, gathered during the past century.

Thursday, June 4, 2015

"Reading Allen Ginsberg, Talking Civil Rights"


Award-Winning Teacher Fired for Reading an Allen Ginsberg Poem: so writes David Freedlander in the Daily Beast. As I have taught Ginsberg to a diverse cohort  in college and met with varying reactions of disgust, resignation, and acceptance, I wanted to share this article about this memorable lesson. "The poem the student discovered and brought in was 'Please Master,' an extremely graphic account of a homosexual encounter published by Allen Ginsberg in 1968 that begins: 'Please master can I touch your cheek / please master can I kneel at your feet / please master can I loosen your blue pants.'"As Freedlander places this in context of Game of Thrones and Fifty Shades of Grey, he also wonders if part of the crackdown is due to discomfort with the gay message, rather than the act itself.

The district ruled that David Olio, a nineteen-year veteran of the South Windsor CT system, showed “egregiously poor professional judgment,” by reading the poem aloud in the AP English class. Many of the students were 17 and 18 years old, some taking this course in conjunction with UConn for college credit. While this, as friends on FB have countered, does not excuse the fact that students had no choice but to listen to the poem, I wondered if the AP context mattered--I got the reply that it did not, and that this showed unwise judgment on Olio's behalf. What would you have done? Hurriedly suggest another poem might be discussed instead? Asked the class for feedback? Refused to talk about it? Those reactions in turn, given our tremulous times, ironically might have singled out Olio as intolerant. Well, one student had complained that he or she could not focus on a test in a another class the day after this poem had been discussed in the AP course. Three weeks later, Olio had to resign.

Freedlander avers: "to call Olio’s reading of the poem a mistake—a poem a student brought to class and asked to be read—is to say the reading of a work by one of the towering figures of 20th-century American poetry is out of bounds. 'Please Master' was written in 1968, just before the Democratic convention in Chicago would erupt in riots. Ginsberg had already been put on trial for obscenity in 1957 for his poem 'Howl,' which with its casual depiction of gay sex and drug use, and lines like 'The asshole is holy,' was considered far outside the bounds of what was considered good taste. A judge, however, ruled that the poem had 'redeeming social importance' and was unlikely to 'deprave or corrupt readers by exciting lascivious thoughts or arousing lustful desire.' I doubt, having taught "Howl," having shown the innovative (if widely panned) film adaptation, that Allen seduces anyone--at least on the page. His portrayal by James Franco may, but many of my students cringed.

Helen Vendler, one of the nation's leading poetry critics, wrote on Olio's behalf: “Given what students are already exposed to via TV and film, Ginsberg’s poem, which concerns a well-known form of abjection (whether heterosexual or homosexual) reveals nothing new.” Courtney King, a former student and now a planning commissioner, puts it more bluntly. "I mean, if there are parents in town who think their teenagers don’t know what a blow job is, they are sorely mistaken.” She sums it up: “In defense of this whole imbroglio, at least it got people in this town reading Ginsberg.”

My blog title comes from a lyrical fragment I heard back in high school. It was sung by a musician who had an early song banned by the BBC in the late 60's for the f-verb. Al Stewart's "Post WWII Blues" in appropriately Dylanesque homage, from his 1974 song-cycle Past, Present and Future, first exposed me to Christine Keeler, Nostradamus, Lord Grey's phrase about the lights going out in Europe as WWI rose, Warren Harding's middle name, and the Soviet tank battles on the steppes. It's much better than his hits that dominated easy-listening AOR in that decade, be assured. The image caption, expanded, cites Ginsberg: "To gain your own voice, you have to forget about having it heard. Become a saint of your own province, your own consciousness." But not too provincial, Connecticut.

Thursday, March 6, 2014

Andrew Schelling's "The Wisdom Anthology of Contemporary North American Buddhist Poetry": Review

The contributions of the Beats (see the complimentary collection Big Sky Mind ed. by Carole Tonkinson a decade earlier) to Buddhist culture continue to gain documentation. Naropa Institute professor (and former chair of the Jack Kerouac School of Disembodied Poetics) Andrew Schelling lists those who follow the pioneers. He explains in his preface that he encounters in many contemporary poets here a more casual diction "as though one reasonable person were conversing intimately to another."  He compares this style to that of ancient Chinese verses that reminded listeners of  "gnawing on withered wood'": the results tend towards a calm, unhurried approach. While some poets strive for levity, straining to shake one awake, to shout, to beckon, to entertain, most settle down to ponder and ruminate, as this context would lend itself to further, of course.

Schelling shifts attention to thirty living poets; a few Beat veterans (Diane di Prima, Lawrence Ferlinghetti, Joanne Kyger, Michael McClure, and the exception, the late mentor of many, Philip Whalen) feature here. The alphabetical order ensures that the new and the old share pages; this directs a reader to surrender expectations, to find fresh names. Still, Gary Snyder stands out as one who conveys vividly the power of nature and the presence of people, in suburbanized or remaining rural landscapes of California, through the eyes of those of us who burrow into both locales.

