Showing posts with label IWOSC. Show all posts
Showing posts with label IWOSC. Show all posts

Wednesday, September 26, 2007


IWOSC Panel: Book Reviewing

Gary Young had asked me to a Independent Writers of Southern California meeting held last spring where I shared my Amazon experience as a Top 1000 Reviewer with an appreciative and enthusiastic audience in the Valley. Last Monday, at the Veteran's Memorial Building in Culver City-- this time along with my wife who took the photo-- I returned by his kind invitation to talk to IWOSC members, this time along with Amy Wilentz, journalist, chronicler and novelist with expertise as the past Jerusalem correspondent for The New Yorker; Erika Schickel, a blogger, reviewer, and freelance writer as well as a first-time memoirist; Michael Dresser, a talk-show radio host who interviews writers; and Edward St. John, who reviews, admirably as he's limited to objective statements of about 300 words, for Library Journal.

Before a full house spanning two what we called in grade school "multipurpose rooms," not a chair to be found, the evening was ably moderated by the L.A. Times heir to the late Jonathan Kirsch, book reviewer and former editor of the section, Digby Diehl. He set the tone immediately when he lamented the diminution of opportunities-- at least in print and traditional media. The chains do not wish to advertise in local newspapers, and the LATBR has suffered notably, now up-ended with the Opinion section each Sunday in a soixante-neuf exchange of positions.

I've been reflecting on the issues raised in the hour-and-a-half roundtable. For instance, are we in Los Angeles neglecting the non-English speaking population? The statistics show 52% of local households do not use English as the primary language, so I wished I could have commented on this factor. Reading in the NY Times the other day of a Hispanic bookstore's closure, I wondered how an English-dominant press can acculturate an audience that simply does not choose a book in English, and even their own native language, to pass the time. The Blue Line that I ride may have supported my skepticism. I'd estimate 80-90% of the readers choosing Spanish that I see read "Hoy," the LA Times-sponsored giveaway paper, or a religious tract or Bible. At least half the riders at any given glance I cast their way drowse, chatter, listen to music, stare without any print to peruse at all as they sit on the Blue or Red Line.

I am not sure if the colorful circulars for markets count, or coupons, as reading a paper: these gain lots of eyeball contact whether as images to pass the time or impromptu seat covers. An audience member asked about the separation of African American books in stores. Diehl acknowledged the pros and cons of this, but I would support his consideration that such "niche" markets certainly appeared to meet a demand. The black riders on the Blue Line tend from the glimpses I can make out to read a local (often not the LAT) paper or a novel aimed at the black readership, usually women reading a woman writer targeting their own demographic. The times that I saw literature being chosen by apparently non-students (the same reader on different occasions) with Paul Roche's translation of Aristophanes and Ron Rosenbaum's "The Shakespeare Wars" (the latter reviewed by me here and you know where), makes its own case in my memory as the exception proving the rule. Mass-market paperbacks of the romance, fantasy, thriller, mystery, or SF categories predominate among the relatively few riders who pack a novel, from my perspective.

Also, along these lines of genre, the NYTBR this week expands its bestsellers to a third category, trade paperback, or "quality" (and pricier) fiction aimed at the more upscale customer. A page will be lost in the Book Review to allow for this feature. Surely, as I pointed out, this only plays into the bestseller ranking obsession I share in a small way in my Top 1000 perch with the writers listening to those panelists who boasted of their own ratings on Amazon. The competition, whether driven by Amazon, the chains, the fourth estate, Library Journal and the trade, or any other category in the reading and writing realm does intensify in our capitalist society where the arts have always had to appeal to the kindness of strangers more than the fellowships and grants and acclaim of patrons.

My own efforts to concentrate on lesser-known books and music decrease my own ratings, ironically. But, I try to apply Amazon or this blog as I teach: my vocation is to expose whoever you are, in my classroom or online or in person, to what I think, given my own narrow areas of favor and personal expertise, you'd like. I did mention my own experience teaching complex ideas to students with often first-generation college backgrounds, and/or immigrant status, and attempted to justify, if not praise, my own diligence on Amazon and elsewhere on the Net (where you ponder this) as extensions of my belief in the spread of literate discourse.