The first selection in his section, "Breasts" snaps to attention with a vivid image:
". . .So we celebrate breasts
We all love to kiss them
            --they’re like philosophers!
Who hold back the bitter in mind
To let the more tasty
Wisdom slip through
            for the little ones.
            who can’t take the poison so young. . ." (excerpt qtd. 300)

Shin Yu Pai's "Office Feng Shui" evokes the artificial nature (literally) of transplanting Eastern sensibilities into Western space. She uses a prose-poem block to force the meaning into a package, imitating the pressure exerted by expectations of conformity, suitably limiting form into content. As Schelling notes in his introduction, the energy of those schooled by heritage as well as initiation into the Asian contexts infuses many of these poems, and represents a wider basis for future progress among Americans (despite the subtitle, Canadians aren't much to be found, but one Chilean exile is.)

Similarly, if with a looser, more typically modernist line, the more fragmented approach of other poets, younger ones influenced (as are their forebears) by the Beats and the far older Asian writers continues. Hoa Nguyen's sensibility filters a broader heritage, one shared by her counterparts in this anthology, but rarely achieved as well, and as succinctly, as here, in one Schelling justifiably singles out in his introduction. [Roll in Your Skull Gone Green]

"Roll in your skull gone green
like a mossy cog that wings
Sing the good times
You seem a tiny wrecked thing to me
something sacred           where time has gone
old and green       Norse
hymns bringing dawn" (qtd. 195)

Dale Pendell's rambling but engaging prose exegesis on "Amrita" explores entheogens and argues back and forth the benefits or drawbacks of stimulants compared to meditation practices taught by traditional Buddhists. This entry broadens the intellectual value of this collection, and perhaps a follow-up volume with more essays on such topics might be a fitting venture for Wisdom Publications. This one, appended with a helpfully annotated bibliography, guides the seeker to the few previous anthologies and to key works by many contributors, and venerable Asian and Western predecessors. Schelling emphasizes translations, and he includes prose studies as well as verse.

Whether the top thirty playlist that comprises most of this volume soothes the audience today or lulls it to sleep depends on your sensibility. This fills a need, but does it peer far enough outside itself? The imprimatur of the small press, the adepts who leave home whether in Asia or Brooklyn to find their way to the Bay Area, and a zendo there (or sometimes a Santa Fe/ Boulder Tibetan teacher) imprints itself heavily on those whom Schelling knows and who print and support and mingle together.

While this editor (and contributor himself) is well-placed to assemble this anthology on these merits, the results favor M.F.A. earners, grant wranglers, the footloose but somewhat secure students able to enter monasteries for awhile or devote themselves to intense practice. This may be expected, for who else would be sought out, visible enough, to be chosen for inclusion? A necessary beginning, but where are the rebels? Maybe it's a tautology.

However, for most folks, who rarely read poetry, who must make a living by means other than poetry, one wonders--when perusing the biographical bylines before each writer--where the rest of America is when it comes to Buddhism, the creative arts, and those not in the zendo in the usual Western (American: moving to if not staying in the Bay Area appears nearly a prerequisite for admission) settings. Outliers appear rarely in these circles. Are there better entries unsolicited, from those trapped in a cubicle 9-5, who struggle with laundry and carpools, commutes and cable t.v. options?

Maybe they lack tutelage to write worthy poems. Maybe they need workshops, retreats, and contacts. I did not find enough of my own experience in nearly four hundred pages of verses draped down, crammed tight, floating and measured, but that may be, poet-practitioners may correct me, the fault of my own lack of insight compared to theirs. I hope I'm humble enough despite my critique to acknowledge this lesson, even as I try to examine from a curious but distant perspective this volume. (Amazon US 8-29-12)

Saturday, March 1, 2014

In Search of Buddhist Fiction

Daydreaming as a college instructor with limited courses assigned over and over teaches me "what goes around comes around." Faced with a Lazy Susan rotation and a steam-table of mandated texts and modules, I yearn to explore ideas not only on my own as in my reading but within a circle of students, given my avocation.

Lately, two ideas while sitting in my bathtub. Given where I live, I'm not sure Irish or Irish American fiction's the easier L.A. sell. Kicking around an idea for an imaginary course in option two, much as I suspect airy dabblers or self-realized adepts in these haunts who might sign up for Buddhist Fiction, here's a partial reading list. I'd begin with a grounding, if via a suitably for me restless and sly selection: Glenn Wallis' deceptively titled "Basic Teachings of the Buddha". Its phenomenological gloss enhances its maturity and depth. Perhaps for comparison to our Western mentality, I'd next contemplate "Life of Milarepa" newly in Penguin classics, but did its Tibetan author intend it as fiction, or fact? Easier is the first, if stolid, novel written in English by a Bhutanese woman, Kunzang Choden's "The Circle of Karma" even though it reveals in the put-upon protagonist's exile in Sikkim and India its forced or willed encounters with greater impacts outside a Buddhist heartland, as she toils to build roads in.

After that, I fingered three novels as front runners. For historical context and mythic jumpstart, I'd start off with "The Dharma Bums" although I prefer the retrospectively cautionary tale within Jack Kerouac's massive messy notebooks as "Some of the Dharma". Not sure what to fill the shelf space between the Beats and those of us who've grown up after Beatlemania and the Maharishi. That generated earnest proclamations and aimless if inevitable babble-baby steps, but it may secure surely some "terton": a "terma" text tucked away as raw ore if not a "wish-fulfilling gem" for rediscovery.