(After I typed this to set aside as a draft, I rushed off to teach my night class-- is not this term itself redolent of seventy-five years ago, CCNY and red-diaper babies turned intellectuals, neo-con or Yiddishists, Marxist or anti-Stalinist? Talking outside the room was a student of mine who in a previous course gave a term paper in form of recounting and summarizing a debate he'd hosted between members of his own family from Mexico about the pros and cons of illegal immigration. A year later, he nears graduation. Beside him were a couple others whom I did not know. But I recognized under one young man's hand the library book's picture of James Joyce. The Modern Library-Random House [speaking of our American equivalent to Penguin Classics and the old Manhattan duty of a publisher to bring culture to the masses] "Ulysses." I asked him if he was reading it. "For school," he agreed, adding he'd taken it at random but quailed after the first page. I sympathized, but had to assure him how "that's my favorite author" even before I rambled on. Urging him to go to the Robot Wisdom.com website for help of all sorts, and making him -- me the pedant-- repeat the domain name to remember it, off I dashed through the door for my three-and-a-half hour class all about "Brave New World" and reprogenetics.)

You never know, then, who you will run into. After the panel, I chatted with a woman preparing an historical novel on ancient, or at least pre-contact, Hawai'i. I admitted my lack of expertise but added the nails vs. food, native vs. sailor taboos that were both broken, and after the first Europeans left the Sandwich Islands, the shattering of the old ways led to civil war that destroyed the old order-- and this in the interim before the Western missionaries returned thirty or so years later. She was delighted at my knowledge, and told me I was the first person she'd told of her novel to that knew even this much about the topic.

Another man had a contract with U of Cal Press and was editing his architectural and cultural guide to U.S. Highway 99; a third writer with the fine surname of Redmond spoke of her spirituality interests; a fourth man told me of his series of ESL dialogues for foreign college students coming here who knew grammar well but could not speak intelligibly-- this was based on his experience with science TA's at USC. So, I was able to talk with each aspiring author a bit, as well as a woman who reminded me to be charitable in comments on the creative contingent, recounting briefly not only her own son whose film was slammed by the L.A. Times, but of her own show business career with "each of the Three Stooges." I assured her my son and wife would be delighted to know of her filmography. (And my father-in-law, gone now a week to wherever Moe, Larry, Curly, and even Shemp chuckle on the clouds, serenaded by Harpo.)

So, back to summarize: the panel tended to divide over a crucial function of reviewers. Dresser held that it was his business to help the writer sell books. I contended that I sought to help the reader decide to buy (or at least check out from the library) the book. Identifying as writers, Wilentz & Schickel disagreed over how much slack should be given a reviewer for a first-time novelist. Diehl tended to advise tempering justice with mercy for newbies, while Wilentz appeared eager to balance the ledger by slamming immoral, immodest, or indifferent writers especially if they dared to court fate by climbing the bestseller lists without due preparation in their labor and with doddering veneration of millions. They both reminded us, like St. John's own efforts, that reviewers do not choose the books they review-- a point often overlooked and the fundamental difference with my own eclectic choices.

Point well taken. But I'd add a coda that I wish I'd have thought of before. "The wit on the staircase," the bon mot that comes to mind too late-- after you've already stepped away from the dinner table's repartee. We did fill well the time on the panel, however. In the words of RootsWorld.com (where I review Celtic and Irish music for "the online magazine of the world's music" by his own invitation) editor Cliff Furnald that as he was told by another scribe: "you listen to a record differently when you have to buy it first." Same for books.

Thanks to the missus for the pre-panel snapshot; see her blog for snide comments about my "working class background" and more.

http://www.robotwisdom.com
http://www.iwosc.org
http://www.rootsworld.com"

Saturday, April 28, 2007


Dr. Francis Collins: DNA as God's Language?