As a pertinent detour, in college I found the opening chapter of John Nichols' 1981 (the novel slid downhill after) "The Nirvana Blues" a potent distillation of the Sixties' blooming bouquet and blowsy aftertaste for New Mexico's New Age. But, for those of us too young to remember much ("Sgt. Pepper" appeared the month that I finished first grade), how has Buddhism entered post-hippie or post-boomer, Gen-X fiction? Krishna-core via straight-edge punk inspired Eleanor Henderson's "Ten Thousand Saints", but my archival glances haven't led to a treasure-text Buddhist equivalent in fiction to Brad Warner's "hardcore Zen" or Noah Levine's "dharma punx". For those of us reared in less starry-eyed times, as a child during Aquarian dawn, I'd precede a pair of mainstream, millennial novels about folks entering middle age in what Wallis labels as "unease" compelling them to yearn for meaning-- Keith Kachtick's "Hungry Ghost" and Anne Donovan's "Buddha Da" --with titles where excerpts from these appeared, the short story collections "Nixon Under the Bodhi Tree", and "You Are Not Here and Other Works of Buddhist Fiction".

Speaking of this term, I then searched online to find a couple of helpful resources. I wanted to find a later 20th century work worth seeking out. First, via the suitably eclectic Unitarian Universalist website, Kimberly French's "Guide to Buddhist Fiction" (2010) provides all of the above--except Kerouac! So does the more scholarly project of a Canadian doctoral candidate.

Kimberly Beek's "Buddhist Fiction Blog"(2011-) goes deeper, reminding me of my own attempts via WorldCat to find such obscurities as Elsie Sze's "The Heart of the Buddha" in my own research on accounts of Bhutan. The outlier Xinran's PRC-friendly, Chinese bestselling view of liberated Tibet, "Sky Burial" shows the reach of Beek's investigation, beyond the expected Hesse. While I favor the late Joachim Neugroschel's skillful translation of "Siddhartha" as opposed to predecessors (check out his version of Sade's "Philosophy of the Bedroom" as an friskier adventure into palatial or carceral, half-mad erotica), I find Hesse's evocation too familiar via teens wanting a "short book" for a report. I have my hunches about why that German master titled it (obliquely, coyly, wisely?) the way he did.

For a book that will never be chosen for brevity unless by hapless teens who may then switch to the film for comparative if not cinematic concision, I note both Kimberlies feature David Mitchell's "Cloud Atlas."" I had wanted to read this years before the movie, and having failed for better or worse to lure my family to see it in the theater (we did choose with my paternal lobbying "On the Road" rather than "Zero Dark Thirty" for the 2012 birthdate of the Prince of Peace), and while I still know nearly nothing about it, a densely esoteric po-mo subtext encourages me, I had to hunt it down. It was checked out everywhere post-flick even if that tanked at the box office: I did enjoy it. At least it found a wider audience. From the library, John Burdett's wobbly but whirlwind mystery thriller "The Godfather of Kathmandu"  reminded me of Victor Pelevin's Russian box-layered tales to unlock. The Warchovskys might be suited for optioning Pelevin, from the sample that concluded "Nixon"'s entries that I'd admired. Suited for a mash-up as "The Master and Margarita" meet Neo.

Promisingly or dangerously, another far-out pick for the literati, from New Directions, appears on Beek's sidebar. Severo Sarduy's Maitreya (1978) suggests RuPaul's after-party preference for dharma bums. Not sure when I'll up for a tranny take on multiple rebirths, but seeing I've name dropped the Marquis, alluded to the Wachowskis, and touched on Pelevin, a logical progression or transgression. I think Lana's own transition--and she and Andy being raised as their Wiki entry notes by an "ex-Catholic turned Shamanist" mother--directs their own engagement intellectually and spiritually with visions they've channeled into film. The Wiki also credits Hindu texts with a key formative role.

Leads me to wonder about film tie-ins: "The Matrix," "Enter the Void," as well as "Cloud Atlas"? Ruminations after my own doctoral work a decade "in purgatory" spin me off another direction: "Jacob's Ladder," "The Truman Show," "Groundhog Day," "Fight Club," "Memento," and...? I confess avoiding any explications of such films as to relevance so as not to spoil my own quest. That'd be another exciting course to design and direct, combined with lively texts. Out of such musings, I recreate my own Nalanda, my own imaginary locale for entering the inner via the outer medium. I note a Wiki "Films about Buddhism" reveals no titles that look to have escaped the East.

Perusing Beek's list, I welcomed memories from some books from the exotic East via Western eyes which I've enjoyed: Kim Stanley Robinson's alternative history (what if the Black Plague had nearly wiped out Europe, so Christians did not conquer much of the globe?) "The Years of Rice and Salt", Roger Zelazny's phantasmagorical, "altered states" utterly-1967, Hindu (less so Buddhist) clash of the mega-titans as "Lord of Light", Rudyard Kipling's mostly calmer if rather tangential "Kim". (I've started J. Jeffrey Franklin's study of Buddhist reception in 19c Britain, which argues how "Kim" and other texts, factual as well as fictional, represented a "cultural counter-invasion" to Victorian verities.)