I am mulling over posting this on Amazon (#743 at last count!) where about 380 people have already weighed in on "The Language of God: A Scientist Discovers Evidence of Belief" by the director of the Human Genome Project, Dr. Francis Collins. Despite the moniker he grew up with proto-hippies who had moved in the Depression to the Shenandoah Valley (where The Shakespeare Wars reviewed by me here and Amazon on April 23, the Bard's birthday I remembered only yesterday! Ron Rosenbaum describes how in the titular hamlet there a marvelous theater recalling the BlackfrC.S.Lewis, Christianity, DNA, IWOSC, Occam's Razor. Medieval Philosophy, ontological proof, Religion and Science, Theodicyiars in Elizabethan London hewed in Virgina anew out of raw wood, built due to the philanthropic campaigning and local labors under the goad of one Ralph Cohen). Raised without religion, he drifted into what he might have called "soft atheism," that is, not from any solid intellectual conviction against the existence of a deity, but out of convenience or not analyzing his true beliefs rigorously enough. Well, as a student in his twenties he read C.S. Lewis' classic work of apologetics, "Mere Christianity." Lewis, you may recall, also followed the same path as Collins; although the Inkling and "Kolbitter" of Oxford grew up in the North of Ireland, few recall.

This will likely be the only book that I'll ever read that I can verify outside of Holy Writ that Newt Gingrich, Robert Schuller of Crystal Cathedral fame, and Naomi Judd have also enjoyed; their blurbs appear inter alia before Collins' text, somewhat undermining its rarified content if not its appeal to the ordinary folks, who surely need Collins' appeal to science married to faith as much as whatever Pasadenaean recalled my copy via its public library, in-- let it be recalled-- that heart of CalTech and The Skeptic magazine-- sponsored in turn by Penn & Teller! In my review, I focus upon Collins' use of Lewis' own argument to prove that the universe could not have been created ex nihilo. Or, as I read Martin Luther's phrase today, "ex Deo nobis est, non ex nobis"-- in my poor version: from God we exist; nothing comes from ourselves.

Do you think I should post this review below? Or will it only be rated according to my reactions and not the merit of the review itself? A problem built-in to the rating system, as I told the IWOSC crowd earlier this month, given the limits of Amazon's binary, thumbs-up, thumbs-down limitations. I'd love to improve it, but on the other hand as we know, it's futile to discuss religion dispassionately. As the Good Book parable reminds us, "pearls before swine" might be my haughty reaction to the brickbats flung my way by Scopes trial fanatics and proponents of a ten-thousand year old planet.

If you have suggestions for fine-tuning my response below, let me know...

Kindly rate the "helpfulness" of this review by its contents and not your bias. On Amazon, it's not whether you agree or disagree with the author or the reviewer. It's whether the review contributes to your understanding of what you could expect from the book before you decide to read it. Here's my guidance.

I can see from previous reviewers that their own beliefs colored their reviews. Trying to avoid this bias for my own comments, I will try for objectivity. Perhaps I am an ideal reader for this book. I share interests in religion and DNA- informed "genogeography" that range widely. My review sums up the pivot of Collins' own conversion which he makes the basis of his defense of theistic evolution. Early in the narrative, Collins shares his inspiration when encountering C.S. Lewis's argument that our own benchmark for right & wrong that we seek within ourselves points to a Moral Rule that is a universal, a irrefutable attraction to the Good which is planted by a supernatural force outside of ourselves.

Whereas Daniel Dennett, in ""Breaking the Spell: Religion as a Natural Phenomenon" (also reviewed by me late last year; the book appeared at the same time as Collins' work), might counter that such a leaning towards altruism gives us oldsters a shorter shelf life! That is, we sacrifice ourselves, stop consuming valuable resources, and get out of the gene pool, once we've done our job and reproduced. We're driven towards saving each other even though it's inexplicable or irrational. Collins takes the kinder, ethical alternative that may explain why we'd jump into a lake and save a baby even if we risked drowning, for instance. Collins assumes this inborn unselfish quality we all would recognize-- even if we emulate its nobility only imperfectly-- is prima facie evidence of a supernatural design beyond our ken but harmonious with our spirit.