However, that trio--and others she includes--may touch more lightly on Buddhism than other influences. Western Buddhist fiction, placing themes within more mundane settings, appears to look within and sometimes pause at rather than plumb its subtler currents. Much as I liked the appropriate second-person voice dominating Keith Kachtick's "Hungry Ghost", that plot felt as if it yearned to loom as a Manhattan-to-Morocco thriller on the big screen. More placidly, Anne Donovan's "Buddha Da" nestles a Glaswegian house painter's shift towards practice within domesticated settings, but it falters in sustaining its tripled narrative perspective and its momentum. Translated into English last year, Bruno Portier's "This Flawless Place Between" unevenly balances the exotic Himalayan and the everyday urban encounters; it boldly depicts the (so-called) Tibetan Book of the Dead come to "life."

Two collections of short stories, one excerpting the first chapter of Kachtick's novel, the other Donovan's first, span the gap between their quotidian orientation and the more vivid or daring fiction that challenges perceptions and plunges the reader into more of the disorientation of Portier, if not quite Zelazny. It's disappointing that speculative fiction at least to my limited gaze has not produced newer imaginative applications of Buddhist thought, but these may lurk under New Age, fantasy, or inspirational categories, which I don't drift among. Blame my skepticism, and my impatience with what nears self-published uplift. That's why for all its colonial insistence, I preferred the energetic  mindset of Kipling, to my surprise. However, that gives way as Franklin follows, to more manifestations of globalization. Turn to two nets of tales plucked from big fish and small fry, grilled on the page to spice, savor, or taste. My appetite tends to roam and wander more than settle down.

Compared to its 2004 predecessor, "Nixon Under the Bodhi Tree",  "You Are Not Here and Other Works of Buddhist Fiction" 2006 anthology blends more little-known with established names in the Buddhist realm in the West. Its editor, Keith Kachtick, provided his strong opening chapter from his novel, "Hungry Ghost" to the collection of "Nixon" edited by Kate Wheeler, and Kachtick returns the favor with room for her long story, "Ringworm." It's not the only one among volume two's twenty entries to feel semi-autobiographical (at least), but it works as one of the best, as it evokes Burma through a Western nun's eyes---feeding a sick kitten--before one of many military crackdowns.

Many stories, or vignettes, in both collections failed to rouse me to stand up and cheer. Some contributors obviously were included for "marquee draw" from the American Buddhist pantheon of name brands. I do betray my own detachment along with my ongoing interest. I liked some authors lesser known but more ambitious or subversive. What do I want? Fiction as friction, afflicting the comfortable, as the Buddha's message meant to wake us up. The links to both anthologies reviewed reveal who roused me more. Any reader has his or her own reaction. My serpentine, spiraling nature regarding belief tangles me. I squirm with "unease" if pigeonholed. I try to elide denominational bias in my real-world "Contemporary Religions" (as I prepare to teach it again online tomorrow), which does attract the credulous, denying, or dogmatic, along with earnest pilgrims or ornery iconoclasts.

As for these titles, any uncredited links above to all but the unread "Maitreya" (my own reminder), take you to my Amazon reviews for in-depth critiques, and as another guide for online seekers. If you have suggestions for my imaginary course, let me know. Maybe it can reincarnate somehow as real.

Ultraculture.org: "Keep Calm and Enter the Void": Image credit.

Friday, August 2, 2013

Jonathan Lethem's "Dissident Gardens": Book Review




Radicalism rattles three generations in New York. Dissident Gardens dramatizes this disruption. Rose Angrush, her lover’s son Cicero Lookins, and her half-Irish grandson Sergius Gogan, when pushed far enough, fight conformity. How long they can stand their ground?

Rose lives in the Sunnyside Gardens housing project in Queens, in the decades when Reds were hunted.  In turn, Reds hunted those deviating from the Stalinist party line. Ostracized for not only her political stance but her affair with a married black policeman, Rose broods after the policeman leaves her and his son Cicero matures. Unhappily married to her own husband, Albert Zimmer, Rose bristles. She resents their daughter Miriam. Her late beatnik-early hippie days in Greenwich Village unfold as she and her husband, Irish folksinger Tommy Gogan, watch the Beats ebb and Bob Dylan rise. Their son, Sergius, will grow up to witness the 2011 advent of the Occupy Movement, as embodied in one girl half his age, in a tiny sit-in at Cicero’s own college town in coastal Maine.

Jonathan Lethem's family saga recalls Saul Bellow or Philip Roth’s urban intellectuals battling Jewish angst.  Fewer protagonists in Bellow or Roth, however, held out so long against capitalism. Embodied by Rose, her headstrong affirmation of an idealized communism which never happened leaves her adrift in the later part of the last century. Lethem’s characters reject their faith and traditions. They all pursue progressive causes. The Old Country offers no solace; neither does any affinity with a Chosen People. Whatever binds Rose, from a background in the ghettos and villages of the featureless Pale of Settlement, to Albert with his urbane German Jewish upbringing, remains attenuated and brief.

Filtered through the indirect, omniscient voice which dominates Dissident Gardens, Rose reflects on her marital and ideological discord: "Unlike every comedy ever devised by Jewish writers mocking class difference from the sanctuary of Hollywood, these were divisions that exactly couldn't be closed by the bonds of love. This wasn't ‘screwball, it was 'you're screwed.' Not It Happened One Night, but It Happened Never."

Assimilated vs. shtetl Jews, allegiance to Communist purity vs. hero worship of Honest Abe or Uncle Joe, Irish, African-American, and bohemian diversification of an American lineage: these tensions provide rich material for Lethem. Yet, this account betrays an awkward voice. For instance, "these were divisions that exactly 'couldn't' be closed by the bonds of love" may retain Rose's irritable opposition, but that stilted phrase sounds at odds with her earthy, frank personality. Lethem inserts his narrative voice into her silent reflections on her tetchy marriage, but Rose remains a brittle, grumbling protagonist. Her prickly, ornery self, until old age alters her wits, keeps her a dire, forbidding materfamilias.

Albert and Rose's similarly stubborn offspring Miriam; her partner and erstwhile Dylan rival Tommy Gogan; their drifting son Sergius; Rose's wayward nephew Lenny (short for Lenin); cranky, obese, and gay Cicero: all fight the power as America snoops on dissenters from WWII, through the Cold War and counterculture, then up around the East Coast, ten years after 9/11.

Letters by Rose and Miriam to Albert in East Germany and a quiz show transcript from contestant Miriam offer a bit of variety in prose and diction, given Lethem’s tendency to sustain an epic narrative style which elides distinctions for many key characters. It also grinds down much in a sprawling plot. That roams widely and at whim. In retrospect, its highlights linger longer than its addled protagonists. At his best, Lethem sharpens his gaze as he peers around the teeming streets he creates, so he can penetrate the hard heads of his blunt characters.

Tommy Gogan tries to break free of a Clancy Brothers-type of musical bond with his clan. Emboldened by his love of Miriam, he fears the leap away from his siblings will leave him, a solo artist with only one LP in him, having to compete with a rising folksinger in from Minnesota, who sparks a buzz in their beatnik neighborhood. Tommy predicts to himself his recorded fate: “A second album will never exist and Verve Records wants free of the contract and are willing to front you a suicide room at the Chelsea to be shed of you.”

That album fails, sunk by a review. At twenty-seven, Tommy observes with detachment both his own irrelevance and Bob Dylan’s electrification. “Dylan, having shrunken a whole world to his sole person, was terrified by the isolation.” Instead of fame, Tommy chooses activism, and with Miriam, they march on into radical causes, long past the Sixties. They tempt fate. So will their son, Sergius.  In their tales, as the energy of the era matches the passion of the characters, the novel succeeds.

Lethem invents affectionate scenes, often within his native city. Dylan’s arrival at MacDougal Street complements the Mets' arrival soon after at Shea Stadium. A figure nicknamed “The Last Communist” flees by subway from a conspiracy he may or may not have conjured up. Sergius’ anarchic quasi-Quaker school and Cicero’s tony, vapid Baginstaff College spur Lethem to sharpen his sly wit. Rose entertains visits from an imaginary Archie Bunker, which overlap with her lifelong veneration of Abe Lincoln. From East Germany, Albert documents the Allied bombing of Dresden. Other characters will blunder into an imminent Sandinista triumph.

Yet, nearly every character bent on reform suffers from self-righteousness. Impassioned speechifying veers into sit-com parody. Ambitions beginning wryly or in a quirky manner soon wind up for most protagonists and antagonists (interchangeable in many cases) as humiliating. 

Lethem may aim at social critique. Yet some set-pieces can feel rickety. Rose is called a “ziggurat”: so feared is her towering presence by so many. A symbolic scene when she puts her own head in the household oven to try to win an argument against teenaged Miriam lingers, but more as an author’s labored contrivance than a powerful vignette.

However, most of these earnest radicals earn sympathy more than satire by trying to better each other, and us. Rose laments to Cicero, who she mistakes in her dotage for Albert: “Capitalism wouldn’t get out of the way. We couldn’t breathe, we couldn’t begin to exist. It filled all available space.” That’s about as incisive as this narrative gets regarding the failure of alternatives to the present economic and political system. Lethem shifts any sustained discussion of ideology off-stage; he brings in casual asides and bitter (or parroted) comebacks. 

Lethem attempts to join the novel of critique with the novel of ideas. Characters think too much or act too quickly. Then, trapped by machinations, they find themselves too compromised to escape or outwit their many foes. Zimmers, Angrushes, Gogans, and their progressive comrades fumble. But they try to "speak truth" to power--and to themselves. This dogged impulse to argue and agitate for a better world, transmitted by nature over three generations or by nurture in “red diaper” nurseries, nags at these impetuous New Yorkers.(Amazon US 7-29-13; revised as above for PopMatters 10-9-13)

Tuesday, July 23, 2013

Patrick Lundborg's "Psychedelia": Book Review

Beginning three-and-a-half thousand years ago, unfolding over five-hundred closely printed pages and half a million words, presenting two decades of research, Patrick Lundborg explores "the world's largest mystery cult." Rather than reducing psychedelia to psychology or religion, he envisions a philosophy. His foreword explains how Edmund Husserl's theory of phenomenology melded his study of Aldous Huxley and hallucinations to trigger "several hundred pages of speculative thoughts." Inspired and intrigued by the elusive lack of a label for his pursuit, he provides two sections, corresponding with the two cycles of psychedelic culture.