He cites Lewis: God's the architect. We live inside the house, looking at the wall or ceiling, but from our knowledge have no way to understand the mind of the house's architect. But, where Collins loses me is in his next step. He posits therefore that this Law of Moral Nature cannot be explained as cultural artifact (e.g. enhancing our appeal for mates or our status in the clan) or (contra Dennett) evolutionary by-product.

He supports his theistic claim with Lewis. He argued that "if there was a controlling power in the universe, it could not show itself to us as one of the facts inside the universe-- no more than the architect of the house could actually be a wall or staircase or fireplace in that house. The only way we could expect it to show itself would be inside ourselves as an influence or a command trying to get us to behave in a certain way. And that is just what we do find inside ourselves. Surely this ought to arouse our suspicions?" (Lewis, Mere Christianity, 1952, pg. 21 as footnoted by Collins.) I stopped at this passage and pondered. The rest of the book builds upon this citation.

I found Lewis' argument intriguing. Yet, it did not convince me. I needed Collins to slow down and make sure we understood what he was so impelled by, but Collins wanders off for the rest of this short book into other topics. I wished he'd stuck with the veracity of Lewis' theological proof. Otherwise, why devote so much of a book ostensibly on DNA to the God behind such intricate patterns underlying the fabric of life itself? Since Collins uses this architect example so prominently as the "prime mover" of his own soul towards faith, it demands to be taken seriously by his readers. Yet, is Lewis' metaphor as compellingly persuasive to readers as it was to a twenty-something Collins?

As with his discussion of his version of Rev. Paley's venerable watchmaker analogy, Collins seems to ignore the similarity between this sort of theodicy and Anselm's Ontological Argument for the existence of a God "greater than which nothing can be conceived." Aren't we still trapped in our puny human efforts of trying to explain the vast processes of billions of years? If we cannot get past 10 to the minus 43 milliseconds after the annihilating Big Bang, in the absence of our ability to delve further back, why does this "gap" for Collins give way to a belief in a deity who started it all? How does Collins or Lewis know that the universe demands the absence of its maker from what has been made? Furthermore, the chances of finding an intricate mechanism on a desert floor as if it somehow evolved on its own outside of an external designer may defy probability, but the appearance of the watch or our own amazingly nuanced universe seems not to me to prove an "uncaused cause" that crafted the watch or ourselves. Sure, it's nearly overwhelmingly probable, but there still remains doubt. Chance could have triumphed, this once.

The problem with the Lewis analogy that so convinced a young Collins is that it assumes that a deity cannot be present within the system created, or for that matter has to be outside of the universe for the system to work. But we are making the rules that our God plays by. How can we succeed with such hubris? His assertions of theistic evolution that we cannot fully comprehend then come down more to "it's all part of God's mysterious plan" than a thoroughly investigated and exhaustively defended proposition that will convince skeptics wondering if maybe we are results of the 1-in-50-billion odds of our evolution by non-theistic causes, or one universe among many.

Collins applies Occam's razor frequently, but the fact that causes should not be multiplied without necessity does not always mean there cannot be multiplied causes. Of course, this is a short book for non-specialists. Surprisingly few endnotes, by the way, The author does take pains to remain clear in his explanations, to his credit. But, for such weighty matters, this leaves theological arguments that underly his scientific claims open to charges that he gives too superficial a foundation for his DNA-as-language theory. It's difficult to reduce such complicated material into a few pages, and when he tries to place a defense of the central claims of Christianity on top of science and DNA, it's too many messages for too small a medium.

Collins slips into the simpler explanation: God started it, since the universe is too intricate for chance or unguided design. But this fails to convince. It reminded me of Anselm's medieval "proof" for God's existence. That is, Collins edges near an a priori claim. He dismisses the multiple universes or the "hey, it just happened despite the odds" alternatives for the Anthropic Principle with insufficient consideration. This section is crucial. The subject is enticing. Collins genially presents the commonsense approach: God set it all in motion 14 billion years ago. Engagingly as Collins writes at this stage, his presentation is too brief. He embraces the theistic model too quickly. Without taking the other two possibilities of the Anthropic Principle seriously, Colloins does not fully explore why we need to take for granted the divine clockmaker as the accepted argument for evolutionary processes that unfolded ever since the Big Bang. He too complacently invites a clockmaker to wind it all up and let it tick away. This is not enough to support his claims that the best of the three Anthropic Principle models must be irrefutably that of theistic evolution.

However, intermittently, Collins' book makes complex theological and scientific subjects accessible for the non-theological, non-scientific reader. But it moves too quickly. Collins has the ability to expose false claims made by those too credulous in namby-pamby childish conceptions of deities, as well as those scientists too dismissive of the claims that faith and reason can join to expand our knowledge of the universe.

But here he needlessly complicates his argument. As a Christian, I suppose Collins felt he must testify. But his appeal for religion and science thus weakens. He clings too closely to his own model of religion, understandably as a believer but too restrictively as a scientist who seeks broader ground upon which to allow diverse religious and determinedly scientific proponents to meet and exchange ideas. Near the end he brings Jesus and the redemption/ substitution/ resurrection in as essentials for the religious truth of his assertions. I wondered why he had to make the deity so specifically incarnate in Christ's role. He states that His intercession was necessary to pay the human debt for our misdeeds, but fails to ask why people have had to be under the thumb of such a petty and vengeful taskmaster as the version we know incompletely as Yahweh. Collins by his faith accepts this, but this cannot convince a reader who does not share his belief.

The Anthropic Principle that we evolved in a universe fine-tuned for our evolution into creatures capable of appreciating our existence in that very universe can be fascinating if to me at least still unprovable. Collins seems to think the odds are against any evolution without a kickstart by a Creator. This part of the book, however debatable, shows Collins at his most lively. Curiously, the part on DNA I found comparatively dull. Still, his appendix raises relevant points about the film "Gattaca" vs. a probable future, genetic predisposition vs. predetermination, and pre-implantation genetic technology that are all explained clearly and concisely.

Collins is very convincing in explaining the shortcomings of Intelligent Design. He neatly proves why the "God in the gaps" approach to inserting "then a miracle occurs" into the Great Chain of Being fails as science constantly progresses and what we once thought Providence achieved only through intervention has been found to have a perfectly rational scientific explanation. Here he is at his best, and the book would have been more consistently convincing if he had left off his own Christian witness and kept to what a scientist who believes in God can bring to the debate that Dawkins and Dennett lack, and what creationists and ID proponents remain ignorant about from his genetic discoveries. The strongest feature of this short study is Dr. Collins' ability to sum up the strengths of theistic evolution.He offers an appealing counterargument to Dennett or Richard Dawkins who claim perhaps too smugly that belief in God and endorsement of Darwin cannot co-exist.


Wednesday, April 11, 2007


Independent Writers of Southern California-- and me!

Gary Young runs-- at least up to this date, it seems-- at least part of this organization which, as you can see at http://iwosc.org lives up to its name. Gary invited me based on the strength of my Amazon reviewing and the fact I am foolhardy enough to leave at my Amazon Profile my e-mail. Not to mention that I live in Los Angeles. I had a wonderful hour earlier today to share with a couple dozen fellow writers with far more experience than I have, for they publish, and I trust that they (unlike me) get paid at least once in a while. They asked me, as practitioners, what I was looking for in my admittedly eclectic choices.