First, the Eleusinian Mysteries of the ancient Greeks begin an historical magical mystery tour. Lundborg presents recent analyses pinpointing the catalyst for the storied inner journeys undertaken by a coterie of initiates. The Greeks brewed an infested barley-mint concoction which sparked hallucinations resembling those of ergot, refined by Albert Hoffman in the 1940s as LSD-25. Between these two events, part one unfolds the range of "an ancient culture".

In thoughtful vignettes integrating everyone from The Fisher King to Tiki-exotica musician Martin Denny, this delves into hundreds of figures who've established careers and courted notoriety by daring to leave their convention behind, by ingesting substances or immersing themselves in situations open to what Husserl's follower Eugen Fink summed up as "a wonder in the face of the world". This suggestive phrase invites us, I may add, to contemplate these terms: does the psychedelic adept make the "face" of the average human "wonder" as a few rebels depart the mundane "world" by experimental inner journeys? Or does such an adventurer witness the "world" in its true "face" through a burst of released, inherent "wonder"?

Bookended by old and new decoctions from barley's alchemists, part one sets up twelve chapters which crisscross the globe and time. Hoffman, Huxley, the McKenna brothers, Alan Watts, the Grateful Dead, Owsley, Tim Leary: while many names will be familiar as our near-contemparies, appearing as if characters encountered in a vast picaresque novel, the pace remains steady and the learning simmers into a satisfying, if thick blend. Best taken in small doses, given the small font and formidable size (one drawback: the paperback feels enormous, relegating its index to online access only), it's a solid resource on what's been too often left for silly flights of fancy or sophomoric pronouncements an ephemeral topic. Lundborg, as a diligent tour guide through psychedelia in theory and practice, keeps moving forward in time and space. But like his swirling subject, he cannot help pursuing byways, tracking trains of thought, and wandering off on rewarding detours.

Here's a sample of the range in part one: from Neoplatonism to Shakespeare's The Tempest; ayahuasca to DMT; Yeats to peyote; Blake to the first Western Buddhist Beats; Swedenborg to psilocybin; Forbidden Planet to Apocalypse Now. A handy index is missed, as the material can prove enormous to keep track of (beyond a thematic table of contents) as it accumulates, However, its gathering in a compendium enhanced by a blog and pdf index via the author's Lysergia website attests to his ongoing commitment to understanding this notoriously caricatured and misinterpreted subject.

To exemplify the depth of Lundborg's printed excursions, dip into a random page (288) to find a discussion of the 13th Floor Elevators' undeservedly obscure cult 1967 album Easter Everywhere, graced with nods to lyrical allusions to Robert Heinlein's arguably too-well-known cult novel Stranger in a Strange Land, and its predecessor for a previous century of exotic Western seekers, The Rubaiyat. Cymbeline and The Waste Land earn inclusion, to express the meaning of "dust" in on side two as a "life-embracing world-view around a word usually associated with death".

The second section examines psychedelia as "a modern way of life": it flows from preceding treatment of the explosion of interest in drugs and spirituality in the 1960s. Lundborg divides the ancient from the modern era in 1963: that concludes the "Scientific-Artistic Phase" and introduces the counterculture. Ken Kesey, Alan Watts, Allen Ginsberg, Richard Alpert, and Tim Leary's roles, familiar to many, find juxtaposition with now less celebrated proponents such as Ralph Metzner and the Diggers, who urged radical transformation given the freedom conceived via hallucinogens.

Concerning liberation, the political and spiritual ramifications of such advocacy, the author notes, did not always mesh well with imported academic theories-- or with other novel systems imported. Lundborg astutely warns of the fallacy of many "Western psychedelicists" to too "readily accept the religious-mythical label from a remote and highly complex culture as an explanation for a personal experience," when it comes to spurious applications of such texts as that popularized as The Tibetan Book of the Dead. From 1964, one recalls "Leary-Alpert-Metzner's generally useless guide-book" The Psychedelic Experience as illustrating this "presumed overlap". Instead, Lundborg urges one to enjoy without trying to bias or label the encounter within an esoteric mind state.

Later coverage roams into the rave culture, garage bands, stoner rock, shamans and chillouts, Ecstasy and DMT, and comparisons between LSD and ayahuasca. Philip K. Dick's attempt to describe his VALIS visions enters a chapter reflecting on--as one subtitle has it--"poetry, gibberish and eloquence" appropriately. Lundborg calmly tackles slippery subjects: how can a report on a non-verbal experience be rendered in print? Perhaps film, art and music (also treated here; a few brilliant color and sepia plates try to depict venerable and fresh adepts under the influence) may better capture the plunge or the flight.

Therefore, in challenging closing chapters, Lundborg posits a "Unified Psychedelic Theory" that charts the aftermath of "an effective dose of a major serotonergic psychedelic" on four levels of a "General Trip Model". This necessitates brain chemistry, multiple realities, and perceptions that defy facile reduction. The heft of this volume delivers the results.