For books, how an idea percolates down from the rarified to the demotic, so to speak, engages me as a consistent, if silent, attraction. How does an idea like purgatory get to be inextricably woven into the consciences of billions of Catholics, and non-Catholics wishing or resenting such a liminal state, over centuries? This became my dissertation. I suppose a similar urge to span wide areas of knowledge and make them relevant drives my teaching and my thinking. I talk most of the time to students without any real liberal-arts background or inclination. To survive in such a classroom, and to keep myself honest, I have to translate what I read in some scholarly tome into popular terms. This means for me a broad familiarity with examples I can pull out and share within the give-and-take of discussion and presentations. My Amazon reviews often warm me up for deeper study when I sit at this keyboard, and over the years I have used this process to keep my intellect alert and my tendency to procrastinate in check.

I tend towards the neglected and overlooked album within my general fields of all sorts of usually lesser-known rock. I also search out Irish traditional or folk music. My emphasis, as I have come to realize after seven hundred reviews the past eight years (but the vast majority over the past three or four years), is in getting abstruse, academic, or arcane ideas across in an accessible fashion. In turn, this tied in, as a couple of respondents noted, my own tension between living here and wanting to be in Ireland, that sheer separation of utter oppositions, and the restless intellectual longing created by this shift that energizes my thoughts and choices.

This complements, as I explained to the IWOSC folks earlier today, both my own attraction to books and information (within which I can include film and music!) and my teaching career with vastly different students than myself, with whom I share perhaps only the unfamiliarity with growing up lacking a cultured bookish environment. Beyond that of my own making. Which is the reality behind the current buzzword of "lifelong education." I only wish my current teaching regimen allowed me and my students a wider range amidst which to roam.

Giving my modus operandi helped me clarify how reviewing helps my own critical acumen. I read with a few notes the better to concentrate the essence by a well-chosen quote the power John Banville can convey, despite his opacity elsewhere, in his fiction. I think as I listen to an album about the numbers corresponding to weaker or stronger tracks that I can comment about to back up my general impressions. Generally, and this is why my rating is relatively low, averaging perhaps 3.5 votes per posted review, I wander the hinterlands rather than the marketplace. The less common book or album needs attention on Amazon, not only the bestseller with 600 previous reviews, many a useless sentence of two of anodyne praise, exclamation-pointed contempt, or bland recommendation based on emotion. Or, in answer to another question, seemingly friends of the band or author. This is a delicate point, for Gary answered another writer's thought. She articulated a common thought for a room full of authors.

How to boost your ratings? Get your friends to chime in, sure, but beyond that, is there a Google-like algorithm that can be manipulated? He seemed to think that a concentrated barrage of queries into the Amazon keyword search as well as direct hits by name and title might do the trick, at least temporarily. Besides the mysteries of Eudora and concentrating your appeal to a list of your five hundred closest friends and that 1-2% response rate, it seems that for all the hi-tech we have thanks to this medium and Amazon's dominance over a significant part of cyberia that the elusive word-of-mouth or tap-of-the-key still works best, on as off-line, in the absence of agents and deep-pocketed publishers.

Not getting paid for what I read or listen to means more visits to the library, as I have to pay for the music. I do peruse other reviews in general that alert me to titles of interest, but I do not scrutinize published critiques before writing my own, nor do I study earlier posted reviews on Amazon before deciding-- given whether I can make a fresh contribution to the review thread or not-- to comment upon and rate a work. This does get frustrating at times as I think I have a lot to say after listening to an album or reading a fine book. Then, I log on to Amazon and find it's been said already, and there's not really any more to say. But, if I do post, building upon what others earlier have reviewed makes, I trust, my own contribution more meaningful. Still, as I lamented, the limit of five stars, the bias set up by "3 out of 23 readers found this review helpful vs. "567 out of 589" and the emotion that replaces analysis for so many reviewers, top or otherwise, limits the impact of the whole mechanism that Amazon uses to boost our egos and sell their products.