Lundborg presents a "supra-state" which "birthed our consciousness" but which we don't rely upon for daily survival nowadays. Beyond this level, we can "poke holes through our common mindstate" so as "to peek into" a higher state. Enough of a dose, and "we may put our heads through the wall" and communicate with this state, which has accompanied us since we were born. On the final page of this massive, energetic, and reflective study, we find that this Stockholm scholar has barely nudged open what Blake, Huxley, and a certain rock band testified to as the "doors of perception". (Slightly altered state to Amazon US 1-31-13; as above to PopMatters 2-7-13)

Author's website: Lysergia

Saturday, June 22, 2013

"Selected Letters of Allen Ginsberg + Gary Snyder": Review

Having finished "The Gary Snyder Reader" last month, I wondered how this collection might illuminate some of the contexts as Snyder's wanderings across Beat San Francisco, early-'60s Japan, and back to settle in first Marin County and then the Sierras connect with Ginsberg's New York (city and then upstate) and West Coast residences. Both, furthermore, roam far as they become countercultural spokesmen. Early on, both found success, Ginsberg in the spotlight of course, and then, after his Asian travels, Snyder's poetry finding more recognition.

While Ginsberg's reputation earned him the headline role, Snyder's influence as this series 1956-1991 documents reveals him as the guide. Ginsberg's attraction to Buddhism appears more gradual, as Snyder had preceded him and nearly every other young (non-Asian or a few academics excepted) American. I looked for a pivotal shift to acceptance of Buddhism by Ginsberg in the letters, but it's occluded. Perhaps an early-'60s trip to Asia and extended visit with Snyder in Japan can be credited.

Yet the pull of the possibilities that expanded consciousness exerted on these eager seekers tugs early. 8/10/60, Snyder expresses disgust with American politics and foreign policy. "Bread and Circuses. No longer a problem of helping out American workers, but of giving up for the whole world welfare...will America ever choose to be a bodhisattva? and wear blue jeans and sandals before the world and give up her property? The 'orgy' has political and metaphysical significance." (31) I guess he got the fashion trend right, at least. Anticipating often this decade the inevitable triumph of socialism if not communism, Snyder fears its "one pair of glasses" as well as the capitalist insanity, and expresses nascent fears of climate collapse and economic inequality.

From Kyoto, writing to Allen and Peter Orlovsky in Calcutta 5/30/62, Gary notes that his Japanese buddies have turned hemp farmers. His future neighbor and rival for Sierra land control, Don Allen (soon to be Swami Kriyananda) appears: "Extremely interested in Buddhism" and the interest starts to spread among their circles. Snyder notes "two things going: 1. The individual working out his path by lonely self-enquiry and meditation. 2. A kind of social-sexual communal breakthrough, aided by drugs, dance, music, (meditation), etc. Now if we can reconcile these two and use them we can remake society utterly. (Cosmo-political project #1)" (55)

How close did these comrades come? By 4/29/66, Snyder maps out four steps to a "bodhisatva path": Zen's samadhi power to apply to love (-making) and turning energy into art as "one's work or craft" and through that into "Action politically" to make "the social happen, correcting and reforming, revolution, so that people will be good to each other and to nature, and come to have enough stock of good-humor, curiosity, faith, and bodhi to try" Zen. (80) It's as simple--or complex--as that.

On 1/7/73, Snyder--worried about the carpet-bombing of North Vietnam--quotes from a Chinese text to Ginsberg, by now trying to go back to the land himself near Cherry Valley in upstate New York: "After Niu-t'ou heard the teaching of Zen he gave up sitting all day in his cave and carried 300 bushels of rice to feed people thru a famine." (148-149). The engagements of both Snyder and Ginsberg with activism remain more as undercurrent, as they roam the milieu where campuses, writers' or monastic retreats, awards ceremonies, and media appearances especially for Ginsberg take precedence. There's a guardedness about some of this period, as with Ginsberg's asides more than details debates over Trungpa and also Tim Leary's 1970s activities. Between confidants, it's odd to me that there's not more to reveal here. The 70s on find both men settled into teaching and traveling.

I expected much more herein about Buddhism as a radical force for transformation, given the prominence of both men in the literary and cultural realms. Ginsberg does betray at one point midway a sense of weariness with lineages, lamas, and the Naropa disembodied poetics scene in the 1970s. Yet, despite the publisher's claim that this volume, edited by Ginsberg's archivist and chosen biographer Bill Morgan, it's much more filled with asides about such as controversial lama Chogyam Trungpa, lots of itineraries as both poets flew around the world to give lectures, attend conferences, and hob-nob with A-listers. Increasingly, the pages by the 70s demonstrate a telling alteration. The spiritual issues fade, and while Ginsberg does three times over the decades weigh in with critiques about Snyder's verse drafts, poetry itself occupies not much space. Instead, we follow disputes with the Swami, the building of the zendo, like-minded neighbors coming in to join Snyder, tax concerns over what became the Ring of Bone in the San Juan Ridge of the Sierras, and the more mundane negotiations of the two writers as they bought property and as Snyder established a "village-temple."

The "real work" as Snyder sums up this stage marks change. Ideas and fantasies took root in concrete and a community. While I continue to wonder why the two and their allies did not buy an old summer camp and convert that rather than move themselves (and this leads to hundreds more as the Swami's foundation and the zendo both drew more to settle in the region) into unoccupied space, Kitkitdizze does represent the fruition of their hopes for (one hopes a small-scale) return to nature and renewal.