A couple of gentlemen asked me what I look for most in influencing book ratings. I told the first that for fiction it was continuity: so many novels-- take science fiction as the best example-- burst into life with great ideas but then fade into disappointment, confusion, or, as in one of the very first novels I reviewed ever, Mary Doria Russell's imaginative and often moving religious allegory "The Sparrow," duck away at in her case the very last page from the implications of the terrible vision that she had, for hundreds of earlier pages, brought into my imagination as chilling possibility and gripping reality. For non-fiction, I referred to academic collections by scholars, often a sorry compilation of their previously published articles with minimal if any scaffolding or internal consistency despite, say, a tacked-on introduction. Too few scholars rework and expand. Many cop out. They often say in their forwards that they have not gone back to rework essays since time has passed, they want to give their state of mind at that time, or they think that subsequent scholarship although valuable has not altered their original arguments. This may be true for some, but for others it reminds me of the lazy musician putting out yet another greatest hits compilation to fulfill their label deal.

A second inquirer asked again what at the start of the book draws me in. I answered, again for fiction as non-fiction demands and rewards different standards outside of a narrative arc, that the writer has to convince me that he or she can lure me into verisimilitude. That is, into the mind and soul and consciousness and body, or mixtures thereof, of a character (or characters) who I can recognize as true, as possible, as realistic in a basic sense that I can identify with who the author creates. I need to believe that despite thousands of years of written fiction, thousands of novels and stories that I have read already, that this novel or story conjures up anew what no other tale ever has before.

For books, in response to one man's question, I guess my choice averages about 70% non-fiction, around Irish topics, with forays into religion, current affairs, European history, Hungary and the Czech Republic, a bit of science if genogeography and DNA findings that further genealogy might be involved, and perhaps what I see at the library on the new books shelf.

Last weekend, at Glendale's library, I checked out in wild optimism six books. Ron Rosenbaum's hefty The Shakespeare Wars; Ken Bruen's newest Galway noir, The Priest-- probably the only mysteries I read, and not for the genre but the atmosphere; a Rough Guide 2006 to Ireland; the questionable but admittedly intriguing assertions by DNA genome project leader Francis S. Collins that such strands reveal The Language of God; Jesuit father James Martin's memoir that integrates hagiography with his own journey from Wall Street to the priesthood as My Life With the Saints, and, given my wife's insistent questions as she reads that Jane Kramer "The Pope & Islam" New Yorker piece, David Gibson's book on the first year of Pope Benedict's reign. The problem with new books is that once you check them out for the three weeks, you never know which if any or all will be recalled before you can renew them! So, I may not get through all of these so rapidly.

Back to conclude about my extemporaneous speech-- whose construction owed no little assembly to my Speech class yesterday as we studied that rhetorical mode with my talk in mind. See? I gave them credit as promised. Afterwords, George Hassan and I talked about the Shi'ite grip upon Persian freedom-- I silently admired his courage in wearing a baseball hat in properly Koranic green and white with the name of his book "Iran: Harsh Arm of Islam." Gary and his wife Cathy told me about their guide for those under 50 who have lost a spouse-- six million or so in our nation, not counting many more with partners. Sara Shai addresses a similar predicament of grief with her work on suicide. Peggy Miley told me of her grandmother coming over to NYC from Ireland with a five-pound note sewn into her dress. A woman named Bronwyn and I chatted about the book that I insisted that she has to read, all about Welsh-Irish encounters, the very obscure (at least to me before I stumbled upon it and surely must have reviewed it you know where) Minna Gallie's 1970 novel about the Troubles from a Welsh woman's p-o-v, "You're Welcome to Ulster." (I must write on this novel one day soon. Preferably before someone beats me to it, as is usually the case.)

Others, whose names I did not catch but to whom I gave cards-- with my blog address scrawled on as well-- also made me feel very at home. Perhaps I may expand my own interests and reviewing scope after the encounters I had? The range of interests that Amazon and libraries both represent on massive levels could be sensed among the few of us gathered in that small room. I thank all who welcomed me and shared with me and all of us in Encino today what I found a stimulating and enjoyable exchange of ideas.