The collection closes suddenly in 1995; no idea why the correspondence ceases nearly two years before Ginsberg's death. Morgan provides no editorial conclusion; his footnotes tend to be sporadic, explaining some concepts and people referred to but leaving a few misspellings of proper names in the letters and a few references stay too vague for a likely reader. The editor's light touch lets Ginsberg and especially Snyder converse without much interference; there's an index of those named.

Snyder and Ginsberg met in the "strong but reticent Bay Area poetic culture" in the fall of 1955. They, along with Jack Kerouac, managed to move that scene "into public light, with a deliberate intention for some sort of transformation, first literary and then social." In over 350 letters, it's intriguing to find how much of a legacy both young men, dropping out of grad school, left over the next half-century. Snyder typically sums up in his prefatory note their relationship of "mutual respect": "I made him walk more and he made me talk more." (ix) (Amazon US 5-16-13)

Thursday, June 20, 2013

Gary Snyder's "The Real Work": Book Review

After reviewing Gary Snyder's "Reader" and his letters to and from Allen Ginsberg recently, I wanted to learn more about Snyder's relationship to his adopted Nevada County and Northern Californian bioregion during the 1970s. This collection compiles conversations mainly from that decade with the counterculture press, his "East West" in-depth interview which delves deeper into his past and his vision, and an elaboration of his model of the ecological system reaching its climax and sustaining itself by 40% recycling at its steady state of flourishing.

Towards the end he applies this to a restoration of our "inner potential" as our own "sense-detritus" finds liberation by art, work, and creativity. This "fruiting" happens for Snyder throughout this anthology. Editor Scott McLean adds a preface and endnotes to supplement some of Snyder's observations.

Notable is his ability to see within the planet its capacity for our emotional rather than economic enrichment. "It's a problem of love: not the humanistic love of the West--but a love that extends to animals, rocks, dirt, all of it. Without this love, we can end, even without war, with an uninhabitable place." (4) This 1964 Gene Fowler interview captures his "power-vision in solitude."

Yet, he cannot sustain such alone. He returns from a Japanese monastic stint to California, and he eventually joins Gov. Jerry Brown's Arts Council to disburse funds. He believes in the public commitment of the poet and the need to work one's craft and employ one's hands to create.

He even envisions culture, therefore, with fresh eyes. He compares a university's English department to "a cardboard box that everybody throws every poetry magazine that comes in the mail into and says, 'Well, we'll look at that later. I haven't got time to read it now.'" The retrospective perspective of English, "looping backward as they go, and trying to connect" the present to tradition, to rediscover a Blake or a Melville, represents its own function and "truly tribal work," he adds. (63, Fall 1977 to Paul Geneson in "The Ohio Review.")

Such observations reverberate in a period where fewer praise the humanities: he warns of the difficulty that more and more we face as the liberal arts get jettisoned. Practicality, all the same, gets to be its own necessity, for Snyder compares in the five-day April 1977 "East West" interview the contemporary reality for a practitioner as contrasted with the state of monastic Tibet, a quarter of its population meditating, its class structure demonstrating "a byproduct of exploitation"--if someone else grows your food, this cannot be kept on "for a whole lifetime without somebody else having to give up their meditation so that 'you' can meditate." (96)

Therefore, Snyder insists on the poet's grounding in the real and the engaged. Yet I found the same distancing here as elsewhere from the impact of his entry into the Sierras and the attraction this sparked for his followers and friends to join him. "Tracking Down the Natural Man" with carpenter Colin Kowal, whom is to be assumed as one of those who moved there--expresses little worry about the population increase. I suppose Snyder figures he and his colleagues weigh less heavy upon the land.

Similarly, he harbors in these reflections about the nuclear threats and ecological breakdown less tension than in the essays he included in the "Reader" but this unease certainly persists in the interviews during the aftermath of the 1960s. Peter Barry Chowka continues in the "East West" interview to ask about Snyder's "Buddhist Anarchism" essay originally 1961, revised 1969. He reminds us how Buddhism as with Asia did not discover until the last century what the West had earlier: "that history is arbitrary and that societies are human." (101) Not being divine or natural creations, changes and choices can be made. For Eastern systems, compromises with power diminished critiques of state or nation. He elaborates how "World Religions" tend to prop up their societies, and even if they posit liberation, they give in to protect their sub-cultural enclave. Celibacy deepens this institution: it's renewed from the outside each generation, so a tribal accumulation of transformational energy passed down does not build up and threaten the social construct. A fascinating insight.

One final point merits notice in a talk that three-dozen or so years later demands attention. Responding to Chowka's question whether Snyder plays the disconnected muse, Snyder boasts that he worked "nine months on a tanker at sea and nobody once ever guessed I had been in college." (111) This sort of reverse snobbery, arguably logical, does enter parts of this as it has his other writings. Snyder's lucky to have lived his long life so applauded by so many, and he's labored to build on the land his dream. Whether this sort of stance makes him more admirable than his MFA counterparts in the seminar room and his acolytes in the academy remains, perhaps, open to debate.

The appeal of Snyder is that he comes across directly, a bit prickly but usually openhearted. He's eager to express his ecological philosophy and his poetic calling, but he's also mindful to place his vocation within his setting and his respect for nature. Without being sentimental or coy, he helps us to listen to and see our world better. (5-25-13 Amazon US)